The Fortnight (Game Over)

[T-Bone]

I'm fairly content with DGB's list.

[DrippingGoofball]

THE SCUM, FOR YOUR WEIGHING AND CONSIDERATION:
GuyInFreezer > read of game still incomplete? Suspicious stalling.
JacobSavage > I made case a few pages back. Feels sorry for difficult scum wincon.
BBMolla > caught for "wrong reasons" in #378.

OS, give me detailed reads on the three players above.

DETAILED.

[zoraster]

mod can you verify this?

The game lasts 14 days unless 9 players vote to end the game earlier after the Day 1 lynch. There is no real night stage. So you can divide your time between Day 1 and post-Day 1 however you want, though a lynch must be made before moving to post-Day 1. The thread will not be locked until the game is over.

[Oversoul]

THE SCUM, FOR YOUR WEIGHING AND CONSIDERATION:
GuyInFreezer > read of game still incomplete? Suspicious stalling.
JacobSavage > I made case a few pages back. Feels sorry for difficult scum wincon.
BBMolla > caught for "wrong reasons" in #378.

OS, give me detailed reads on the three players above.

DETAILED.

How detailed are we talking? I can give you cliff notes version if you want since that really all I spent on brainpower in reading them.

GuyinFreezer - he could be stalling scum I will admit that because I have seen him around the site during the course of last night/today.
I believe at either 10:20 AM or 10:20 PM there was a lot of activity in this thread and he made a post in Mafia Discussion but didn't comment here. I thought that was odd given this game requires that everyone be active in order for the town to get anywhere.

I didn't like how he called me town and then immediately turned out and called me scum. Seemed like a very Fate thing to do just to try and send out feelers or look town.

I don't understand his most recent post addressing you DGB because he called Quil's RQS stupid/pointless but it looks town because he is bringing that up from earlier in the game as something he probably legitimately does not understand.

If I had to say anything about his alignment definitively, I'd probably be okay with listing him as town.

Jacob, I think is town.
I don't really see where you are getting this super scum vibe from Jacob for multiple reasons.
1) You accused Venmar the Neighbor in First Time Mafia for exactly the same thing (woe is the scum) that you are accusing Jacob here. If anything shouldn't your first reaction be to remember how you were wrong in applying that tell the last time you used it? Off shot of that... why the fuck would any scum say that publicly. That is something you bitch to the moderator about.
2) The "wishy washiness" about my wagon isn't really wishy washiness at all. I think it is fairly town since we are currently playing 3 games (if you count this) and applying meta from one game to another concurrently while playing another I think is a townie thing to do even if it is fakeable.
3) What do you mean he is "hung up" on the fleeing buddy?

This post is literally the only one of his that even mentions the word and it hardly seems "hung up"

VOTE: Ghostlin

Seems jumpy.

Is on most of the major bandwagons, looking like he's trying to get a lynch any lynch that isn't him.

Probably scumbuddy that will flee.

Thanks you can sheep me now.

That post also has the added cockiness line at the end which I don't think Jacob as scum would ever do. THen again I have never played with Jacob scum

The last point of your case is legitimate but by and large I consider your "case" bunk.

I think Jacob is probably town for the reasons I mentioned earlier countering your case.

BBmolla I think is town because of the audacity for his "if you chose me you lose" statement. It reminds me of his matter of fact and no fucks given minimal posting that he did in invitational 14 (the one that Nexus modded).

Looking at his iso there and his iso here, the games are pretty similar and it is a vibe that I get from BBomlla that he is town.
His "I can do one case better" in response to the "caught for the wrong reasons" point you bring up looks like he wants to teach Kid A a lesson more so than anything else given the perceived (on BBmolla's part) stupidity of the reasoning behind Kid A's vote.

So yeah.

I think your entire scum list is likely town DGB. If at the end of the game that happens to be true I want to hydra with you as a teaching lesson.

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

Can we go back to lynching OS, DGb?

[kuribo]

OS you listed reasons why GiF is possibly scum.... then call him town?

[DrippingGoofball]

Can we go back to lynching OS, DGb?

Don't worry we will, but I'm a leave-no-stone-unturned kind of gal.

[DrippingGoofball]

OS, your detailed read on Benmage please.

[T-Bone]

Nah I think we can move GiF to the town list. He was legit on v/la, even if he was slow to catching up with this game. His attempts to catch up seemed genuine enough to me.

I'm feeling one scum between OS/Jacob/BB/Ben, and 1 scum in the rest of the playerlist. One of these four players is scum, and their partner is chilling because the majority of the playerlist is writing that person off as town. I just haven't decided who that player might be.

[BBmolla]

I'm not scum g fiznit

[Oversoul]

OS you listed reasons why GiF is possibly scum.... then call him town?

Those were the thing that I felt were scum from his iso, but my overall feeling of him as a whole is that he is likely town.

DGB tends to play up the real life excuses tell more than it is actually useful.

[BBmolla]

Unless you're Kid A, calling me scum is scummy itself.

[DrippingGoofball]

DGB tends to play up the real life excuses tell more than it is actually useful.

Sorry scum, that's one tell that pays off in spades.

[kuribo]

Unless you're Kid A, calling me scum is scummy itself.

Why Kid A?

[Oversoul]

OS, your detailed read on Benmage please.

To expand upon what I said earlier, I thought his "plan" was suspicious as fuck and possibly a concocted attempt to gain town credit for misunderstanding something.

I thought he was town for his attack on you + trying to analyze the playerlist as a whole in terms of playing ability.

Recently I don't like how he gave up on trying to get you lynched, publicly planned to lynch someone he thought was town (although "less town than the others"), and then turns around and votes for the same person I am voting.

Because of that he is a weaker townread.

Kuribo, if you want me to list those 3 in terms of towniness to better help you understand my reasoning, it is Jacob > BB > GIF t

To compare, GIF and Benmage are near each other in that they did some weird and suspicious things, but overall I get a town impression from their slot.

Meanwhile, CES continues to ignore my questions and in general be useless. And I still don't get why DGB thinks that he is town.

[Kid A]

Unless you're Kid A, calling me scum is scummy itself.

Why Kid A?

im village idiot apparently

[DrippingGoofball]

So, OS, other than CES, everyone is a town read.

CES is the only player you are reading as scum.

Who's CES's buddy?

[kuribo]

If i day his name three times, will greygnarl appear in the thread?

greygnarl

greygnarl

beetlejuice


err i mean greygnarl

[GuyInFreezer]

No you gotta put "SCUM" at front to call him.

Anyway, I've been digging up CES's game and none of his game (regardless of aliignment) was entirely contentless like what he's doing in this game. O.o

So I'm even more confused on CES, because posting short seems to be his playstyle, but lack of content is quite bothering.

[GuyInFreezer]

Fyi I read two of his newbie game (town) and one of his /invitational game (scum)

[GuyInFreezer]

None of his game that I've read*

[Oversoul]

No, I don't have a read one way or another where I am confident on Grey or Kanye.

[DrippingGoofball]

No, I don't have a read one way or another where I am confident on Grey or Kanye.

But you're

confident

that CES is scum.

[Oversoul]

Yes

[DrippingGoofball]

Nobody's strongest read is CES, ever.