Mafia 57: Good Ol' Mafia - Game over!

[livingod]

You said CDB was a fantastic player, or something along those lines.

[Nightfall]

I called him a really good player because I've played with him before and I know this...
I also said that he could be scum.

[livingod]

He's CDB, cmon...

[TheJiveMachine]

Since when are compliments a scumtell?

FoS : Panzer

for fishing for reasoning.

[PJ.]

Shadowlurker for saying that everyone but him and Twito are scum, for saying with such certainty that people are scum then denying it when they turn out to be town and then exploding for thinking he is scum, claiming a kill role in his first 5 post, and confusing the town.

What the fuck? All of these are blatantly false.

You have finally convinced that you are dense and that you sit on a chair and say that you are the perfect townie, this town upon a hill for all to examine, guess what, read your own post man, you are scum. Do you even read what you write? All of these things i have said are very true. Does any one else see this or are you guys just ignoring me cause SL is a mod?

[livingod]

Being a mod has nothing to do with it. Just FYI.

[JDodge]

Shadowlurker for saying that everyone but him and Twito are scum, for saying with such certainty that people are scum then denying it when they turn out to be town and then exploding for thinking he is scum, claiming a kill role in his first 5 post, and confusing the town.

What the fuck? All of these are blatantly false.

You have finally convinced that you are dense and that you sit on a chair and say that you are the perfect townie, this town upon a hill for all to examine, guess what, read your own post man, you are scum. Do you even read what you write? All of these things i have said are very true. Does any one else see this or are you guys just ignoring me cause SL is a mod?

I've been ignoring it because:

A) It doesn't really strike me as dense.

B) Even if it was dense, dense =/= scummy.

C) I don't see anything scummy about his posting.

[livingod]

^
|
|
|

I agree

[Dagger]

Let me elaborate. SL's stating who and who have to die tonight feels like he's trying to give orders to someone, vig most probably or some other roles. The fact that he dictates it that way to direct the night actions does not sit well with me.

[ShadowLurker]

Let me elaborate. SL's stating who and who have to die tonight feels like he's trying to give orders to someone, vig most probably or some other roles. The fact that he dictates it that way to direct the night actions does not sit well with me.

If you were the vig and I told you to vig yourself, would you listen to me?

[TheJiveMachine]

Let me elaborate. SL's stating who and who have to die tonight feels like he's trying to give orders to someone, vig most probably or some other roles. The fact that he dictates it that way to direct the night actions does not sit well with me.

It didn't seem to me he was saying "Hey vig, kill scotty" as much as "I'mma kill scotty tonight". Which to me says he's a vig, or claiming so at least. Unless he's a mason with a vig partner, but that seems like rather an obvious signal.

Or he could be scum.

[ShadowLurker]

Yes obviously scum would announce their night targets in the open.

[TheJiveMachine]

It's the last place most people would think to look >_>

[Dagger]

Let me elaborate. SL's stating who and who have to die tonight feels like he's trying to give orders to someone, vig most probably or some other roles. The fact that he dictates it that way to direct the night actions does not sit well with me.

If you were the vig and I told you to vig yourself, would you listen to me?

No, but I would have vigged Fircoal based on what you said if I was a vig.

And that is not a claim whatsoever that I am a vig.

[ShadowLurker]

Let me elaborate. SL's stating who and who have to die tonight feels like he's trying to give orders to someone, vig most probably or some other roles. The fact that he dictates it that way to direct the night actions does not sit well with me.

If you were the vig and I told you to vig yourself, would you listen to me?

No, but I would have vigged Fircoal based on what you said if I was a vig.

And that is not a claim whatsoever that I am a vig.

So you regularly trust other people to tell you who to kill when you have no indication of their alignment, I see. How about you just proxy your vote to me then? I'll find scum for you.

[Twito]

And I don't like SL's way of posting, the way he knows who and who is scum with such certainty. That'll be my rationale of voting for now.

Vote: ShadowLurker

.

That makes no fucking sense at all.

Agree.

Alright, this is my scum list

~N9V~
ShadowLurker
Nightfall

N9 for voting himself, trying to confuse town, and not being concerned with catching scum.

Shadowlurker for saying that everyone but him and Twito are scum, for saying with such certainty that people are scum then denying it when they turn out to be town and then exploding for thinking he is scum, claiming a kill role in his first 5 post, and confusing the town.

Nightfall for kissing ass, posting little of content, and delibratly confusing the town.

Unvote

I will think about who my vote will belong to later.

Obviously one of those is your scumbuddy. As usual you are scum who lists three people and one of them your scumbuddy but tries to put the pressure on others. You are also unvoting your scumbuddy, N9V, who you were planning to bus.
When did SL say that only me and him are town?

I think N9V and Dagger are buddies, be it scum or mason, but I'm thinking scum.

Sure looks like it. With Panzer.

I'm kissing ass? Confused

Yes, mine, during every nightfall.

Let me elaborate. SL's stating who and who have to die tonight feels like he's trying to give orders to someone, vig most probably or some other roles. The fact that he dictates it that way to direct the night actions does not sit well with me.

If you were the vig and I told you to vig yourself, would you listen to me?

Exactly. But he sure is trying to make up reasons to wagon you.

So you regularly trust other people to tell you who to kill when you have no indication of their alignment, I see. How about you just proxy your vote to me then? I'll find scum for you.

I already have scum for both of you.

So N9V is scum.
Panzer is scum.
Dagger still stands a change of being newbie town but could be scum.

[autoload]

Let me elaborate. SL's stating who and who have to die tonight feels like he's trying to give orders to someone, vig most probably or some other roles.

The fact that he dictates it that way to direct the night actions does not sit well with me.

If you were the vig and I told you to vig yourself, would you listen to me?

No, but I would have vigged Fircoal based on what you said if I was a vig.

And that is not a claim whatsoever that I am a vig.

So you don't like how SL appears to be giving orders to unknown vigs on who to kill, but then say that you would have killed who he suggested anyways?

Unvote: RafK

Vote: Dagger

[Dagger]

The way SL made out his statements, it seemed as he's very confident that he is right. That would have swayed me to believe him if nothing else.

I have no experience of being a vig before and I have no experience of playing in such a large game with people just accusing each other just for the heck of it without providing anything to back those up.

It made analysing difficult and I am tired, so I am just going to go with my guts. So far, what I have had is 'please reread', 'go back through the threads', 'I know he's scum', etc. etc. That's assuming people know specifically what one is referring to. I don't and like hell I am going to reread all those nonsense of insulting each others and accusing each others scums with nothing sensible to back those up. It makes it so damn difficult trying to decipher anything useful out of those garbles.

Want me to claim? I would be perfectly happy to do so right now.

[Mariyta]

Why would you claim?

[Twito]

Want me to claim? I would be perfectly happy to do so right now.

Don't be a moron. Help lynch scum.
I've told you who is scum now just help me get rid of em. KTHXBAI.

[ChannelDelibird]

~N9V~ is the best lynch. He's admitted to going after ShadowLurker specifically and I think he's been following Panzer around quite a lot.

(translation: I'm still here, I have nothing to add so I am outlining my position on who I think is scummiest again.)

Mod:

could we have a vote count please?

[PJ.]

Lynch all trendy bastards.

Vote: N9V

[Twito]

Lynch all trendy bastards.

Vote: N9V

Back at bussing buddies are we?

[TheJiveMachine]

Want me to claim? I would be perfectly happy to do so right now.

Got your false claim all ready for just such an occasion, eh?

Vote: Dagger

[Twito]

Want me to claim? I would be perfectly happy to do so right now.

Got your false claim all ready for just such an occasion, eh?

Vote: Dagger

Post without vote on N9V noted.