Well I kinda did a re-read. Interestingly, Twito was kinda pushing hard for an ubertimmy lynch before anyone got on board. However, there really was no evidence to push for. So - it's still not a tell. And considering at that point, there was very little ubertimmy was giving us, it's even more of an anti-town tell. However, the way that Twito keeps on mentioning his position on the ubertimmy lynch makes me think it's more luck than anything else. Twito may say it's skill that got him on the ubertimmy lynch, but I think it's just luck. If Twito could manage to explain any reason why he was on ubertimmy that early, I'd give him props for it. Otherwise, I see Twito as being reasonably pro-town, but his actions...not necessarily.
So before I finish my read, I'm going to put my three suspects: molestargazer, Kelly Chen and Save the Dragons/Twomz.
Kelly Chen, first, since that's where my vote lies.
Mostly it was gut that got me, plus there was a lot of interesting things she decided to not address. But now I can find crap to back it up. Oh and by the way, my KC and StD are based on gut feelings, and everything that I'm posting now is just crap I'm throwing together to make me look better.
118 wrote:I get that pablito is being silly, but his joke about Sherlock's posts doesn't make much sense to me. Also, metagaming, bailing on a game when scum strikes me as something Sherlock would do. I need to look for some evidence for that, but if I do, god help you pablito.
I think bird, Twito, and Tamuz are ok. Not actually sure on MSG. I would like to ask Twito for his other thoughts on the game. At the moment I don't think he should be followed on ubertimmy.
Shortly thereafter 121-123, c_d and KC get into a heavy discussion over pretty much nothing, but nonetheless, I see it as KC instigating it.
At this point in the game, while voting C_D was very justified, in retrospect, I'm not getting it. I actually find c_d to be pro-town, and seeing KC and StD attack c_d early upon their replacing, I feel less confident about their alignment. oh, and coincidentally all three of my suspects voted c_d at that point right after another. I doubt all three are scum together, but I find them to be my best suspects.
Oh and another instance where KC instigated a fight with C_D was over the whole OMGUS definition statement. Very useless. But also a bit hypocritical. Twito's argument on it was that c_d was trying to find something to say about nothing, but KC discussing and taking the whole argument to a different level was doing the same thing.
KC knows how to ask the right questions, but I feel she's doing it without a healthy pro-town curiosity. And bah, the whole argument between C_D and KC at that point after the OMGUS definition was very annoying to read.
The best thing KC has going for her is that she actually participates and gets people to think about their actions, which is something scum can do as well, but also KC did help kick off the timmy wagon, but by that point, Dead Rikimaru made a good post to start the timmy wagon phase 2. I still find it humorous that ubertimmy was lynched within 2 hrs since my vote just happened to fall there and all other previous votes were there for ages.
But I've never remembered KC to be the human-interest reporter on the local news channel. She's been asking way too many questions in this game, and I don't remember that. It's really what caught my interest before.
When I voted KC, I wanted to see her reaction, but I was more interested in other people's reactions and I wanted to see how KC might react to other people itching to vote her. Well TCS kinda hinted that he might vote KC, and then KC didn't really comment on TCS' scumminess, considering how she attacked him before. I also noticed that she seemed to be less inquisitive after that point. Something changed, and that's alarming and thus I keep my vote because something smells wrong.
MSG
218 wrote:Whoops!
Sorry all!
pablito, I think that that vote (which is almost random) doesn't seem helpful in this stage of the game. Surely we need to find who's the scummiest and get this day over with before the deadline, not pick off those who have been voted on before, randomly with a dice roll.
Very bad post in retrospect.
228 wrote:*Yawn*
Morning all!
Hey Jack! Mike said to give you a cheer, so... cheer.
Anyway, down to the matter at hand.
I find it odd that no-one has died, although I've never played any mafia variations before. Any ideas, anyone?
bah, the classic first post of the day mentioning the no-kill. I've been trained by the wiki to value this more as a scum tell than doctor, however, we've just recently all discovered the madbomber theme.
270 wrote:
Is there any particular reason for that other than you want to lynch an inactive? I don't think you're doing what's best to try and get us a good lynch.
FoS - Pablito
However..
MC wrote:
I'm just waiting for something scummy to happen. So far, I see nothing wrong.
I personally think you've got plenty to go off right now, especially if you read back a page. There's even been things happening since you were here.
With that and also your completely useless posts - I've not seen a single one of value - I think I've found my vote.
Vote - Masterchief
MSG on the MC wagon was just way too opportunistic. Extremely opportunistic especially the way MSG tried to stick with the MC wagon no matter what anyone thought. MSG's voting pattern and D2 actions were just too wacky to be pro-town.
StD
I don't really have a case. But I found Twomz to be somewhat suspect for not saying much. And StD doesn't really say much, and as we've learned in this game, not saying much is a common thing. However, if we're to take this whole mad-bomber multi-SK setup as what we're dealing with, I could find StD and also KC's behavior as SKish. And then StD pops out of nowhere and asks for TCS' suspect list. It's very interesting.
Next to go is StD, I kinda want TCS to go next because I'm curious to see what he has to say, but since I've got a gut feeling on StD, I should see his next, plus I know StD will likely pick TCS to go next afterward.
Sup, later.
