Mini 378- R&GAS: GAME OVER

[Sherlock]

I think we need some justification from Rosso, not saying he doesn't have a good reson, he just hasn't shown it yet. I guess since I have to vote someone I will go for

vote: rosso_carne

. I'm not actually accusing him, just want some answers.

[serinah80]

Vote: Maz Medias

because I have to vote someone and your name is alliterative. That's it.

You are absolutely useless.
don't you actually read the forum? aren't you supposed acting to benefit the town?
don't you see we have to wagonners here???

I really want to vote you but as I see that but one vote usually achieves nothing I

unvote. vote Rosso

but Rosso hasn't been active in the other game I'm playing with him wither. I think he should be prodded.

Mod?

[The Central Scrutinizer]

Early bandwagons are far less likely to be indications of mafia than indications of town trying to gauge the reactions of the other players-- in my experience. Mafia generally play it a little safer until they can feel the game out. Unless it's Rosso, who for all I can tell is insane anyway.

[Maz Medias]

Early bandwagons are far less likely to be indications of mafia than indications of town trying to gauge the reactions of the other players-- in my experience. Mafia generally play it a little safer until they can feel the game out. Unless it's Rosso, who for all I can tell is insane anyway.

Nice WIFOM.

[rogue_two]

Okay, so I'm sort of back.

Can't remember why I was even voting for him anyway, so

unvote: Jules

.

Since I have to vote someone....

vote: bogre

because of the suspicious Rosso/bogre => ThAdmiral thing going on.

[The Central Scrutinizer]

Early bandwagons are far less likely to be indications of mafia than indications of town trying to gauge the reactions of the other players-- in my experience. Mafia generally play it a little safer until they can feel the game out. Unless it's Rosso, who for all I can tell is insane anyway.

Nice WIFOM.

Nice what?

[EmpTyger]

Votecount

3 Rosso Carne

(Jules, Sherlock, serinah80)

2 Maz Medias

(rich_25, The Central Scrutinizer)

2 ThAdmiral

(Bogre, Rosso Carne)

2 Bogre

(ThAdmiral, rogue_two)

Not voting: Maz Medias

[Maz Medias]

Early bandwagons are far less likely to be indications of mafia than indications of town trying to gauge the reactions of the other players-- in my experience. Mafia generally play it a little safer until they can feel the game out. Unless it's Rosso, who for all I can tell is insane anyway.

Nice WIFOM.

Nice what?

:wink:

Nice WIFOM.

Vote: The Central Scrutinizer

.

[serinah80]

Early bandwagons are far less likely to be indications of mafia than indications of town trying to gauge the reactions of the other players-- in my experience. Mafia generally play it a little safer until they can feel the game out. Unless it's Rosso, who for all I can tell is insane anyway.

Nice WIFOM.

Nice what?

Nice WIFOM.

Vote: The Central Scrutinizer

.

*running around, waving hands*
I've spotted an idiot! I've spotted an idiot!!

Why the blooduy hell did you vote Scrutinizer??

[serinah80]

oh, because of his vote on you?

I've spotted another idiot!!!
*running away from the mirror in panic*

[Maz Medias]

I voted for him because he dropped a WIFOMbomb, then joked about it, trying to be coy when I pointed it out.

[Rosso Carne]

on

i hadnt noticed that the site was back.

gathering thoughts tommorow.

[Jules]

Interesting that rogue_two decides to vote for bogre as opposed to rosso when he seems to suspect both equally and rosso is the one leading the votes. Surely if you suspect him to be scum, you would want rid of him?

[The Central Scrutinizer]

I voted for him because he dropped a WIFOMbomb, then joked about it, trying to be coy when I pointed it out.

Stop OMGUSing and be serious! This is a game, after all...

[The Central Scrutinizer]

unvote: Maz Medias

[Bogre]

Do you think rogue_two is scummy?

[EmpTyger]

Votecount

3 Rosso Carne

(Jules, Sherlock, serinah80)

2 ThAdmiral

(Bogre, Rosso Carne)

2 Bogre

(ThAdmiral, rogue_two)

1 Maz Medias

(rich_25)

1 The Central Scrutinizer

(Maz Medias)

Not voting: The Central Scrutinizer

[ThAdmiral]

Do you think rogue_two is scummy?

Is this aimed at anyone in particular or everyone?

[Jules]

Rogue_two is very high on my scum list after this post

Okay, so I'm sort of back.

Can't remember why I was even voting for him anyway, so

unvote: Jules

.

Since I have to vote someone....

vote: bogre

because of the suspicious Rosso/bogre => ThAdmiral thing going on.

[EmpTyger]

Act 1, Scene 6

“

HackerHuck

is now playing

rich_25

’s role.”
Recasts: a necessary evil.
“So

HackerHuck

is evil?”
He is necessary.
“How?”
Things are moving. And if we do not move with them, we may find ourselves left behind.

A deadline has been instituted.

Day 1 will conclude at the latest in 5 days, at

Saturday 12/16, 7pm (Central)

. I am sending notifications to each player. If no one has been lynched by deadline, the procedure outlined in the rules will take effect:

11) Deadlines will be imposed at the mod’s discretion. The following procedure will be reached if a deadline is reached without a majority decision:
If half are not voting (or are voting for no-lynch), then day will end without a lynch. If not (ie: more than 50% are voting for players), then the player with the most votes will be lynched.
If there is a tie among the players with the most votes, I will have everyone still in the game player PM me a vote for one of the tied players.
If this still does not break the tie, I will choose who is lynched at random from among the tied players.

Please PM me with any questions about deadline procedure.

Votecount

3 Rosso Carne

(Jules, Sherlock, serinah80)

2 ThAdmiral

(Bogre, Rosso Carne)

2 Bogre

(ThAdmiral, rogue_two)

1 Maz Medias

(HackerHuck)

1 The Central Scrutinizer

(Maz Medias)

Not voting: The Central Scrutinizer

[Jules]

We have a deadline...

I'm happy with my vote on Rosso and, until rogue_two explains himself, rogue_two will remain at second on my list

[HackerHuck]

Greetings to all. I will be doing a reread and contributing shortly. Since it looks like there is no longer a vote requirement, I will

Unvote: Maz Medias

Just an FYI, I have not seen the movie and my Shakespeare is many years old.

[Bogre]

UNVOTE VOTE: Rogue_Two

Shouldn't ya'll think I should vote for him because he's being scummy?

Secondly, shouldn't you all vote for him as well?

[Jules]

Why rogue_two and not Rosso, Bogre?

[HackerHuck]

Well, I’ve got a few questions to get me started.
The question game seemed to draw a fair amount of discussion and it seems as if it started to come up again. Could someone explain what it is, how it started and what the purpose was?
In looking at the mod’s list of acts, it mentions the timestamp error that was discussed in thread. Was the timestamp error specific to this game or was it site-wide? I don’t remember seeing a similar problem in my other games, but the term “error” makes me believe it isn’t a part of this game.
Is there anything Rich did during the outage that I need to be aware of? I noticed mention of some Jester controversy, but I don’t really want to miss out on anything memorable or relevant.

I’m also a little confused by what the game state means. Can the mod or someone clarify?

9) Votecounts will reflect the contents of the thread, not necessarily the actual game state.

I’m quite confused at this point. Just trying to decipher which are real votes versus random has been quite challenging and it appears that the system issues and lost posts have really harmed this game. I was hoping to have a more solid analysis, but this is what I've come up with. Sorry for the length.

I think the toughest part of this analysis is that most of the discussion revolves around things I (Rich_25) have done. I’m not trying to be egocentric here, but it seems like most of the other discussions aren’t that serious. I can’t really explain the odd behaviour of Rich, but it is not related to my role. I do want to go on the record that I am not a jester and being lynched is not a condition for me to win.

Can we get a reason for these votes? I try and only vote with a fairly good reason and roughly provable scumtells. Voting for no reason is really working against the town.

Look at post 51 it’s almost as empty as the ones he criticized.
This post is odd, simply due to the fact that Sherlock was voting for Rich at the time.

At least when I'm lynched my fellow townies can look back at this section and take out the scum who seem intent on getting rid of the stupid newbie.

You're not just a newb, you're an idiot! Have you been paying attention in the least. I think that you will win if lynched. Why the hell do I want you lynched?!

He didn’t unvote until four posts later.

Serinah is my top suspect, primarily based on her recent activity. She seems to be fishing here and I’m surprised no one noticed.

And BTW, again, I've seen my role in the mod's lenghtly posts frequently. is it the same for others or is it at random? I personally doubt it. I think he mentiones us all.... or what do others think?

She has also been vote hopping lately after not voting until she was forced. First it was Bogre, then this post:

Vote: Maz Medias

because I have to vote someone and your name is alliterative. That's it.

You are absolutely useless.
don't you actually read the forum? aren't you supposed acting to benefit the town?
don't you see we have to wagonners here???

I really want to vote you but as I see that but one vote usually achieves nothing I

unvote. vote Rosso

but Rosso hasn't been active in the other game I'm playing with him wither. I think he should be prodded.

Mod?

Single votes mean nothing, but Bogre was at two votes. Why pull it off? To me it warrants a vote, but with deadline looming it would just be a waste.

Rosso seems the next scummiest to me, but it could be his playstyle. I don’t much care for the way he seems to be directing the game. Since I find Serinah the scummiest, and she’s voting for Rosso, that’s causing me to question myself a bit.

The Central Scrutiniser has acted really strangely, so he’s also on my scum list. Based on his own belief that mafia play it safer, I’m tempted to think he is scum. He hasn’t voted too much and has been less willing to commit to an opinion. I’m leaning toward Maz’s opinion that he was being coy about the WIFOM comment. The fact that Rich was called out for his misleading use of the smiley, I would have thought that he would be more careful.

Rogue_two has a habit of pointing out my (Rich_25’s) scum traits, but has rarely backed them up with votes. That might relate to the jester issue, but it strikes me as a little odd.

Jules hasn’t posted much, but he does have a good point here.

Interesting that rogue_two decides to vote for bogre as opposed to rosso when he seems to suspect both equally and rosso is the one leading the votes. Surely if you suspect him to be scum, you would want rid of him?

I don’t find ThAdmiral to be scummy from what I have seen.

I don’t understand why Bogre jumped on the ThAdmiral bandwagon, but I’m not getting a scum feel from him.

Maz is just being Maz as I’ve seen him play in another game; however, he seems to be toned down a bit here. We’ve only been in one game, so I don’t know if that really means anything.

In summary, I’m leaning toward scum on Serinah, Rosso, and the Scrutiniser. The others are still up in the air to me.

Since we’ve got a deadline approaching, I’m going to go ahead and

Vote: Rosso

Hopefully this will lead to some more discussion.