NY 162: A Week at the Theatres (Game Over)

[Bacde]

He's going to claim I tin of Tomato Ketchup, I just know it.

posting so that the next claim will be at the top of the page

[Bacde]

KingdomAces - Day Mason
Smashbard - Day Mason
JacobSavage -Vanilla Townie
roflcopter - Vanilla Townie
petapan - Vanilla Townie
Oversoul -

ZONEACE -
PeregrineV -
Bacde -

[Oversoul]

VT
Sorry I was dealing with family/financial issues

[Bacde]

KingdomAces - Day Mason
Smashbard - Day Mason
JacobSavage -Vanilla Townie
roflcopter - Vanilla Townie
petapan - Vanilla Townie
Oversoul - Vanilla Townie
ZONEACE -

PeregrineV -
Bacde -

ZONEACE you're up buddy

[ZONEACE]

I'm the Gunsmith

Night 1 - failed to submit a target in time (I was a couple hours late)
Night 2 - Bacde - No Gun
Night 3 - KA - No Gun
Night 4 - Peta -

GUN

Thus, Peta is scum.

Bacde, KA and Smash (and me) are Town.

[PeregrineV]

I'm Vanilla Town.

Vote: Petapan

[roflcopter]

well i'm standing by peregrine as the second scum.

vote: peta

[ZONEACE]

Before we quick lynch Peta can we discuss how we're going to move forward. There's still some work for the town to do.

We still have to rout out 1 scum.

After peta is dead we'll be at 7-1, with 4 of those 7 confirmed town.

We're looking at Pere, Rofl, OS and Jacob as our pool containing the last scum.

[KingdomAces]

Okay, while it is true that I requested replacement, for some reason I decided that just posting it in the Mason topic was enough that I didn't have to PM it also, but MattP didn't notice it. Due to recent developments though, it looks like having a player that's been reading the whole time would be better than getting a new one to start from scratch, even if the new one would be better in the long term.

Anyway, in case I didn't already, I'll confirm that I am masons with Smashbard, and I did make a crumb of this myself if it is needed.

I see no need to doubt ZONEACE right now. If Peta is town, then we just lynch ZONEACE, and if they're both scum then ZONE will run out of places to hide before long.

My reads so far have been terrible, so I'm probably just going to be voting from here on out instead of actually analyzing, but of the four non-clears, PV seems like the most likely scum to me.

I know this sounds stupid and pointless, but there's still one role possibility that needs to be mentioned at this point: Mafia Doctor. MrZepher seemed convinced for some reason that there would be a vig in the setup, and having a Mafia Doctor on his team would explain that. It is a role that also fits with the day-vig and gunsmith, since the gunsmith would get a false positive on the day-vig and a false negative on the doctor, and therefore be less powerful than it seems aside of masons and a bodyguard. Basically what I'm saying is that while you should still trust positives, you shouldn't put the game on the line for a negative result.

Anyway, I'll keep following along, and if I get a chance I'll look over some more things, but I'm not going to promise anything other than being able to vote on time. Not voting until we're ready to end the day.

[PeregrineV]

Votecount

MrZepher

-

1

[L-9]

TheTrollie

Bacde

-

1

[L-9]

ZONEACE

Nobody Special

-

1

[L-9]

ActionDan

Dramonic

-

2

[L-8]

MrZepher

,

wind-up

petapan

-

1

[L-9]

greygnarl

greygnarl

- 10

[L-0]

Human Destroyer

,

Bacde

,

Nobody Special

,

PeregrineV

,

petapan

,

Konowa

, roflcopter,

Smashbard

, JacobSavage,

Dramonic

NOT VOTING:

Go-Oversoul,

KingdomAces

The first lynch of day1

Bad-ass update.

[PeregrineV]

Nobody Special

-

6

[L-2]

Oversoul,

ZONEACE

,

ActionDan,

Smashbard

, JacobSavage,

Human Destroyer

HumanDestroyer

-

6

[L-2]

Dramonic

,

petapan

,

PeregrineV

, roflcopte,

wind-up, Nobody Special

ActionDan

-

1

[L-7]

KingdomAces

NOT VOTING:

Bacde

WITH [14] ALIVE IT TAKES [8] TO LYNCH

Nobody Special

-

6

^[L-2] Oversoul,

ZONEACE

,

ActionDan

, S

mashbard

,

Human Destroyer

HumanDestroyer

-

8

^[L-0]

Dramonic

,

petapan

,

PeregrineV

,

roflcopte

,

wind-up, Nobody Special

,

JacobSavage

,

Bacde

ActionDan

-

1

[L-7]

KingdomAces

NOT VOTING: nada

WITH [14] ALIVE IT TOOK [8] TO LYNCH

Human Destroyer was Lynched. He was a Mafia RoleCop

EVERYONE SHUT UP AND WAIT FOR MATTP/DR. PRODUCER - I CAN'T LOCK THE THREAD

For my reference later. Because with this and the Zephyr and Day1 lynches, we should be able to glean info.

Updated. I think Oversoul is more likely partner based on above, but will check ISOs later.

[PeregrineV]

Before we quick lynch Peta can we discuss how we're going to move forward. There's still some work for the town to do.

We still have to rout out 1 scum.

After peta is dead we'll be at 7-1, with 4 of those 7 confirmed town.

We're looking at Pere, Rofl, OS and Jacob as our pool containing the last scum.

Sure. At this point my preferred order is
Oversoul
Jacob
Rofl
me

[Smashbard]

Alright well with Zoneace clearing Bacde officially, I think we've pretty much got this in the bag.

Lynch Peta today, Zoneace probably dies in the night because the scum seem to love having two Masons around to box them in further and further.

From there, we lynch Rofl and it's gg.

[Bacde]

KingdomAces - Day Mason
Smashbard - Day Mason

JacobSavage -Vanilla Townie
roflcopter - Vanilla Townie

petapan - Mafia

Oversoul - Vanilla Townie

ZONEACE - Gunsmith

PeregrineV - Vanilla Townie

Bacde - Unclaimed

Updated claims

[roflcopter]

from there you lynch rofl then make a sad face when he flips town after being right about everything you were wrong about all game, then the next day you lynxh peregrine and win (or jacob the day after that if necessary)

[Bacde]

KingdomAces - Day Mason
Smashbard - Day Mason

JacobSavage -Vanilla Townie

roflcopter - Vanilla Townie

petapan - Mafia

Oversoul - Vanilla Townie

ZONEACE - Gunsmith

PeregrineV - Vanilla Townie

Bacde - Unclaimed

Updated claims

since I might die tonight
these are my townreads from a quick reread of the beginning of the game

[ZONEACE]

from there you lynch rofl then make a sad face when he flips town after being right about everything you were wrong about all game, then the next day you lynxh peregrine and win (or jacob the day after that if necessary)

You were right about me?

[petapan]

hi okay this is a complete bullshit fakeclaim and a simple look at the setup should be enough to tell you that he's making it out of desperation because he knows his time is up otherwise and wants to get one more mislynch off

gunsmith is effectively a cop in this setup, we've already had 3 PRs flip + masons in an 18 player setup. that's slightly above a mini, but essentially masons are so powerful in most small setups they get used as a replacement for an investigative role, having them side by side is essentially gamebreaking given the possibility of producing a ludicrous amount of clear town

we've already had jailkeeper flip which is a pseudo-investigative role as well as bodyguard plus a dayvig, even if you discount the protective roles it would be possible to have 6/7 players cleared as town by day 4 of the game with 12 alive and a vig shot, which is literal autowin - that's worst case scenario for scum but yeah a gunsmith would be ludicrously overpowered do i need to build a case here as to why he's scum or are we just going to sheep the claim without a regard for setup balance

[petapan]

http://forum.mafiascum.net/search.php?s ... &start=325

how exactly was he a few hours late of submitting a night action when he was posting the entire time the thread was in night phase

[ZONEACE]

It's an admirable try Peta.

[petapan]

fuck off with the smug scum lines

[Smashbard]

It's a win-win situation for me.

If Peta flips scum, the last scum will kill Zoneace tonight.

If Peta flips town, we lynch Zoneace tomorrow.

Either way Zoneace dies before end game so I'm happy.

[ZONEACE]

It's a win-win situation for me.

If Peta flips scum, the last scum will kill Zoneace tonight.

If Peta flips town, we lynch Zoneace tomorrow.

Either way Zoneace dies before end game so I'm happy.

yes, because the loss of a useful power role is AWESOME.


you're really a dick.

[Smashbard]

Well if peta flips town we wouldn't be lynching a power role Zoneace now would we?

I'm not a dick. I just like to see you rage everytime I mention lynching you. So...yeah that does make me a dick now doesn't it? lol.

[Oversoul]

Peta you are willfully ignoring Zone's posts that pretty heavily corroborate his story

VOTE: Peta