Micro 193 - HD had a Greater Idea (Mafia)! [GAME OVER]

[Amrun]

not really

[Grimgroove]

The lynch on JasonWazza was bad. There's no denying it.
In-game I was agreeing with him being scummy because I don't want to rub town the wrong way at the time, but it was an objectively terrible speedlynch.
Thought it would work out better for me though. Already saw myself winning this, but did not take 2 mafiabuddies into account. Not that that would have changed much from my PoV.

[Amrun]

I wholeheartedly disagree

The speed of it, maybe, but as scum, I wasn't complaining -- and as town, I'd probably demand blood for the blood god there.

That sort of mistake is much more likely to come from town than scum, even if it came from town in this case.

The majority of this site, in current meta, would instant lynch that, just as was done here.

[JasonWazza]

That sort of mistake is much more likely to come from town than scum, even if it came from town in this case.

The majority of this site, in current meta, would instant lynch that, just as was done here.

These 2 lines should not agree with eachother.

Making assumptions based on night kills is NOT EVER A SCUM TELL

[Amrun]

Oops, I meant more likely to come from scum than town, my b. I'm tired.

It's not making assumptions based on night kills, by the way -- it's making assumptions about who made which night kills.

You said Mac wasted a kill on DrDoLittle. I FULLY expected you to flip werewolf or alien that killed CheeryDog. Most people would also assume that.

This is something you really need to learn. I'm not even joking a little bit.

[JasonWazza]

That's a stupid assumption though, i'm making assumption's based on my townie's knowledge.

I'm going to be open with said assumptions, because i want town to be on the same page as i am

IT'S NOT FUCKING SCUMMY

[Amrun]

If you said, "just bear with me, assuming Mac killed DrDoLittle," that's fine. Still weird, and you might accrue a few votes for it, but not the same thing at all.

You just said, "Mac wasted a kill on DrDoLittle" and based some off the wall shitpost on it.

It's poor play as town not only because it got you lynched, but also because building theories on baseless assumptions is never a good idea.

[ChannelDelibird]

I still don't understand what made you make those assumptions at all, that's the thing, there was no reason to think that one was more likely than the other.

[JasonWazza]

There was when i assumed Saulus had access to a night kill.

[ChannelDelibird]

Thought you said the other kill was an assumed werewolf, though.

[JasonWazza]

(Hence why i was calling him a Judas)

[ChannelDelibird]

OK, in which case I don't think that's ever going to make sense to me. Not worth arguing about any more. Sorry for mislynching you, though.

[JasonWazza]

I'll try and break it down

2 night kills:

DrDoLittle
Cherry Dog

Dr never claimed the CD kill, and it's doubtful that he would kill himself.

So i assumed that a werewolf and a Alien made the kills.

[ChannelDelibird]

But you had no reason to assume that there wasn't a mafia who mistakenly killed Dolittle, for example.

[Grimgroove]

Are you going to tell me how you figured me out, CDB? :p

[ChannelDelibird]

Are you going to tell me how you figured me out, CDB? :p

I didn't hold anything back that I didn't mention in the thread. Stuff about you looking like a spectator etc and just general feeling. I was less confident on Day 2, though - I certainly would have lynched Mac before you.

[Cheery Dog]

We coulda been scum buddies ;_;

Except we would have had to repick.

(I still think we should have been repicking anyway - cult recruiter should be classified as 1.5 anti-roles with the judas/saulres as 0.5, but I'm not the mod and I don't want to get into an argument over how I think greater idea works again)

P.S.: i still maintain Trollie lost us that game, and i still maintain that me putting a name to a kill was in no way shape or form a slip.

Let's hope you all learn your lesson that slips like that aren't actual slips.

I'd known you to be town due to reading the spoiler QT, but I still find oyu (I think anyway) using that as a case to not lynch your confirmed scum in Mac. (even if he was apparently without a kill) as dumb.


Though I'm still confused as to where anyone got Mac being confirmed alien from.

(but what to I know, my reads were just wrong.)

[Guyett]

I think its because MAc claimed CT and acted scummy... so he must be the scum that shows up when CT is investigated

[Cheery Dog]

Can I ask what everyone's orginial choices were when we ended up with not enough town?

I had mafia tracker and vanilla townie to choose from.

[JasonWazza]

Welcome to Micro 193, JasonWazza! Please PM me with your choice of one of the following two roles that you will use for this game.

Wrong Place at the Wrong Time Townie

You are a

Wrong Place at the Wrong Time Townie

. You will show up as guilty to all investigations. You win when all threats to the Town are eliminated.

Mason

You are a

Town Mason

. You know any other Mason roles in the game. You may communicate with the other Masons at any time during the game. You win when all threats to the Town are eliminated.

Town Mason was my choice.

[Grimgroove]

I had Mafia Goon twice during the first go, so I didn't really have a choice.

[ChannelDelibird]

I had Doctor or Mason Lover. I really wanted Mason Lover =(

[DrDolittle]

goon v psychotrooper. Chose the alien role

[Guyett]

Town godfather or town lover. Chose town lover

[quadz08]