In post 6123, penguin_alien wrote:
If you don't think red has the roleblocker, you say blue has the roleblocker. Why wouldn't blue have blocked ThAd when he was saying he would shoot CTD?
Maybe you thought that ThAd wouldn't shoot CTD after everything that happened. Maybe you thought CTD would be protected, since I was pushing for that. How am I supposed to know? I'm more curious about why Rena was blocked, since that would suggest a ThAd kill, but yet ThAd was left alive.
In post 6125, Nachomamma8 wrote:
In post 6122, Bulbazak wrote:Ok, so you must think he's blue scum if you're going with uneven scumteams and a powerful red team. Is that the case, or are you just keeping your options open?
Uneven scumteams, Peregrine is town.
So you changed your mind in less than a minute? If that is the case, why were you still pushing PV-scum while pushing uneven scumteams?
In post 6125, Nachomamma8 wrote:
In post 6122, Bulbazak wrote:I thought you were going with uneven scumteams and red having a roleblocker. Wouldn't red just block the other team then?
If uneven scumteams, there would be one scum left for each side.
And? You're not answering my question.
In post 6125, Nachomamma8 wrote:
In post 6122, Bulbazak wrote:But then he comes back from V/LA and the first thing he does is...role the dice to see who to vote in Lylo?
You keep saying it's LyLo. It never has been LyLo. Rolling the dice was mostly a joke.
Fine. It's Mylo. Same thing. If we mislynch today, we lose. Why would you randomly vote in that situation?
In post 6125, Nachomamma8 wrote:
In post 6122, Bulbazak wrote:Then he says that Ninja + Roleblocker is not as powerful as Doctor + Tracker. Why not? One side has an investigative immune role and a blocking role, while the other has a protective role and an investigative role. Not to mention that the blocking role can interfere with the protective and the investigative role AND the NK. So why is that combination less powerful?
Why does that deduction make me scum?
Come on, Nacho. It's a pretty glaring hole in your theory. If I can think of it, surely it occurred to you when you came up with the idea. As I said, the uneven scum team idea is a way for you to distract the town from your team so that you can score the mislynch you need.
In post 6125, Nachomamma8 wrote:
In post 6122, Bulbazak wrote:Then he states that blue can just kill red tonight, when he has just gotten done saying that red has a roleblocker. How does that work? Couldn't the red just block the blue and control the tempo of the game? Why have you forgotten this? This should be a major consideration in your theory. You can't have "There is a very small, very powerful red team." and "Well, blue can just kill the red tonight if we miss." In a game this small, chances are that red will be able to successfully block the blue kill.
All of this is invalid once you realize the difference between the two theories.
In post 6122, Bulbazak wrote:In a game this small, chances are that red will be able to successfully block the blue kill. Then he says that PA and I are scum, but are on opposite teams. But didn't you just say earlier that PV was scum? What happened to that? Again, you can't have it both ways. Seriously, this theory has enough holes in it for it to qualify as a Swiss dairy product. This theory only serves as a way to distract everybody from Nacho's team and allow them to walk away with the win.
See previous.
I don't know what you're getting at here. Please explain, because it seems to me like you are avoiding the issue.
In post 6126, Nachomamma8 wrote:I also like how you immediately jumped on me due to this misunderstanding instead of questioning a bit in order to understand better.
That's what I started to do, but while putting together the post, everything just kinda clicked for me. It made no sense that you'd be pushing this case as town. Therefore, I added the breakdown and reads at the end.
In post 6134, Ms Marangal wrote:
I think he's bussing Nacho, explains why he's voting him over me when he apparently has a stronger read on me
I actually saw your vote while previewing my post. What do I care if you're choosing to bus your buddy? I actually don't care which of you we lynch today. You're both red scum.
In post 6136, ffullisade wrote:I think bulba's a role blocker. I think PA knows it. because of her team - maybe her - getting blocked last night.
Where nacho fits in is less clear to me. But if I'm right about bulba role blocking and Nacho is right about 1 red scum, assuming we mislynch town today, then one townie will die tonight and tomorrow will be 2-1-1. And the game is unwinnable for town even if we lynch scum tomorrow.
If there are 2 reds, then it's possible that it will be a scum who dies tonight and then it will still be 2-1-1 tomorrow and unwinnable unless they shoot each other tonight. And if there is a roleblock two shots won't happen.
If we have 1 red, then Nacho probably isn't it.
I feel like we have to lynch between bulba and PA today and hope for the best.
PA's vote on bulba supports this scenario, I think.
Um...what? I think I got lost somewhere in the middle. Can you break this down for me in simpler terms?
