Mini 391 - Fairytale Mafia, Game Over

[Green Crayons]

No, it would be:

LL (scum)
Lowell (survivor)
CES (vig)
IH (mason)

CES kills LL, LL kills CES (obv choice), Lowell sides with remaining town and town wins. Once again,

nobody

fake claims survivor, it's a stupid claim to make as it gets you lynched every single time.

[Green Crayons]

Eh, double post.

I can't believe that he didn't at least defend Vaughn at least slightly.

Uh, in what posts I made on Day Two, I was against the Vaughn bandwagon. Stop trying to make other ignore my actions. Thanks.

IH's post 368: I don't think these examples have much significance simply because it's the dead scum who authored each of these connections. It would be different if it was Vaughn who had made the posts that connected the two, but as it stands, this evidence only shows to me a scum who continually mentions another player - nothing leads me to believe from these posts alone that this other player is more likely to be a scum partner than an unaligned townie whom wolf was attaching himself to.

So you conceed that the reason to vote Vaughn is weak at best, and yet you're willing to lynch him because "what else is there to go on," or in other words, you don't think there's anyone more suspicious? I don't think I can express clearly enough how horrible of a reason this is to lynch someone. You don't string up someone because there's nobody else who you find suspicious (which I find to be pretty silly considering that we have plenty of pages to read through), you lynch them because you firmly believe that they're scum.

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

I shall kill tonight.

[LuckayLuck]

IH, note that GC is trying to side with you and is going with the "there are two scum in the game" story. Lowell is NOT A SURVIVOR. If Lowell was a survivor, if I was scum, and if you were a cop, the game would be setup in this fashion:

Pro-Town:
Cop
Doctor
Vigilante
Mason#1
Mason#2
Survivor
Townies (3)

Neutral:
Serial Killer

Scum:
Scum #1
Scum #2

That is an unreasonable assumption to draw.
Of course from my point of view it's obvious, let your bullet fly true at that fake cop.

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

His thoughts on that matter are wholly irrelevant.

[Green Crayons]

A survivor isn't pro-town. Stop trying to paint the role in that light, LL.

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

I will be killing whoever's right about Lowell's true alignment. (I'm saying this now in case Green Crayons is unnightkillable scum.)

[IH]

A survivor isn't pro-town. Stop trying to paint the role in that light, LL.

Yeah, but if he's a survivor, and CES kills wrong, town loses...

[Green Crayons]

I will be killing whoever's right about Lowell's true alignment.

I don't see how that makes sense. How does Lowell's role indicate who is lying? For example, say Lowell is scum, meaning LL is right, and there are two scum left (Lowell and either I or LL). How does this make LL more guilty than I (since you'll be killing him in said scenario)? Don't get me wrong, I wouldn't be crying in this situation, because you'll be killing LL and not myself, but the flipside of the situation is (in my opinion) the more likely case. That is: if Lowell is truly a survivor, that means you'll be killing me because... I was willing to believe that nobody would be stupid enough to fake-claim a horrible role?

Yeah, but if he's a survivor, and CES kills wrong, town loses...

Yeah, that is part and parcel with CES taking the game into his own hands tonight. It's kill right and win or kill wrong and lose.

[chaotic_diablo]

Day Three

Vote Count

Lowell (3): Cogito Ergo Sum, LuckayLuck, Green Crayons

Not Voting: Lowell, IH

You all stare at Lowell. Lowell stares at you all.
"What?" he says.
"You're not dead!" exclaim everyone.
"So?" questioned Lowell.
"You have three votes on you, yet you're still here."
"Oh, right... so there is"
Then Lowell is sucked in by a giant vortex and banished into the book.

Lowell the Giant (Mafia Grunt)was lynched.

It is now Night Three. Send in your choices.

[chaotic_diablo]

Day Four

Dawn comes. Three out of the four players face each other, the other is dead. No explanation was needed.

Cogito Ergo Sum the Big Bad Wolf (Vigilante) was poisoned.

It is now Day Four. With three people, it is two to lynch.

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

Go Town!

BRAAAIIIIINNNNNNNSSSSSSSS!

[LuckayLuck]

I investigated IH.
IH is innocent.

Anyways...I'll be voting for Green Crayons, Green Crayons will be voting for me. I'm a cop, Green Crayons is not.

[IH]

Thanks for confirming your sanity LL. GC, who did you investigate?

[Green Crayons]

LL. Got innocent.

I'll be voting for LL, LL will be voting for me. I'm a cop, LL is not. ...Hey, look, two can play that game.


Looks like LL was right about game construction to the T because he has insider (scum) information. Now CES' reasoning makes a bit more sense, I suppose.


Speaking of which, I'll be curious as to why CES didn't kill last night after the game.

Anyways. Unless if you've somehow completely played the town IH, it's safe enough for me to put my vote where my mouth is.

Vote: LL

.

[LuckayLuck]

Vote: Green Crayons

About game construction: I thought you guys all believed survivor was a pro-townie role like Lowell made it out to be, who won with town and if it was just him and a scum remaining, town won. Were you guys thinking he was neutral or something?

I was right about game construction to the T because I have mafia game design/mod experience, and after peeking you as innocent even though it was obvious (to me) that you/lowell were the scumpair, I knew you were a godfather and the 3-scum team matched the balance of a doc/cop/vig/masonry as I've mentioned.

[IH]

..... I'm going to go over the thread and then make my decision.
= | I don't wanna be endgamed....

[IH]

I've made my decision. (crosses fingers)

vote:LuckayLuck

[chaotic_diablo]

Day Four

Vote Count

LuckayLuck (2): Green Crayons, IH

Green Crayons (1): LuckayLuck

Green Crayons and IH stare at LuckayLuck.
"We'll send you into the book."
"Damn you all! Damn you all to hell!" LuckayLuck yells, "You're never stop me once I transform into my ultimate form!"
From there, LuckayLuck grows disproportionally and obtains horns, claws, and fangs. His form was so horrifying, that it was impossible to tell it was really Little Red Riding Hood.
"I'm now going to eat your souls, for I am really the witch who possessed this form! But I had nothing to do with LuckayLuck's badness, he was already screwed up when I came."
"Holy shit we're F**ked," says IH. <------ F* bomb
"Don't worry, I'll save you!" And the wizard appears out of nowhere.
Using his amazing mod-like powers, chaotic_diablo summons a blackhole within the book.
"NOOOO!!!!"
And LuckayLuck was banished into the book.
"You're so great!" exclaimed Green Crayons.
"Yeah, I'm that awesome."
"Not you, this piece of cheese (that was left by Vaughn upon his death) on the floor. It totally kicked that monster's ass!"
From here, the fairytale characters went to live on happily ever after. Except for the other 10 of them, but who's counting?
THE END.

LuckayLuck the Little Red Riding Hood (Mafia Godfather) was lynched.

TOWN WINS!!! Aren't we all so happy?

As a side note, my storytelling sucks and I made that up in half an hour. Anyway, I apologize for any screw-ups on my part that may or may not have contributed to anyone's defeat.

Also, you may post your own epilogues, just for the fun of it. The conditions:
1. If you were banished to the book, then it has to take place in the book.
2. If you died as town, then you are in Fairytale Heaven. You must base it around that place.
3. If you died as scum, then you go to hell.
4. Everyone but scum may have a "revival" story.

Any concerns or hints to improve my modding will be appreciated. Go talk or something, I'll post the night choices and role sorts later.

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

I assume LuckayLuck was unnightkillable? This should've been apparent to both GC and IH and is the reason why I stated who I was going to kill before going to Night.

I thought that LuckayLuck was scum on the one hand, but GC's insistence that Lowell really was a Survivor was damn strange to me. It only made sense to me if GC was scum and he knew Lowell was telling the truth. As such, I made my choice conditional. If GC had been right about Lowell, I would kill him. If he was wrong, then that issue would no longer be relevant and I'd kill LL. (I could also invoke the knowledge-tell here.)

I'll write an epilogue laterish.

[M4yhem]

Well I'm glad you got the people who killed me. Luckay Luck - Well done for fooling me; I thought it was Green Canyons right up to the end. You tricksy man- a pity for you I wasn't alive at the end.

Good job town. I can't really pretend to be happy though- if I had my way, you'd all be dead! *Shakes fist*

Who killed me? And for what reason? Did anyone suspect me of being the SK?

I killed masterchief, for lurking, and spectrumvoid, because I was afraid she'd work out who I was.

C_D- I thought the game was well run and I enjoyed your write-ups. I thought the setup was pretty well balanced although I would have liked a nice toy like investigation immunity or nightkill immunity or something.

Now to go and roast marshmallows on the burning souls of sinners...

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

I should also bring up the humorous fact that Seol IMed me with a request to replace into this game during Night 1 because he thought the need for a replacement was responsible for the long night. Humorous, because I had already replaced into the game during Day 1 and because I was already killing Echo that Night.

[LuckayLuck]

M4yhem, I thought you may have been a cop. *bang*

[IH]

Well.... I wasn't sure the entire time, but LL's vibes and early posts were what did it. Even moreso was the godfather thing he brought up. That's what did it for me I think when he accused GC of being a godfather, and why he would choose to investigate me tonight.

Coupled with GC's innocent investigation on LL, then I was pretty sure that LL knew the setup, hence why he mentioned the godfather.

Not only that, I didn't believe his claim the whole time about little red riding hood. = )

Was GC paranoid?

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

You still suck for failing to realize LL must have been unnkable.