Usually we asked about all of us. Well, TNE sometimes came up.
The last I asked them, I asked all of read about the player. And that was Sora answer. TNE never came up.
Sora ever asked about Buldermar jumped in and though of the plan. I responded the most about the plan. TNE have a new plan with doctor claim. Well you know it.
In post 1427, Remembrance wrote:Last question: Go into detail about one conversation you had about one read that you talked the most about.
The last read I asked to them? I asked all of their read, because I find something interesting, I like to discuss it to them (well, I can't tell it in thread).Even though that they weren't respond it.
Because I already have read in other player, I told my read about Mantis, IaI, and Kuroro. Well, that was Sora's respond. And no other respond. I think Sora still's busy. He promised had other read 3 days ago, but never came up. TNE never came after his V/LA.
^ I expected clear answers and elaborations of your hydra discussions that would allow me to know if you were referencing(you did this earlier) those discussions as a lazy town tell as scum, or whether they were legitimate discussions by a town hydra.
In post 1271, Remembrance wrote:I noticed it, but it's such an obvious agenda playing. He can't possibly believe it is going to work. Aren't scum more subtle about this kinda stuff?
How could Wisdom go about discrediting me in a subtler way?
Isn't it a bit late to be voting someone for being lazy?
1. For example, like Mollie. She has super secret personal tells for town and scum you right? "he hasn't dropped that tell" leads to instant suspicion, if people buy into the ethos reputation that she has worked on building. She brings in her reputation, mentions other successes in other forums, where she always gets lynched day 1 for being such a threat to scum. If you buy it, this lends credence to the idea that you might be scum.
2. Never too late, it often brings them out of their laziness.
a. There are two aspects to this game type for town IMO. Night game and day game. We want to correctly lynch scum in the day, and investigate or protect the right people at night. If Fate continues playing as he has played, he is not contributing to the day game. Similarly, like you said, can investigate Wisdom at night, so why kill someone who might be actively contributing over someone who only has worth as a power role so far?
what are you even talking about here I never said I was lynched on d1 I said I have been the n1 kill for over a year and a half.
nacho isn't looking too uncomfortable so I am retracting my scum read on him.
lol, and no I would not lynch nacho on d1 unless I was absolutely sure about it
I meant that, it was a typo. All I meant is that there are much more subtle ways to create suspicions of a slot, and unintentionally or not, you aroused suspicion in the slot. I was giving an example, as requested by Nacho.
You've retracted your read but not your vote, Mollie. There may be a slight contradiction with line 2 with line 3 in your post, by voting him. But contradictions aren't really scum tells. Much to many a town's chagrin.
Both Remembrance and SE-Asians look town to me from that exchange.
Remembrance shows genuine intent to try and read the slot with his questions, while SE-Asians also tries to answer the questions as effectively as he can, without giving out information that might be better kept hidden.
In post 1437, Remembrance wrote:I meant that, it was a typo. All I meant is that there are much more subtle ways to create suspicions of a slot, and unintentionally or not, you aroused suspicion in the slot. I was giving an example, as requested by Nacho.
You've retracted your read but not your vote, Mollie. There may be a slight contradiction with line 2 with line 3 in your post, by voting him. But contradictions aren't really scum tells. Much to many a town's chagrin.
-I don't consider having opposite reads is a scum indicator in any way. On the other hand if you think he just came up with those reads and have no real reasons behind them then it is something I definitely agree as scumtell, but you should try to prove it and not just sit on the accusation alone.
-I don't understand why that interview Remem did to Asians was enough to call him obv town, sounds like buddying to me. (Or did I misunderstood what Asians said?)
-I see it as scum hydra. Why being a hydra if you are not even discussing your reads with the people you know have the same alignment as you? I guess the whole point of being a hydra is that one. If they are not doing it, it means there is no real interest on scumhunting (not showing in the thread and not on their QT according to Lincolm) which means scum to me.
ebwop: Regarding the post wisdom just made. The hydra is one of the main lynch options at this point. They already claimed. So what kind of info could be so important to kept hidden? I really can't think of anything worth kept hidden in that situation, but maybe that's just me.
I do believe Remem is town but I don't think that interview was any helpful to determine if he is town or not. Those interviews are more related to his play style than alignment related, so null there for me.
In post 1442, kuror0 wrote:-I see it as scum hydra. Why being a hydra if you are not even discussing your reads with the people you know have the same alignment as you? I guess the whole point of being a hydra is that one. If they are not doing it, it means there is no real interest on scumhunting (not showing in the thread and not on their QT according to Lincolm) which means scum to me.
That's a null point considering it's their first time as a hydra. It's not like we're talking about an experienced hydra who usually discusses in length.
In post 1442, kuror0 wrote:A few things I want to say before going to sleep:
-I don't consider having opposite reads is a scum indicator in any way. On the other hand if you think he just came up with those reads and have no real reasons behind them then it is something I definitely agree as scumtell, but you should try to prove it and not just sit on the accusation alone.
-I don't understand why that interview Remem did to Asians was enough to call him obv town, sounds like buddying to me. (Or did I misunderstood what Asians said?)
-I see it as scum hydra. Why being a hydra if you are not even discussing your reads with the people you know have the same alignment as you? I guess the whole point of being a hydra is that one. If they are not doing it, it means there is no real interest on scumhunting (not showing in the thread and not on their QT according to Lincolm) which means scum to me.
ebwop: Regarding the post wisdom just made. The hydra is one of the main lynch options at this point. They already claimed. So what kind of info could be so important to kept hidden? I really can't think of anything worth kept hidden in that situation, but maybe that's just me.
I do believe Remem is town but I don't think that interview was any helpful to determine if he is town or not. Those interviews are more related to his play style than alignment related, so null there for me.
- erm....I have played lots of games with nacho. when he is town our thoughts usually fall into line although certainly not always. town tends to move in herds, blah blah blah I don't really feel like explaining it unless you are actually interested.
Much to many a town's chagrin.
