Mini 396: ChatMafia Mafia; GAME OVER

[Jack]

I still don't get it though. Angus is the most likely to be scum lynch I've ever seen outside of a cop investigation, way better than most lynches, I don't see why you're unwilling to lynch him. Most lynches are done with far worse evidence.

[ChannelDelibird]

The

entire

basis of the lynch is that the lack of a picture in the morning. I've seen more experienced and active members miss night choices before. It's not the nailed-on scumlynch you're making it out to be.

[Jack]

The

entire

basis of the lynch is that the lack of a picture in the morning. I've seen more experienced and active members miss night choices before. It's not the nailed-on scumlynch you're making it out to be.

You said you thought he was scum multiple times earlier. Now you keep trying to play it off like pushing for his lynch is scummy. This is ridiculous.

I name-claimed last post if you missed it.

[ChannelDelibird]

I've said he was scummy. I've never said that I was as sure as you are.

I saw the claim, not sure what to make of it. Doesn't look like a fake claim, but I have no idea whether a Jar of Dirt would be a possible scum role. I'll probably reserve judgement until the full claim, when it comes. (I think when > if at this point.)

[Jack]

It's from PotC. I don't see how it could possibly be a scum role.

[Zindaras]

Ooooh,

that

jar of dirt.

The jar of dirt in Pirates of the Caribbean never made its allegiance clear. A jar of dirt can be used for evil just as easily as it can be used for good.

[Jack]

Ooooh,

that

jar of dirt.

The jar of dirt in Pirates of the Caribbean never made its allegiance clear. A jar of dirt can be used for evil just as easily as it can be used for good.

You admit it isn't inherently evil then? Do you still honestly think I'm more likely to be scum than angus?

[ChannelDelibird]

Is that from PotC: Dead Man's Chest? I haven't seen that one, only the first one.

[Jack]

Yeah, it's the 2nd one.

[ChannelDelibird]

I see.

Anyway, I fail to see how there's a case for jar of dart being inherently evil OR good. I don't think you can expect us to say "oh, that's definitely a town role" just by looking at the name.

[ChannelDelibird]

We need to hear from:

AniX
milkman
Y
HurriKaty
Angus
dragyn_mage
Coron
Twito

Most of these people are not posting enough.

[Jack]

I see.

Anyway, I fail to see how there's a case for jar of dart being inherently evil OR good. I don't think you can expect us to say "oh, that's definitely a town role" just by looking at the name.

So you want to lynch me for having a role name that

isn't

inherently evil? As opposed to Angus who claimed a ridiculous painter role that won't confirm his innocence even if the painting does show up, who "forgot" to pm the mod even though he was here during the night phase and tried to convince us that he was the reason there was no kill?

Is Hypnotoad inherently evil?

[ChannelDelibird]

No, I don't want to lynch you for your claim. I want to lynch you for reasons I mentioned prior to your claim. I just wanted to point out that saying "it's not inherently evil" doesn't clear you.

[Jack]

Why don't you want to discuss the reasons you mentioned prior?

[Coron]

Who says you claimed the name you actually have? What total BS. Tempted to switch my vote over due to massive craplogic.

[Zindaras]

It's neither inherently evil nor inherently good.

[Jack]

Mod, can we have an extension?

[HurriKaty]

Katykatykatykatykaty.

Who do you think is scum, besides Angus?

Are we going to play this game again today?

I already played it yesterday.

[al_kohaulec]

Mod, can we have an extension?

No, I have already extended the deadline for a special case. I will not extend again unless if for instance, the site goes down for a long period of time or something.

[Coron]

Jack, claim your actual role, not just role name.

[Jack]

'tis bogus.

I'm the doctor, protected draygn mage last night. I assume that's why there was no kill.

[Zindaras]

Are we going to play this game again today?

I already played it yesterday.

Yeah, funny game, don't you think?

Well, this close to deadline, a new wagon won't give us anything new, so I'll

Unvote, Vote: Angus

. The absence of a kill probably hints at Jack speaking the truth.

[Coron]

I still prefer a Y lynch, honestly, maybe even a Zindaras lynch, though before actually advocating that I would want to do some research.

[Zindaras]

Y's a reasonable lynch (I have expressed suspicion towards both Y and Twito), but I don't think we should try to hurry into either of those lynches a day before deadline.

[AngusHutchsky]

'tis bogus.

I know how you feel. How does Jar of Dirt = Doctor? or was the jar of dirt a joke to save yourself?