After going through the more players' ISO's, I have come to the following conclusions:
: There is a lot that strikes me as town, and yet a lot that strikes me as scum in this slot. He was very active and very vocal in the first day which is not often characteristic of scum, but he has since lost interest and has retreated to the side-lines.
HD's targets Day 1 (RachMarie Lynched): Tiger/Riot,
Mollie/B&B
,
Wisdom
, Mit,
RachMarie
.
HD's targets Day 2 (Chkflip Lynched):
Chkflip
,
KMD
.
HD's targets Day 3 (KMD Lynched): McQueen/Bacde, ProHawk, Mit.
HD's targets Day 4: Zab, Mit.
The biggest problem I see in HD's posts is that a lot of them seem feigned, especially his reads. He is largely inconsistent throughout the game with his reads and his votes. I am not going to go into a lot of detail here about it, but if anyone wants to see the evidence, I would be more than happy to present it.
Mit's targets Day 1 (RachMarie Lynched): HD,
RachMarie
Mit's targets Day 2 (Chkflip Lynched):
Chkflip
Mit's targets Day 3 (KMD Lynched): McQueen, Jalyn,
KMD
.
Mit's targets Day 4: Zabriel
This cat is super, super cautious when it comes to voting. I don't really have much time to meta him and see if this is his normal play as town, but I generally feel gut-scum for players like this. There have also been a few scummy posts from him, especially recently. However, the vote and attack from KMD doesn't read like a bus to me, and him being wishy-washy on KMD also doesn't seem like he was trying to get any credit from a KMD scum-flip. I could be wrong though... while I would like to think that I was the person Mit saved from death, it may be skewing my view. All-in-all, as I mentioned in my VCA post, a Mitillos flip would shed some light on the counter-wagon to KMD's wagon. Another fact that is bugging me is he claimed the day before the no-kill. Why would scum chance trying to kill someone who might have been priested when they could have just killed the priest himself?
<---------------------- We need to lynch this one today.
Read This Again for my thoughts on the scummy aspect of his ISO.
Zab's targets Day 1 (RachMarie Lynched): TigerZone/CF Riot, HD, ThePuck/Jalyn/Nacho,
Siv/Rach Marie
,
DO/ChkFlip
Zab's targets Day 2 (ChkFlip Lynched):
Chkflip
Zab's targets Day 3 (KMD Lynched): McQueen/Bacde,
KMD
Zab's targets Day 4: HD,
Then we get this little gem...
In post 1067, zabriel wrote:VOTE: DO
I'd really rather not risk having no protection tonight. I feel pretty okay about the case on DO. I can do this or Mitillos today.
I am not sure if its just me, but he sounds way too sure that Rach's claim is real, and not wanting to risk going without protection sounds faked, real faked.
And this...
The real hammer comes from post #1197 by Chkflip. He was more than hesitant to follow through with his threat to hammer town.
Too tired to go through Riot, Bacde, Nacho and Cheery at the moment and is a whole-nother can of worms considering they have all been replacements. While Riot has been in for a while, I am willing to ride on his claim and his result especially considering the low number of cop-claims we have he is more likely than not telling the truth. I am a little less sure about Jalyn/Nacho but still don't want to lynch that slot today. Cheery needs to put out a lot more as Slimer gave us literally nothing to work with.
I would love some help lynching Zabriel today, but if you guys can't pull through and vote Zab... I would compromise on Mit.