The questions for GIF were meta questions. Particular to his play. They were personalized.
I never said AP was not town. I said he's competent and I believe he's competent as scum. You already know what my reads are like. I use them much the same way, I use a note board, of who I am going to pay the most attention to.
When I give a scum list, I am saying, the people's posts I will go through with a finer toothed comb. Also, just because my posts are short, does not mean I don't analyze the shit out of people's posts. And wall afterwards when people ask me to explain why.
Not sure if I believe your claim 100%.
Based on the role description, even-night recruitment checker would make sense, but Odd night recruitment checker? That basically makes Night 1 check useless.
According to OP, Recruitment checker checks if person is recruited a night before. What would checking anyone at night 1 do? The result will always comes up negative and that's stupid. Therefore, I don't entirely trust his claim.
Why would I even add the odd into there? I'm not going to wifom this further.
Not the cult leader. I only say that when I'm town. Meta my only scum game, where I avoid even mentioning I'm town that game. It was awesome, I even warned the town player that the scum team could hammer, LOL.
I believe Remembrance's claim on the surface. The claim itself is kind of worthless role as he pointed out (so why fake it?)
In post 2, zoraster wrote:2. The Cult Leader may have a power role in addition to being the Cult Leader and may both recruit and use his action at night.
When I read this, I kind of expected the CL to have a minor pr - mod wifom, but why put this in the rules otherwise?
That said, Odd night recruitment checker is (entirely?) useless on a cult leader except possibly for fake claiming purposes. I tend to think Remembrance would have claimed full recruitment checker anyways if he were a CL with that power.
It's worthless to mention, I'm very aware. But I'm town this game. The more I say it the less people believe it. ~~~ So there's no reason to mention it as scum.
Kid A wrote:
don't like this, you are currently in a position where claiming anything other than town would be against your wincon
@Gif, what do you think of this post?
@Ap it's only relevant to me, because of how I play as scum.
I'll be throwing that meta away now. Since it's risky, and too many players know it now. But for now, you can buy it. But if you don't like it, just ignore I said it. I've done other stuff, this shouldn't bother you.