Mini #406, Animaniacs! Water Tower Explosion! [Over]

[HurriKaty]

unvote, vote: chamber

guess who caught scum?

Please explain. Do you mean, "I'm a cop, I got a guilty investigation", or "THAT GUYS SUSPICIOUS."

[Fritzler]

unvote, vote: chamber

guess who caught scum?

Please explain. Do you mean, "I'm a cop, I got a guilty investigation", or "THAT GUYS SUSPICIOUS."

definitely the latter

[Foolster41]

I asume you mean because he's lurking (Annoying, but not not he's not nessicerily paying attention to the game) since he hasn't said anythgint in a while.

I would like to see a

prod: chamber

though I don't think this is as certin or a big "revelation" as you make it sound.

[Foolster41]

Bah. What I meant to say in that perenthisis is that it's not nessicerily "proof" he's scum, he could be away or just forgot about the game.

[VitaminR]

unvote, vote: chamber

guess who caught scum?

Please explain. Do you mean, "I'm a cop, I got a guilty investigation", or "THAT GUYS SUSPICIOUS."

definitely the latter

Why do you think he's scum?

[Fritzler]

unvote, vote: chamber

guess who caught scum?

Please explain. Do you mean, "I'm a cop, I got a guilty investigation", or "THAT GUYS SUSPICIOUS."

definitely the latter

Why do you think he's scum?

FOS: vitamin╚

stop protecting your scum buddy

[petroleumjelly]

They're Ani-mani,
Totally insane-y,
Hunchback of Notre Dame-y:

ANIMANIACS!

These are the Facts:

Blake Judge – 1 – JDodge
Chamber – 1 – Fritzler
Fuldu – 1 – VitaminR
mole – 1 – Thesp

With

10

alive, it takes

6

to lynch!

Not Voting – 6 – Blake Judge, chamber, Foolster41, Fuldu, HurriKaty, mole

Mod Note: chamber has been prodded.

[Foolster41]

If you don't have proof, then pushing for a claim is going to be BAD for the town, fritz. I know this is what you do and all, but I'm having serious doubts it's best for the town.

[Thesp]

Still here, still happiest with a mole lynch.

[Foolster41]

I still think thesp's reasoning against mole and Vitiman's reasoning against Fuldu are weak. Dito for Fritz's attack against chamber. Is this day 1 again? I'm going to do some rereading.

[Foolster41]

ok, back.

I intended that statement as a threat, to state that I intended to use my vote against him if he did not explain himself.

See, you say that, but I think you just wanted it to look that way. You made it clear that he needed to say something other than what he was saying. It looked like cleverly disguised in-thread scumhelp to me.

Sounds patenetly paranoid and is very bad logic.

VitaminR: From what I've seen of chamber, he has an unusual playing style. Also, I doubt scum would just announce their intention to lurk if it was a significant decision.
JDodge: So if someone admits to doing something, they're automatically cleared of being a suspect?
Vitanman R: Yes.
This is classic WIFOM, and is also very bad logic.

Vote: Thesp

for being slightly more scummy than VitimanR

[Foolster41]

Sorry. the top quote should read:

I intended that statement as a threat, to state that I intended to use my vote against him if he did not explain himself.

See, you say that, but I think you just wanted it to look that way. You made it clear that he needed to say something other than what he was saying. It looked like cleverly disguised in-thread scumhelp to me.

[Fritzler]

unvote, vote: mole

[Thesp]

ok, back.

I intended that statement as a threat, to state that I intended to use my vote against him if he did not explain himself.

See, you say that, but I think you just wanted it to look that way. You made it clear that he needed to say something other than what he was saying. It looked like cleverly disguised in-thread scumhelp to me.

Sounds patenetly paranoid and is very bad logic.

...

Vote: Thesp for being slightly more scummy than VitimanR

I'm not sure you're considering how Sailor Jerry got figured out on D1. I'm also not sure why in the world you're thinking I have bad logic, and am unsure what you mean by paranoid. (I am under the impression that there are at least 2 other scum out there, so in that sense, I am somewhat paranoid, is that a fair assessment?) Please clarify your position before I take you to task for your loose use of the word "logic", which is being thrown out farr too much nowadays, and the definition is being trampled underfoot.

[Foolster41]

I guess what I mean is what you said sounded to me like you were saying his statement was "Too town to be town." That is what I meant by bad logic. Was this what you were basically saying about the statement?

[VitaminR]

VitaminR: From what I've seen of chamber, he has an unusual playing style. Also, I doubt scum would just announce their intention to lurk if it was a significant decision.
JDodge: So if someone admits to doing something, they're automatically cleared of being a suspect?
Vitamin R: Yes.

The last comment was a joke. I should have made that clear!

I thought JDodge was misrepresenting my logic so I responded with a joke.

I just think that the advantage in lurking for scum lies in slipping under the radar. If you announce your intention to lurk, the advantage is lost. You're actually making it more difficult for yourself.

As for my Fuldu vote, I do feel we're still in a Day 1 phase, basically. It's primarily gut.

Hope that clears things up!

[Thesp]

I guess what I mean is what you said sounded to me like you were saying his statement was "Too town to be town." That is what I meant by bad logic. Was this what you were basically saying about the statement?

Goodness, no. I'm saying he was trying to act as though he was suspicious of Sailor Jerry, but trying to give Sailor Jerry a chance to redeem himself from an intensely scummy action. In and of itself, it's not

that

bad, but now that we know SJ is a confirmed group-baddie, it's pretty condemning that mole tried to give him that out.

[HurriKaty]

As for my Fuldu vote, I do feel we're still in a Day 1 phase, basically. It's primarily gut.

... So wait, Sailor Jerry managed to get lynched Day 1 on "gut"?

[VitaminR]

Erm... no...

[Foolster41]

Hmm.

unvote. [?b] I guess that makes sense I'm not sure I exactly agree that what mole said was scummy, in my mind I can see either side saying the same thing.

[Foolster41]

bah.

unvote

[VitaminR]

As for my Fuldu vote, I do feel we're still in a Day 1 phase, basically. It's primarily gut.

... So wait, Sailor Jerry managed to get lynched Day 1 on "gut"?

Right, I get what you mean now.

No, but I do think 'gut' votes are justified at this point. SJ got lynched so quickly that we don't have that much info, really.

I do think these are the scum:

chamber - too lurkish for his normal lurkish self + I trust Fritz's judgement.
Thesp - metagame reasons mostly, when he's town he goes out of his way to ask questions, test theories and clear people. As scum he just pursues people ardently. I think the latter is happening in this game.
Fuldu - for reasons already given.

But I don't really have enough evidence.

[Thesp]

SJ got lynched so quickly that we don't have that much info, really.

Really? I think it gave us plenty.

FOS: VitaminR.

Mod:

Can we get activity prods on anyone who hasn't posted in the last 72 hours? Thanks!

[VitaminR]

SJ got lynched so quickly that we don't have that much info, really.

Really? I think it gave us plenty.

FOS: VitaminR.

Why does that make me suspicious?

It hasn't stopped me voting or explaining my actions. I've mostly used it to undermine my own vote.

[JDodge]

Sorry for the inactivity, I've been super busy; I'll reread as soon as I have the time.