Let's try that again EBWDP:
A townie might forget something, and scum might forget something, but scums also "forget" things. Generally bad play, like not remembering when certain people can't post, shows an inattentiveness to the game - or an intentional desire to distract people,
is more of a scum tell than a town tell
. In either case its better to get rid of people like that. If you missed (or forgot) something as big as someone not being able to post, you
could
miss (or forgot) a certain person playing the game and defending scum every time.
Having a townie like that could almost be as bad as a mafia member.
If having 10+ games makes you not be able to play effectively in a game - perhaps you shouldn't
play
such a large number of them, as you certainly don't have as much value as someone paying more
attention
. And no, forgetting something when we are only 4 pages in on day 1 and paying attention to the game are largely the same thing. I might let something like that slide if we were 80 pages in, but its one of only 3 "truths" you could bank on at this stage
:
2 people can't talk, your role, and pooky and pots having some kind of connection. I'd say forgetting 33% of the pertinant information at this point is not paying enough attention.
To recap - I don't necessarily think you're scum - just at this point you seem like someone I could just as much see getting rid of as keeping. Considering the chances of hitting scum on day 1 are slim anyway, I think you're a good bet. Inattentativeness is minor - but not much else has happened.
If you would like to think of that as "forced reasoning" that's fine.
I'm suspicious - in every sense of the word.
you don't need much of a reason to vote for someone yet 
)