Bastard Mod mafia - GAME OVER!

[TBuG]

a) This is Bastard Mod, so I doubt it's even.
b) There was a traitor, and in my experience the traitor is a wild card, not really counted in the numbers of how many mafia there are.

I'm gonna go through in a minute and see if anything looks overly suspicious to me, if anyone else wants to as well, please do.

[Primate]

PBuG, the obvious notable point in that is the n2 killing of MoS, after the SK was dead. Considering the lack of other kills, though, I wouldn't be surprised it was the SK, otherwise the killer would have killed again by now.

Also, considering his win condition, I am unsure if Fritz should have been counted as part of the mafia. If the kills didn't say otherwise, I would think that there wasn't a mafia, and MoS was only there to create what was (I assume) a masonry with two scum and no town. But there are the kills, so there probably is a mafia.

3-3 seems too few for a 25 player though. On the other hand, 4-4 seems a litle harsh, especially with a town that will screw itself, causing mislynches of it's own back. When you add to that the SK, Dahen's 'mr burns' role, and PbuGs necessary lyncher thing, it becomes less likely. That said, Vismaior included 5 mafia in a 20 player vanilla game, which I'd consider harsh, so I think it could be mistaken.

I'm assuming this game is kind of balanced, despite it's setup though. Not because it'd be fair on us, but more along the lines of the mod wanting the game to last as long as possible, so more of the bastard nuances could come out.

[TBuG]

Der Hammer posts rarely, and generally goes with the flow when he does.

ubertimmy often goes with the town, but not always. He didn't believe CD's vig claim and wanted him lynched.

Fortimate (Fortify/Primate II) generally gives off a town vibe, though he seemed to be kind of floating along by actively lurking. Believed my town claim.

Romanus (previously Green Liquid) trusted Glork and changed his vote from M4yhem to Fortify. If we still have a werewolf left, which we probably don't, it's him. Claimed Paranoid Cop, which is very easy to fake (I have done so in the past).
Green Liquid was mostly focused on vigging and then lynching DGB. That could verify the cop results, though, as Day 1, he was all for vigging, but Day 2, after supposedly investigating DGB, he was for the lynch.

CES has a post restriction, which although it isn't 100% sure, implies town. He generally gives off a very protown vibe, but he was eager to trust my "cop" results.

Dur Magemark (bethelmark/Dur-Galad/dragyn_mage) hasn't posted too much. Dur-Galad was generally unhelpful in his posts, when he made them. bethelmark voted for Shamrock then disappeared.

Thok has generally been helpful and pro-townish.

Based on that compunded, I am leaning towards either a Der Hammer or ubertimmy lynch. That in mind,

Vote: ubertimmy

.


BTW, Primate, thinking about it, I have a theory about DGB. I think she was time-delay, planting an explosive during the day that would explode at night.

I'm going to look over MoS to try and find any valid connections to living players.

[TBuG]

Only one connected to MoS is me, and I'm confirmed.

[Primate]

PBuG, how exactly are you confirmed again?

Not that I'm challenging it, I just don't remember.

[TBuG]

Ah, wait, looking back over it, I'm not. I forgot that the voice (which I also thought was a note, not a voice) was proven to be wrong when we lynched Toaster Strudel.

[TBuG]

Note to self: Check things over before you actually attest to them being fact *sigh*

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

Crazy PBuG. (ylbaborP nwot.)

[TBuG]

So, anywho. Here's my list of who I think is town, who I'm not sure about, and who I think is scum.

Town:
Cogito Ergo Sum
Primate
Thok

?:
Romanus
dragyn_mage

Scum:
Der Hammer
ubertimmy

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

Let us hcnyl ymmitrebu?

[TBuG]

That's what I want to do.

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

Vote: ubertimmy

[Romanus]

Vote ubertimmy

[Thok]

I'm willing to wait for ubertimmy to give some sort of defense or something.

[TBuG]

Agreed.

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

Thok = Coward.

[draygn_mage]

Hold it right there Romanus.

I want to know why you jumped off the M4yhem wagon and went after Fortify.

vote Romanus

[ubertimmy]

WHOA

ok

i'll claim

I am a MASON

with KALEIDOSCOPE. I sent him a PM at the beginning of the game, he NEVER talked to me once. We didn't have confirmed innocence. But it was JUST the two of us in our group - there must have been another one. But that's the truth.

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

Hmm, I dah demussa Kscope was nosam htiw MoS and ok_la. gnitseretnI.

[ubertimmy]

I know, right. It's weird. 2 pairs of mason tho, it mustve been.

[Primate]

Is there a bastard aspect to your role, or are you just a normal mason?

[TBuG]

Unvote

for now,

Vote: Der Hammer

Although I agree with dragyn_mage, I do want to hear why Romanus switched votes.

[draygn_mage]

*feels incredibly happy that he helped nail scum first game day in*

*worships at the feet of AniX- he who hunts by sense of smell*

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

*slaps some ytilibisnes otni draygn vehemently*

[Romanus]

I'm not sure what you all are talking about. I jumped off fortify and hammered M4yhem, or am I looking in the wrong place?