Robotics Mafia Mini 347 - Game Over

[Maz Medias]

STD
PlaysWithSquirrels
Mastermind of Sin
PookyTheMagicalBear

[Mastermind of Sin]

i'm here

STD, PWS, POOKY

[PlaysWithSquirrels]

Ya.

Pooks, StD.

[Save The Dragons]

not last

List = Pooky

i will try to post something of content in the near future, this game has fallen off my radar.

[PlaysWithSquirrels]

Same as STD =/.

I think Pooky's contribution to the game amounts to something like 5 posts. And that's being generous.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

well its 6 now.

[Thestatusquo]

Vote: Pooky

[PlaysWithSquirrels]

Vote: Pooky

[Mastermind of Sin]

I don't think Pooky is the play today. I'll try to post something substantive this week.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

I see you guys have forgotten Romanus started a bandwagon on me Day1 and he turned out to be scumbag?

seriously what's the reasoning behind this bandwagon?

[PlaysWithSquirrels]

If you're trying to make the case that Romanus isn't that dumb, you are doing a bad job.

[Glork]

Beginning re-read.

[Glork]

Okay, the whole "who replaced whom" thing started getting me confused, so I'm posting this here as a reference to myself and to others:
Ibby replaces Bacde
PJ replaces Nonny
Maz replaces EnderX
TSQ and StD replaced HIAB and Lordy, I think... but there is no mentioning of either replacement gig in any of Coron's posts. (Okay, TSQ replaced HIAB, so StD must have replaced Lordy. Correct?)

HIAB never responed to my comment about his following of Bacde's horrible logic in Post 47[/ur;]. Not really anything TSQ can do about that, but I wanted to note it anyway.

First thing I noticed is that Romanus FoS's Pooky in Post 88, even though he was already voting Pooky. Pushing the wagon without climbing aboard? Distancing? Undecided right now, though leaning towards PookyTown. Either way, it seems Romanus simply forgot that he was voting Pooky. (At least, in my experience, somebody who FoSes someone they are already voting mentions it as a "confirmation" FoS or something.)

Eleven posts later (Post97), Romanus abandons it. There seems to be a little Pooky/Romanus interaction.

Romanus then *joins* Pooky in attacking Scalebane. Definitely noted!

Post 117, HIAB is already talking about hammering Scalebane and basically asking more people to pile on.

Scalebane claims SK, people are a little WTF'd, Scalebane gets hammered and modstomped. I didn't find anything interesting in all of that. If anything, I'd say that someone eager to just throw down the gauntlent and kill Scalebane is more likely to be scum. "He claimed a scum role, let's just kill him and end the day!" Nevermind the fact that we could still be discussing a lot of things. There were a couple of solid wagons and a few counerwagons. Mini black marks go to HIAB and MoS for that one.

Post 168... votes Romanus because his Ibbyvote has the last basis and is basically admitting a bandwagon vote.

Post 171, Lordy: "Oops, I was lurking. Hi. What's going on?"
Post 172, Pooky votes for Lordy. I find it *slightly* odd that Pooky would slap a vote for what I see as very typical Lordy behavior, but the vote makes sense all the same.

<<NOTE: I wandered off for an hour because we just moved our cats from our old house to our new house, and I was helping get them out of cars and acclaimated to their new home.>>

Post 211 sets off the scumdar BIGTIME. I get the "Hay, I want to vote Romanus, but I'm going to find an excuse not to do so yet" vibe from the first part. The second part sounds like little more than pure filler, as he piggybacks onto MoS's post to give a non-opinion on Bacde.

Enter Glork's previous re-read in Post 319. Projects Romanus+HIAB. I like where this is going. (I always feel a little reassured when I notice that multiple re-reads turn up same/similar suspects. It makes me think I'm on the right track of things.)

In post 331, TSQ (replacing HIAB) says this:

I don't want to join any wagon, Ibby. I re-read the thread, and started thinking, maybe around page 6 "Why the hell is Romanus not lynched yet."

When I finish this re-read and post, I'm going to re-read the first 6-7 pages and see whether it should be obvious that Romanus is scum. Maybe TSQ just has damned good instincts. Maybe he's trying to bus. I can't tell at this point, but this definitely warrants a second look.

...okay, so TSQ explains himself in Post 333. I still want to look things over for myself. (In fact, I just thought of something. After this post, I have a handful of questions I want to ask TSQ.)

The PJ-Ibby fight I merely skimmed, as both players died pro-town.

Enter Day Three.

Glork votes PWS, StD makes a case against PWS, PWS goes "I vigged Ibby. Oops!"

Post 395, MoS makes his suggestion -- MoS, while I didn't re-read with the intent of looking for connections between living players, I do think I found some potential Romanus-connections. I'll look over everything once more and try to make some projected scumpairings once I finish this up and ask TSQ the stuff I want to ask him.

Oh yeah, TSQ claimed to be an ability-tracker. I had forgotten about that. There goes my TSQscum theory. >.<

Post 459 doesn't really sit well with me. Romanus could have distanced from PookyScum (as I mentioned earlier) just as easily as he could have tried to wagon a TowniePooky.



...so let's see. All game, Bacde/Ibby, HIAB, and PWS have pinged the most for me, yet it seems unlikely that any of them are scum. I could easily see EnderX-Maz, Pooky, or Lordy/StD as lurker-scum. If it's only one of them, I definitely think that . I could definitely see Pooky as scum, but I find it much more likely that StD is scum right now. Unfortunately, both of those players have lurked enough that I don't think I could find the "go look for player interactions/connections" if I wanted to. The only thing I saw was Pooky's vote for Lordy, which never really went anywhere. Weak distancing? Possible.

I'mma

Vote: StD

, with an

FoS/IGMEOY: Pooky, Maz

. I'd like to see some substantial contributions from each of these three players.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

huzzah

vote STD

i knew Glork would come lead us to the promised land

[Glork]

Apparently I can't use tags properly, though. Stupid typo. >.<

[Glork]

Also, Pooky, what do you think of the fact that I implicated you nearly as much? Are you simply ignoring that possibility?

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

Glork loves me

If he's implicating me, it's to make the scumbags think twice about killing me

He can't be serious about thinking I'm scum.

[Maz Medias]

How many living scum are we looking at at this point?

[Glork]

How many living scum are we looking at at this point?

....

Look at the dead roles, go find out which living claims are out there, and take a wild guess.

[Maz Medias]

How many living scum are we looking at at this point?

....

Look at the dead roles, go find out which living claims are out there, and take a wild guess. :roll:

Considering that alignment isn't shown in the dead list and that my internet is rolling slower than Tiny Tim, it's understandable that I asked for a hand.

[Glork]

Dead:
SK
Godfather
Doc, Roleblocker, "Masonizer"


Claimed living:
TSQ -- Activity-Tracker (sees if a player took an action that night)
PWS -- Vig (Killed Ibby -- seems to be confirmed)

[Maz Medias]

That's what I wanted to know: if the RB was mafia or town RB.

[Maz Medias]

That's what I wanted to know: if the RB was mafia or town RB.

[Coron]

unless otherwise specified roles are town.

[Save The Dragons]

Post 211 sets off the scumdar BIGTIME. I get the "Hay, I want to vote Romanus, but I'm going to find an excuse not to do so yet" vibe from the first part. The second part sounds like little more than pure filler, as he piggybacks onto MoS's post to give a non-opinion on Bacde.

Ummm...I'm sorry lordy did that? I dunno how to respond other than giving lordy the benefit of the doubt since I know his role.

I know that's not substance but that's all I can say at the moment. I'll say more soon.