Mafia 60: Face-to-Face - Game over!

[Patrick]

Patrick: Needs to post more. What he's posted makes sense.

I find it curious that you would make a point of saying this about me in particular. Alot of ppl have posted less than me, you included.

[Thesp]

He recommended Nightfall follow CDB's lead and bus AndrewS. To me that implies he thinks Nightfall is scum.

I wasn't sure who the third scum was. I did indeed suggest if Nigthfall was scum, he should follow CDB's lead. It turns out MBL is the third scum, though, not Nightfall. I have an alternate theory, but both involve AndrewS as scum.

[Patrick]

Ok. So do we kill them in alphabetical order?

[Zindaras]

I find it curious that you would make a point of saying this about me in particular. Alot of ppl have posted less than me, you included.

If you take a look at your posts, you'll notice that most of them are one-liners.

[Patrick]

Some of them are, I just found it strange that you picked me out when that is true of most ppl (including you again).

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

Zindaras: it's pretty easy to get a read on Thesp. Just follow him blindly. If the town's losing, he's probably scum. If you just won the game, well, then he's probably town.

[Zindaras]

Some of them are, I just found it strange that you picked me out when that is true of most ppl (including you again).

One word: Vengeful.

I don't think I'll ever be able to trust you again. *sad*

Zindaras: it's pretty easy to get a read on Thesp. Just follow him blindly. If the town's losing, he's probably scum. If you just won the game, well, then he's probably town.

Totally awesome idea.

Also, wanna switch votes to scumvoid? It'll be fun.

[Glork]

Glork: Way too bandwagonish. He's playing one of his "crazy" games, with all kinds of random stuff. However, odd bandwagoning isn't usually part of that. Has been on both of the 3-post 3-vote bandwagons I really didn't like.

viewtopic.php?t=3684&userposts=1333

[Thesp]

Zindaras: it's pretty easy to get a read on Thesp. Just follow him blindly. If the town's losing, he's probably scum. If you just won the game, well, then he's probably town.

This is probably the highest compliment I've been paid in a mafia game. I'm flattered!

[Glork]

Zindaras: it's pretty easy to get a read on Thesp. Just follow him blindly. If the town's losing, he's probably scum. If you just won the game, well, then he's probably town.

Dammit, he figured out my strategy!

[IH]

While I was puking my guts out last night from a virus I just had a major revelation.

unvote, vote:MGM, IGMEOY:AndrewS

I need to do a little reread to make sure, but pretty sure that MGM has been wishy washy, unhelpful, and "misread" the game a few times to many for my liking.

= | Lemme go through his posts first to make sure.

[spectrumvoid]

I'll never ever trust Patrick again. I was reading through some of his older games, and I was completely fooled as well.

You too Zindybuns.

Glork is... well, being Glork.

Hope you get better soon IH.

Let's kill them in alphabetical order... hammer!

[Zindaras]

You too Zindybuns.

Hmm?

[Patrick]

Your perception of me is skewed

[Mgm]

I'll be out of the running this weekend. I have a website to update and a deadline to do it with. After that I'm going to reread the thread on monday to make sure I don't accidentally overlook something when I respond. Maybe a reread in one sit will give me some new revelations to work with too.

[Nightfall]

Nightfall: Typical Nightfall-lurker.

*Posted elsewhere*

Hey ***, I check in to everygame I'm in at the least once every two days.
I work during the week so I can only post when I get home. If you check my posts you'll see that they are all from certain blocks of time with each block being almost 24 hours apart. Over the weekend I usually spend time with my girlfriend family and other friends, but I still do my best to make time to come by at least once in the two days to post something. Yes I am in other games with you, **** mafia comes to mind, and if I remember accurately I am 1 of the only 4 people who actually didnt leave that game because of inactivity. I may not make posts 24/7 but I am in the games I play for the long run.

It's not lurking if I post whenever I visit the site...

I'll do a read of MGM's posts alone and see if I can pick up on anything that others seem to already have.

[Nightfall]

I think MGM's 10th and 11th post are a little bit scummy, but I dont think his theories are all that skewed...

I for one still think there is at least one scum between Ether and AndrewS.

[IH]

I don't get you, Zindaras.
You agree it's WIFOM, yet you don't think it's lynch-worthy.
I've seen a lot of scum, who attempted something just because scum wouldn't do that so they could use that argument. (I even did it myself over in DragonPhoenix Mafia on the GL)

If you're not going to vote someone for WIFOM, then do you have a better idea? The only reason I'm not voting yet is because I don't like fast lynches. But I'm all ready to pile up.

Unvote:Cogito Ergo Sum

First, a little bit of a fallacy here. "You agree it's wifom, you you don't think it's lynch-worth". No middle ground.

Not only that, but what he criticizes Zindy for, he's not doing himself. He doesn't like fast lynches, but he's ready to pile up.

-_-

I do. Because you actually voted no lynch when we were discussing how bad a no lynch would be for the town following Andrew's bandwagon. If you're pro-town, surely you have a better place to put your vote than on a no lynch you know won't happen. It is a waste of voting power.

I still don't get it. I'm pretty sure it was apparent that Glork wasn't being serious. In later posts you still don't seem to accept it. I thought you did, after this post though.

MGM, read the game - he was parodying me....

Oops, I guess I was the one not paying attention. I thought his post 117 was in response to my post 116. I didn't notice he responded to an SV quote.

apparently not, as in your next post though

Thesp, you've pretty much worded my feelings better than I could myself, but just in case someone wants to hear it.

AndrewS and Glork made a bad suggestion. Whether they meant it is irrelevant. Suggesting it is scummy, following through on it by making the vote is scummier.

Granted, you might get a few scum on your bandwagon, but not because they're opportunists, it will be because you called the wagon on yourself and it's logical to punish scummy actions or take action against anti-town play. Scum want to mix in, so if the town wagons you, they'll join (regardless of whether you're their buddy or a townie). It's not rocket science.

From some of his posts I see him trying to make Glork look scummy because he voted for a no lynch.

= / When no one else seemed to go along with it, it just kinda seemed to.... drop.

mm, I'm feeling pretty good with an Mgm lynch at the moment.

Also Mgm, I'm not sure WHAT the attack on the person link had to do with anything in one of your posts.

[Zindaras]

*Posted elsewhere*

Look, deary, that's how I'll always characterize you. You wouldn't be playing this game if you sucked. I'm not suspicious of you for the way you post.

I still wuv you. <3

[Patrick]

I for one still think there is at least one scum between Ether and AndrewS.

Any particular reason for this dilemna?

[IH]

To be fair that isn't exactly a dilemma as it says "I for one still think" instead of "There has to be/must be".

Slight mischaracterisation.

[Patrick]

I humbly apologise for any discrepancy and hope that Nightfall and any other players who took offence will forgive me.

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

That doesn't make it less scummy, Patrick.

[Nightfall]

Well we could continue to go over WIFOM stuff for ever to discuss it deeply but my best estimate is that AndrewS has likely done what he did (The whole no lynch saga) as scum, planning to use the excuse that if he really was scum that he wouldn't be stupid enough to propose it here. I admit that a little of my suspicion is likely from the fact that I have never played with him before and I'm not aware how he usually acts, how much Im not sure. My thoughts on Ether are that she is trying really hard to argue that AndrewS is town, and as far as I can tell seems near sure of it. As posted earlier, scum usually like to snuggle up with people who are innocent to make themselves appear innocent. I feal this could be going on here.

Im also not that sure how I feal about thesp now though. I thought he was actually one of the more protown people here, but then as soon as I mention that someone other than AndrewS could be scum he seems to snap at me...

[Patrick]

That doesn't make it less scummy, Patrick.

I hope you're joking. I expect IH to nitpick semantics. Not you though.