Mini 1500:Narnia- The Lion,the Witch,and the Wardrobe Mafia

[projectmatt]

vote: hermy

We're doing this today. Yesterday you guys were stupid and ignored the blatant mafia so maybe today we can actually, you know, go for it. Don't lynch Broken Aquarium. This is happening. Today.

[projectmatt]

Other mafia are probably in Killerjester/Skelda/JKLM but I'm not as sure in those. Whatever. Hermy is getting lynched today and I'll strongarm and yell all day until you guys vote with me.

[JKLM]

I've over looked hermy hobestly so I'll look into that

[mozamis]

@Moz can you link us to the game were JKLM is town and acting like this.

I looked at a game where Jk was scum - Room of Doom maybe? - and his play here is a just much more confident. Check it out, he's completely different.
Yeah I avoided the BA thing since its just gonna be WIFOM, which I assume is what scum want. People should just ignore it and judge BA on his record yesterday, which IMO was pretty town.
As for the NK, I'd say I assume they just thought Bro was a safe kill, no trail of blood leading back to anyone - Alienbro wasn't very vociferous in his supicion of anyone.

[mozamis]

vote: hermy

We're doing this today. Yesterday you guys were stupid and ignored the blatant mafia so maybe today we can actually, you know, go for it. Don't lynch Broken Aquarium. This is happening. Today.

Yeah, nice open mind...Really trying hard to look for scum, aren't you? You've been tunnelling on her pretty much all game. Has NOTHING else happened in the game to make you look elsewhere?
I mean, could there BE a more obvious mislynch candidate than Hermy?

[mozamis]

I'll strongarm and yell all day until you guys vote with me.

How about some analysis rather than just assertion?

[projectmatt]

vote: hermy

We're doing this today. Yesterday you guys were stupid and ignored the blatant mafia so maybe today we can actually, you know, go for it. Don't lynch Broken Aquarium. This is happening. Today.

Yeah, nice open mind...Really trying hard to look for scum, aren't you? You've been tunnelling on her pretty much all game. Has NOTHING else happened in the game to make you look elsewhere?
I mean, could there BE a more obvious mislynch candidate than Hermy?

Yeah, the guy who got lynched yesterday was the mislynch candidate but you guys didn't realize it until after you killed him, did you? Hermy is the mafia. If he was the mislynch candidate there would be little to no resistance on her but yesterday just about NOBODY joined me on my wagon.

I will give you analysis but my analysis means nothing if you guys aren't going to listen. I'm telling you all to connect the dots that Hermy = scum and vote with me.

[Skelda]

So I've come to a conclusion.
There are only a couple of reasons to silence players:
-to shut a player up that's making good points
- to create false suspsicion on player to get town to mislynch
-to let scum silence themselves as an excuse to bot be lynched for the day


It is the third one as a result of process of elimination. Here is why:

It can't be the first because look at his ISO. BA has made no arguments or accusations outside of what other players have said. There is no way he could have caught onto scum because he hasn't made any unique cases that would warrant him as the one to be silenced.

It definitely isn't the second reason, why? BA had a wagon in his own right throught the end of day 1. If scum wanted to stage a mislynch and BA was town, he would have cursed himself into being lynched himself. He only got SCUMMIER by the second and mos people were starting to scum read him.

By POE the third point is the only logical thing that would cause scum to silence BA.

VOTE: BA

And that's that.

Case closed. Good huddle guys. Let's get him.

Or maybe you killed him so you could push him due to his being silenced? We don't even know if Mafia members can be silenced, although I assume they can be. But bringing that up seems horribly scummy, since I think BA being silenced was a failed attempt at making him look suspicious.

Anyway, I'm not entirely opposed to the Hermy wagon. A Hermy-JKLM team wouldn't surprise me in the slightest. Although, I do agree that this JKLM sounds different from his scummy one that I knew, so he has either become a much better scumplayer miraculously or he is town here. So I'm keeping an open mind...

And I'm definitely not as sure about Hermy as, say, projectmatt, so I think I'll hold my vote for now. She's collected a nice hunk of pressure without it.

[RachMarie]

hmnm will do some ISO research and check the VCs, see if I can get a better handle on this game.

[JKLM]

Skelda, one don't put actions in my mouth. This would be a stupid tactic for scum to do by silencing a person and then calling themselves out on it, you know I'm not only not that ballsy but I'm also not that stupid.

Two, silenced usually make people less suspsiscious anyways, so in order for your logic you'd have to actually beleive my argument that silencing of BA was done for a very specific purpose. If BA was going to be a mislynch target, they wouldn't have silenced him, based on the fact that BA had bough people on his tail and honestly him talking a bit more deal his fate of a lynch. He would have out himself in, so scum silencing BA would have been useless an a waste of a night action.

[PeaceBringer]

Going after BA at this point would result in a lynch without words. Not wise...
Looking at things with MD as town is interesting.
not gone back enough yet to pull thoughts and won't tonight.

[projectmatt]

I'm going out of town for the weekend.

V/A until Sunday

When I get back, I expect to see Hermy either LYNCHED or at L-1. Do not disappoint me, please.

[smargaret]

I'll sheep that.

VOTE: Hermy

[JKLM]

We can't really KYNCH BA today unfortunately (peace is right) so I'm gonna have to move my vote

I'm lazy right now and hermy is kind if a toss up

Sooooooo

VOTE: Hermy

Very lazy I know

But idont have any other reads that seem to be irony out for me

[Garmr]

UNVOTE: Hermy

What the fudge how the hell did Hermy get to lynch 1 already. It's barely been a page on day 2 everyone hasn't posted and so close to lynching. I really don't like that.

[JKLM]

Oh whoops somehow I thought it was at l-2 when I voted

Well it is now so I'm fine with pressure cooking him

[Broken Aquarium]

hmnm will do some ISO research and check the VCs, see if I can get a better handle on this game.

UNVOTE: hermy
VOTE: rach marie

>>BA, youre not allowed to QUOTE. I ll pass this but next time be careful. your posts can't be more than just vote. <<

[Garmr]

BA are you allowed to quote.

[Broken Aquarium]

UNVOTE: rachmarie
VOTE: garmr

UNVOTE: garmr
VOTE: rachmarie

[Garmr]

I'll take that as a message to me. Maybe you don't know oh well. Also has anyone argued Rach Marie's slot yet. I think honig was pretty town but he didn't really add much to the debate. It was more a gut read on him with his frustration and all. But Rach hasn't contributed much either she's had at least 100 posts to catch up. Yet she didn't really offer any of her opinions about the first couple of pages ect. Through this may be due to real life but i still want her to give some in depth posts. Town dropped to null.

Also Killerjester reason for voting Moz were the weakest now I start looking back on the wagon. 283 he mentions having other points but he doesn't list one, Even if he agree's with anoter's case you'd think he would list the post. That and Shane didn't offer any great scum hunting feats when he was alive his Moz is scum no wait his town because he was being serious thing is questionable but since his not in the game he can't really defend himself so just going to be focusing on KJ end day game.


VOTE: Killerjester

[mozamis]

I'll sheep that.

VOTE: Hermy

What the "fudge", as Garmr would say, is this?

VOTE SMARGARET

[Garmr]

Well we have a list of Potential scum for today if we exclude the the BA mute for today. I think we should investigate it more in depth tomorrow but with out any knowledge it may just end up one big wifom fest and probably will be a great day for scum. Just some quick thoughts and probally the last I say about it. No matter BA's alignment through it is a major slip up for scum If BA is town they pretty much wasted a silence as he was mislynch material and If BA is scum they would of brought BA under the spotlight either way once we figure out his Alignment It will be a big blow against scum as we can see his interactions.

Still through my thoughts remain the same.
KillerJester>Smargreat for a lynch today.

Hermy's still suspicious but so was that quick wagon on her.

[PeaceBringer]

reading over Alienbro I think Rachmarie is the top canidate

vote rachmarie

[JKLM]

I'll sheep that.

VOTE: Hermy

What the "fudge", as Garmr would say, is this?

VOTE SMARGARET

Hey you forgot that I was even lazier

ALTEAST pretend like you're not skimming this board for easy to make cases

vote Mozamis

[ArcAngel9]

VCA is coming