Mafia 57: Good Ol' Mafia - Game over!

[Nightfall]

Whose "both"?

[autoload]

Both meaning Battle Mage and scotmany.

My apologies for not making that more clear the first time.

[Fircoal]

OMG it's a newbie game on steroids!!!

I'm sticking with my vote, and

FOS:
Twito
RafK
Primate
Chaucer
~N9V~
Fircoal
SenFive
autoload
Blue Gatorade
pevergreen
dagger
JDodge
cheesefan

13 people and none of them are SCotmany12, and BAttlemage.

I don't know why you'd think that 13 people might be scum, just because they thing that BM, and Scotmany12 are scum.

[Fircoal]

SOrry

FOS: Nightfall

[PJ.]

Alright..first order of buisness..Thank you Mariyta, love you too.Oh and Go Gators!!

ok now for analysis..umm i think Jdodge and scotmany are scumbuddies..they have pretty much ignored each other the entire game and have not and wagoned on BM..scotmany is just really bad scum..being a bad newbie doesn't mean your a bad townie as everyone has seem to guess.

Confirm Vote: Scotmany, HoS: JDodge

I just think BM is a walking talking logical fallicy because he has kept on trying to pass of the same reasoning as different and explaining it with the same damn reasoning like we were 6th graders. I don't like that he is OMGUSing CDB but i don't like CDB's reasoning either.

FoS:BM

I think CDB is pushing for it because he is either A. scumbuddies with scotmany due to him putting little attention on the scot case and saying "it's not really a case" or B he is just really really pissed that BM is an idiot and sees that scot has at least tried to reason with his idiocy. I don't know if i'm leaning more A or B.

FoS: CDB

Shadow i hesitate even mentioning your name in fear of being vigged or NKed. Sir, you are the scariest MF in this game and if you are a vanilla townie you are the BEST mafia player ever.

EVER

. All i know for certain is that you are a kill role. Like i said before it will be very hard for you to tell me otherwise.

N9V, congratulations on not being a stupid newbie.

Jive, congratulations on having a radiohead avvy.

and whoever FoSed 13 people..*High 5* you sir have failed at adding anything to the thread.

Request Vote Count

Thank you in advance MM.

[TheJiveMachine]

Jive, congratulations on having a radiohead avvy.

<3

[Fircoal]

BM, not a smart move standing up for me, as now it just looks like we are both mafia. I know that I am not mafia, and I am also pretty sure the you are not mafia as well, but it really doesn't matter what we think at this point.

ARe you trying to tell your mafia partner directions during day.

MOd, can we have a vote count please.

[Fircoal]

and whoever FoSed 13 people..*High 5* you sir have failed at adding anything to the thread.

excatly.

[~N9V~]

N9V, congratulations on not being a stupid newbie.

Ahh thankyou *brush away tear* now only to figure out if that was sarcastic or not. T'is kind of hard when I can;t hear your voice. And I also agree with the thirteen FoS guy. I belive he did that to everyone who has posted alot, or not at all.

[Fircoal]

N9V, congratulations on not being a stupid newbie.

Ahh thankyou *brush away tear* now only to figure out if that was sarcastic or not. T'is kind of hard when I can;t hear your voice. And I also agree with the thirteen FoS guy. I belive he did that to everyone who has posted alot, or not at all.

No, he did that to either

1) every one who did a vote that was like a bandwagon. (even with proof)

2) everyone who isn't mafia.

[PJ.]

thanks assholes..comment only on the the credits..and N9V nothing after the opener was sarcasm. and the opener wasn't that sarcastic.

[Fircoal]

thanks assholes..comment only on the the credits..and N9V nothing after the opener was sarcasm. and the opener wasn't that sarcastic.

Then why didn't you mention me, I'm new.

[PJ.]

cause you are not flashy..you are merely succeeding to be less scummy or stylish then those mentioned..but that kinda the point of mafia..i actually feel i have posted too much.

[Fircoal]

cause you are not flashy..you are merely succeeding to be less scummy or stylish then those mentioned..but that kinda the point of mafia..i actually feel i have posted too much.

no you haven't posted that, much. :O, so that's why.

[~N9V~]

I have one proposal to everyone that beleives that Scotmany12 and Battle Mage are scumbudies, or even JDodge is in that group. Why don't we lynch one of them, then we will find out.

[Fircoal]

sounds good enough.

VOte: SCotmany12

He's the most scum like, and I voted him before.

Mod: Vote count please.

[spectrumvoid]

MOD

I'm requesting replacement. This game is insane, solely because there're too many newbies around, and I don't want to waste time explaining BASIC mafia strategy in every other post or so, and I don't want to waste my time reading through bad grammar. Once or twice is fine, or if English isn't their native language, but BASIC capitalisation? If I wanted a game like this, I could have gone to a kindergarten. I accuse you, you insult me, I accuse you, you accuse me, then we insult each other and fight about it.

I see the other ICs here not doing anything either. I've tried to do something about it, and no one has bothered. They're still making the same mistakes I pointed out.

Apologies mod, I'll replace in any of your other games now or in future if you need want as repayment.

[Primate]

Hey, SV, if you want something to entertain you for a bit, I'm sure I could throw some proper analysis together, in a couple of hours time.

Don't leave me alone wiv all the newbies.

Let me bounce a few ideas off you, 'k?

[spectrumvoid]

I'm sorry, but no. I rather play in games where decent playstyle is the norm, and where actual strategizing is required. I don't see the other ICs here making any effort to salvage this either.

Case in point: nightfall.

[Machiavellian-Mafia]

It’s time for the fourth vote count of the day!

8 - scotmany12 (RafK, Twito, panzerjager, nightfall, SenFive, ~N9V~, The Central Scrutinizer, Fircoal)
4 - Battle Mage (ChannelDelibird, cheesefan, Blue Gatorade, TheJiveMachine)

2 - ChannelDelibird (Primate, Battle Mage)
1 - Twito (spectrumvoid)
1 - panzerjager (Mariyta)
1 - Blue Gatorade (Dagger)
1 - No Lynch (scotmany12)
1 - ~N9V~ (ShadowLurker)
1 – JDodge (autoload)

Not voting: Chaucer, pevergreen, JDodge, Canucklehead17

Remember with 24 alive it takes 13 to lynch!

[JDodge]

ok now for analysis..umm i think Jdodge and scotmany are scumbuddies..they have pretty much ignored each other the entire game and have not and wagoned on BM..scotmany is just really bad scum..being a bad newbie doesn't mean your a bad townie as everyone has seem to guess.

Confirm Vote: Scotmany, HoS: JDodge

I don't see the case on scotmany, actually. I'll have to reread and see for myself. I wagoned on BM originally; I unvoted for fear of putting him too close to lynch. I'm trying to keep an open mind that a lot of these players are newbies; prone to make many mistakes. I could probably be considered as part of that category as well. If I remember correctly, whatever scotmany did to deserve this wagon seemed more like a newbie town mistake than a newbie scum mistake. But I'll have to go over it again.

[JDodge]

Okay then... I rescind that previous comment... He doesn't want to be considered a newb, so I'll take that out of the equation. And then I see what he did, and how he defended himself, I can REALLY see the case against him now. Really looks like scum who doesn't know how to play the role.

[scotmany12]

I just don't really care anymore. Anything I say you twist against, which you will most likely do with this vote too. Right now I have no idea how to defend myself instead of simply saying I am a townie, but that is not good enough. So lynch me if you want, I honestly don't care anymore, the town has already lost this game.

[The Central Scrutinizer]

I'm sorry, but no. I rather play in games where decent playstyle is the norm, and where actual strategizing is required. I don't see the other ICs here making any effort to salvage this either.

Case in point: nightfall.

That's a fascinating point.

unvote, vote:nightfall

[Mariyta]

Yeah, not seeing the case on Scotty. People need major justification for such a wagon so early... I need proof, people!