Mobile Suit Gundam SEED Mafia - Game Over

[Majiffy]

Also I thought this was a large. How come I'm consistently arguing with the same 3 scumbutts and everyone else is just sitting around with their thumbs up their asses?

[Majiffy]

and there's no real confirmation needed

Certainly seems to be a big deal for Majiffy who doesnt believe he will kill who we tell him to kill.

*Usually kind of an MO for scum.

[NachoKoopa]

I'm not wagonning her to read her.

Then why are you wagoning her? Do you already think she's scum? Why?

I think she's scum because she's prod dodging hard and not even making an effort to skim around the posts when she does show up. She's been active elsewhere, it shouldn't have taken this long to get into the game. She's stalling.

I mean, do you?

I don't think that way.

also I'm pretty sure I have. what question haven't I answered about it? the name? i don't have one.

What is your suit's name?

Conspiracy theory obligates me to wonder whether this is indeed multi, where both scum factions have *anytime* kill abilities. The command wasn't dayvig, it was kill, which would support this marginally I suspect. So would x-shot.

This is a hell of a conspiracy theory.

Let me clarify: you are saying that Kalimar is looking pretty town.

Having just killed town.

Townies do the darndest things.

I still don't think Pie is the best lynch for today tho.

ArcAngel!

I EXPECT him to subvert site meta.

When you subvert site meta by giving scum a role like that, you don't fuck them over by putting another role that essentially counterclaims them.

Pie kills Talah.
Pie claims busdriven.
GG.

Then we lynch the living fuck out of him.

[NachoKoopa]

DeasVail, we're not lynching Majiffy anymore.

[Sakura Hana]

Also I thought this was a large. How come I'm consistently arguing with the same 3 scumbutts and everyone else is just sitting around with their thumbs up their asses?

And here I thought you were the busy one who didn't have time to post.

P-Edit: Ok Nacho, I can buy that

Unvote
Vote: AA9

[Majiffy]

Hi Nacho. Help me lynch obvscum pie.

[DeasVail]

DeasVail, we're not lynching Majiffy anymore.

Is he town?

[Svenskt Stål]

I hate these nacho posts. I hate that short reply to everyone approach, he can be scum too.

And yes Nacho, we are beheading Majiffy.

[Majiffy]

And here I thought you were the busy one who didn't have time to post.

I've functionally had three days off and it has been wonderful.

[Sakura Hana]

And here I thought you were the busy one who didn't have time to post.

I've functionally had three days off and it has been wonderful.

So everyone else also has three days off?

[talah]

Note to self: ask Majiffy why he re-ordered me in a lynch list a couple of pages back.

Whatever.

VOTE: AA9

[Majiffy]

And here I thought you were the busy one who didn't have time to post.

I've functionally had three days off and it has been wonderful.

So everyone else also has three days off?

I don't think this logically follows as an argument.

We have too many lurkers/non-participants in this game. Too many un-opinioned, quiet voices.

[Majiffy]

Note to self: ask Majiffy why he re-ordered me in a lynch list a couple of pages back.

Because DV is a scumbutt and Wayne had him too low on the list.

[NachoKoopa]

DeasVail, we're not lynching Majiffy anymore.

Is he town?

Yep.

I hate these nacho posts. I hate that short reply to everyone approach, he can be scum too.

And yes Nacho, we are beheading Majiffy.

You've played with me for... how long?

[Natirasha]

Oh I think I can and I think you know that I can.

*cough*

Swinginess does not make a game bad or imbalanced. It just makes it swingy. I can point out numerous games that could be considered 'swingy', but also were considered fun & balanced by the players.

I EXPECT him to subvert site meta.

When you subvert site meta by giving scum a role like that, you don't fuck them over by putting another role that essentially counterclaims them.

...fair enough.

[DeasVail]

DeasVail, we're not lynching Majiffy anymore.

Is he town?

Yep.

I've been worried about that, but I'm still a bit hung up over him being so scummy earlier, and I could still see his recent posting coming from scum. Is there a reason why I shouldn't be thinking this?

[Majiffy]

DeasVail, we're not lynching Majiffy anymore.

Is he town?

Yep.

Hi, welcome to the game. Glad you could finally join us.

Swinginess does not make a game bad or imbalanced. It just makes it swingy. I can point out numerous games that could be considered 'swingy', but also were considered fun & balanced by the players.

If a faction can win or lose solely based on a single player's competency of a role mechanic, you're gonna have a bad time.

[waynegg]

Note to self: ask Majiffy why he re-ordered me in a lynch list a couple of pages back.

Whatever.

VOTE: AA9

Scum claim. Bus choice.

[Natirasha]

If a faction can win or lose solely based on a single player's competency of a role mechanic, you're gonna have a bad time.

By that logic any game with a vig or cop is imbalanced? A mafia team can just lose if the vig hits scum with every shot.

[waynegg]

DeasVail, we're not lynching Majiffy anymore.

Is he town?

Yep.

I've been worried about that, but I'm still a bit hung up over him being so scummy earlier, and I could still see his recent posting coming from scum. Is there a reason why I shouldn't be thinking this?

Umm...null. Isn't that pretty much the definition?

[Majiffy]

If a faction can win or lose solely based on a single player's competency of a role mechanic, you're gonna have a bad time.

By that logic any game with a vig or cop is imbalanced? A mafia team can just lose if the vig hits scum with every shot.

If it's an unlimited shot vig, yeah. That's why you make it even/odd night, or x-shot.

Which only supports my argument that two vig types (with one unlimited) on the same alignment is unbalanced.

Cop was a ridiculous addition to your position. Incompetent cops get innos which don't hurt and competent cops are easily stopped by roles such as millers, godfathers, framers, etc.

[Natirasha]

If a faction can win or lose solely based on a single player's competency of a role mechanic, you're gonna have a bad time.

By that logic any game with a vig or cop is imbalanced? A mafia team can just lose if the vig hits scum with every shot.

If it's an unlimited shot vig, yeah. That's why you make it even/odd night, or x-shot.

Which only supports my argument that two vig types (with one unlimited) on the same alignment is unbalanced.

Cop was a ridiculous addition to your position. Incompetent cops get innos which don't hurt and competent cops are easily stopped by roles such as millers, godfathers, framers, etc.

Actually you just proved my point with your addition. If you design your setup around the fact two vigs are in the game(scum doc, bulletproof, roleblockers, etc) you can balance the setup and make it less swingy.

[Majiffy]

Which is why I'm asking you how you would balance a game with an unlimited-shot nightvig and an x-shot dayvig on the same alignment.

And saiyng "scum doc, bulletproof, roleblockers etc" is not an answer. It doesn't address anything.

[DrDolittle]

jiffy's arguments actually make a lot of sense.

[DrDolittle]

he still could be scum though.