Micro 193 - HD had a Greater Idea (Mafia)! [GAME OVER]

[ChannelDelibird]

Also, hang on: Why do you assume that Mac 'wasted' his kill on DrDolitte, Jason? Do you know who killed Cheery Dog?

[Amrun]

Holy shit that's probably a slip.

Now I want to lynch Jason.

But Mac is also scum.

Halp someone give me two votes

Fuck now I seriously don't know who to vote this is a problem

[JasonWazza]

:eyeroll:

Yes that was totally a fucking slip.... dumbasses.

CDB, he is claiming Salrus, meaning he dies and turns into town, thus there is 2 night kills by his saying.

I am calling him a Judas because i think he is lying THAT'S PRETTY DARN SIMPLE

He is basically setting up Mac for a lynch down the track.

and i think if DrDoLittle's claim has ANY scrap of truth, that the Alien kill was wasted.

Now given the info DrDoLittle has given us assuming the following is natural;

a) there was 2 kills (quite easily the simple assumption is that there is 2 factions.)
b) That DDL didn't attempt to kill himself (No fucking shit)
c) That therefore leaves Mac (or assumedly someone else) as an Alien.

BUT there is one thing that he leaves out, he never EVER claimed the CD kill.

THERE'S A GOOD REASON TO THIS PEOPLE, CAUSE HE COULDN'T KILL BECAUSE HE IS A MOTHERFUCKING JUDAS.

If he is Salrus he's the fucking worst ever, because he should be pushing the Mac lynch straight up.

[Amrun]

But you seem to know that Mac attempted to kill DrDoLittle, thus "wasting" a kill on him. HOW do you know this? I didn't know that shit. So where did it come from?

[ChannelDelibird]

Jason, Saulus wouldn't have had a kill last night (or ever) because they can't have communication with any mafia buddies because they might become town and then expose them. Saulus just knows they are aligned with the mafia to start, not who their buddies are.

On that part of your theory, you are understandably mistaken. I'm still considering exactly what kind of wrong the rest of your theory is.

[ChannelDelibird]

and i think if DrDoLittle's claim has ANY scrap of truth, that the Alien kill was wasted.

Why is one of the kills from an Alien?
Why was the Alien's kill 'wasted' on Dolittle rather than doing exactly what it was supposed to on Cheery Dog?

[ChannelDelibird]

Now given the info DrDoLittle has given us assuming the following is natural;

a) there was 2 kills (quite easily the simple assumption is that there is 2 factions.)

Vig? One-shot vig? PGO?

c) That therefore leaves Mac (or assumedly someone else) as an Alien.

Again, why Alien?

[Amrun]

cdb

please explain to me how that shit DOESN'T come from scum

because i'm looking over and over

and i just

don't see it

[ChannelDelibird]

...Yeah, OK, he's scum. I was trying to figure out if his understandable wrongful assumption that a Saulus would have been able to claim one of last night's kills might be at the root of a genuine town hunt. But I don't even think that line of thinking is one he's consistent in showing.

Next thing that I want to happen is Mac to claim a result. Then we'll lynch one of them.

[Human Destroyer]

Mod Note

TheTrollie has been prodded.

[TheTrollie]

yo im still VLA till tomorrow but i caught up:

VOTE: Trollie
Cheery's death lines up well with Trollie-scum the most.

i honestly dont even get this

Also, hang on: Why do you assume that Mac 'wasted' his kill on DrDolitte, Jason? Do you know who killed Cheery Dog?

pls explain this slip i dont see it

I think drd is telling the truth but i also saw a possible slip relating to him not really understanding his role, i thought one of the posts made it seem like he had some mafia-es

[TheTrollie]

EBWOP: q knowledge

[Amrun]

Trollie -- Jason assumed both that Mac is an alien (??? still gotten no explanation as to why), AND that Mac shot last night, as an alien, and shot DrDoLittle.

None of these assumptions make sense, or can be possibly be informed by anything in thread, except for the assuming Mac is an alien thing which several people seem to be doing for no reason at all that I can tell. The most significant thing is assuming that Mac shot DrDoLittle, when DrDoLittle isn't who died last night. It doesn't make sense for town to EVER assume this.

[TheTrollie]

can u pls quote the post with the slip in it?

[Amrun]

Because it's not only a single scum that is by themselves that would be afraid of a kill.

Could you clarify this sentence please?

I (JasonWazza) am implying that the Judas (DrDoLittle) isn't pushing the Alien (Mac) because the Alien is an easy mislynch for later and that a singular scum (DrDoLittle) would be more likely to attack and lynch a killing faction.

That is what i'm getting at as to how his claim is not town at all, it's him trying to change us from focusing on the Alien that wasted his kill (Mac) to the werewolf that he is yet to find (assumed second kill)

[Amrun]

He has several other that say sort of the same thing, but that's the big WOWZA one.

[TheTrollie]

k fine yeah lets lynch it. i dont necessarily get how this is a complete slip but i think thats cuz i havent read the posts leading up to that one so well.

p-edit: like was the Mac=alien thing totally out of left field or have ppl been talking about that?

[Amrun]

People have been like, talking about it, (one or two, not everyone), while others (including me) have been like, "Wait, why is he an alien again?" and getting no answers.

I'm assuming it has to do something with the fact that he says he's the alien cop (forget the name, but you know the role), but refuses to claim his result.

[ChannelDelibird]

The reason why people are screaming "Mac is an alien" is because he claimed Conspiracy Theorist, as if aliens are the only kind of scum who would claim a role which appears in triplicate. Marginally more likely to be an alien, sure, but "Mac is just some kind of scum" is the more compelling angle.

[TheTrollie]

right

[Amrun]

This game is in easy mode. How exciting.

[JasonWazza]

You guys are fucking retarded.

I'M MAKING ASSUMPTIONS THAT DOESN'T MAKE ME SCUM

CDB, would that still be the case if he is a single scum member (ie. as Salrus he is the only Mafia member) because i would have thought that didn't apply.

Amrun, i assume that because i'm going for what is being pushed by DrDoLittle (mind you i may be now wrong due to the Salrus not knowing the mafia)

The reason i am saying Mac made an alien kill, is because that is the only logical way in my mind of thought that it would have made sense.

The fact i made an assumption of who killed who, means fuck all, i like to put names to kills, it doesn't matter if it's back to front, that isn't the point.

[ChannelDelibird]

CDB, would that still be the case if he is a single scum member (ie. as Salrus he is the only Mafia member) because i would have thought that didn't apply.

Yes, in the same way that a lone Mafia Traitor in normal games can't kill even if the whole of their team is dead. They're just working to benefit the mafia rather than actually become one - and the fact that they can't fairly be told who their buddies are if there are buddies means that it's unfair to tell them that there are

no

buddies because that's more information than they would normally have.

The reason i am saying Mac made an alien kill, is because that is the only logical way in my mind of thought that it would have made sense.

The only logical way?

How does Mac making, say, a mafia or werewolf kill not logically make some kind of sense? Or anyone else, for that matter?

[JasonWazza]

The fact i made an assumption of who killed who, means fuck all, i like to put names to kills, it doesn't matter if it's back to front, that isn't the point.

[ChannelDelibird]

Yeah, not good enough.

Mac, get in here and claim your result so we can lynch Jason.