Royal Family Mafia - Game Over!

[Thok]

Yes Thok. I randomly chose some names and shouted out SCUMSCUMSCUM.

I'm sticking with Jack.

I did say mostly random; Jack I'm sure wasn't random.

[Ether]

(I've really been neglecting this game.)

Yeah.

So, I'm back. I don't think I'd mind a Thoklynch especially. Better than Pooky's last two picks. I want Thok's opinions of Cogito, Jack, MoS, Nightson and Day 2. (I am aware of his...meh, I'm not referring back to the V/LA thread, some kind of condition; I'm patient, sympathetic and probably a bit run-on-sentence-happy. Stupid "being awake for over 24 hours straight due to time zone swaps" factor.)

[LuckayLuck]

We still have a ways to go before deadline, so I don't really like how Luckay's pushing for a lynch. Especially now that he's abandoned the spreadsheet of doom.

I'm just saying that if we were to be at deadline now (and things certainly are not moving at all) and we had these bandwagons:

IH – 5 – Jack, Canucklehead17, Cogito Ergo Sum, Fritzler, Thok

Cogito Ergo Sum – 2 – Save the Dragons, HackerHuck
Jack – 2 – IH, the silent speaker
Nightson – 2 – LuckayLuck, VitaminR
LuckayLuck – 1 – Mastermind of Sin
Mastermind of Sin – 1 – Ether
VitaminR – 1 – Maz Medias

With 18 alive, it takes 10 to lynch!

Not Voting – 4 – Bogre, Nightson, PookyTheMagicalBear, TheEyeofMordor

we would not get a lot of information.

Things are moving pretty slowly, I want to sort of...get people in position. So yeah. Vote for IH, or vote for Thok, or if you really really feel like someone is scum repeat your vote for them and say that you really really think that person is scum. That's my request. The secondary request is basically not to have IH lynched with something ridiculous like a 5 person majority vote.

And, by the way, IH is a townie.
Just letting you guys know.

[Cardinal Ibelly]

The Official “The Sky is Falling!” Vote Count!

IH – 4 – Jack, Cogito Ergo Sum, Fritzler, Thok
Thok – 3 – PookyTheMagicalBear, LuckayLuck, Canucklehead17

Cogito Ergo Sum – 2 – Save the Dragons, HackerHuck
Mastermind of Sin – 2 – Ether, the silent speaker

Jack – 1 – IH
Nightson – 1 – VitaminR
LuckayLuck – 1 – Mastermind of Sin

With

18

alive, it takes

10

to lynch!

Not Voting – 4 – Bogre, Maz Medias, Nightson, TheEyeofMordor

Mod Note: If the town would like any prods, all you must do is ask.

[Maz Medias]

I'll cast my

Vote: Thok

to even it up before I reread.

[Save The Dragons]

I think CES is scum. Maybe I ought to reread.

[LuckayLuck]

Prod those not voting (Bogre, Nightson, TheEyeofMordor)

[Mastermind of Sin]

LuckayLuck is Scummy McScummerScum

[Mastermind of Sin]

Of course it's the truth

he has lovely eyes.

Pooky was innocent one my first night's investigation, so I would like to trust that he's actually got something here. My only fear is that my sanity might not be straight yet, as I haven't gotten a guilty return on any player. IH, I've soooo GMEOY.

unvote, vote: Thok

HoS: Jack

Just a reminder, but Pooky's innocence doesn't make him right. It just means that he won't be deliberately sending us down the wrong path.

We still have a ways to go before deadline, so I don't really like how Luckay's pushing for a lynch. Especially now that he's abandoned the spreadsheet of doom.

Not to mention that we haven't confirmed the cop's sanity (have we?), and even if we had, there's a good chance that a game this size has scum that come up innocent to investigation.

[Cardinal Ibelly]

Prods being sent on Bogre, Nightson, and TheEyeofMordor.

[TheEyeOfMordor]

Gets poked back into action.

Votes IH

Vote: IH

Disappears...

[IH]

1.Why
2.Thok, why did you think that my suspicions were random?

[Mastermind of Sin]

Why is LL not dead yet?

[Thok]

1.Why
2.Thok, why did you think that my suspicions were random?

I think your Jack suspicion wasn't random, it's a natural continuation of what you've been doing the last few days. But you really haven't said much about STD, and the third person you've listed was Twito, who was dead. It felt like you were trying to list Jack and two random names to look at.

Looking over your posts, I can see where you think HackerHuck suspicious.

[Fritzler]

Why is LL not dead yet?

i dunno, i'd be willing to do a ll wagon before deadline though

[Mastermind of Sin]

Get to it!

[Maz Medias]

I think LL's a retarded townie and I stand by my vote. *shrug*

[Mastermind of Sin]

I think I want him to explain himself.

[the silent speaker]

In retrospect I sort of see what MOS is talking about. I continue to disagree with him about LL being scum, but

unvote: MOS. Vote: CES

to put another bandwagon in the sweepstakes, and because he hasn't posted in three weeks.

[Canucklehead17]

I think I want him to explain himself.

Actually, you probably DON'T want that.

This game has my head spinning.

[Bogre]

got prodded

[Jack]

got prodded

...ok

[LuckayLuck]

I think I want him to explain himself.

I'm a new guy, an outsider from a mafia fan from another forum which has a radically different style. I came in with that style, and it was a bit much. Sorry. Anyways, I'm mellowing out, trying to be more "normal."

Still though, if this 5-4-3-2-1 (literally, look at the votes at the time of this post) voting spread for today's lynch, after a month, is standard for this forum, then sorry for intruding and making an outcry. However, I don't feel that if the lynch were to happen now with the lead vote-getter IH (5) getting lynched and coming up townie, it would give us much information. IH eerily rose up to 8 votes so quickly in the first 3 days, I felt so strongly that something was fishy and that he had been townie-ish in the first 2 days that I had to derail it, which is an action you're all attacking me for, but...y'know, my action really is valid here guys. Those first 8 votes on IH were done reasonless and eerily quickly. Just let it be on the record that I tried extremely hard to derail an IH wagon, and that I really think IH is a townie here, if he gets lynched and appears pro-townie. Yes yes, there's the chance he appears scum and I look foolish. Yes yes, there's the chance that I'm a scum and already know. Blah blah blah. Hopefully at least my sleuthing gets some credibility to it?

[Save The Dragons]

Why is LL not dead yet?

We're all gluttons for punishment.

[Mastermind of Sin]

First off, I love your playstyle, LL. Absolutely love it. When you first replaced into a game I was in, I knew you would be a good player from the moment you posted. Your posts showed careful thought and deep insight into the game, and I'm not feeling that from you anymore. I understand why you don't want to lynch IH, and I'm not voting him either, but I don't understand how you think randomly following Pooky on no evidence is a better alternative to actually sleuthing out scum like you usually do. If you really think IH is townie, why are you putting so little effort into saving him from lynch?