Diffusion of Power (Open 478) over

[Human Destroyer]

UNVOTE:
VOTE: Mitillos

I'll take some of that wine. I have an immunity to poison.

[Mitillos]

Pointing out null-tells is WIFOM? WIFOM is not a null-tell itself? Whence did you pull all this out?

But seriously, I'm as bad a mislynch as Rach was.

[Cheery Dog]

Why were you on the reach wagon if it's as bad as yourself?

[CF Riot]

Why were you on the reach wagon if it's as bad as yourself?

Ooooooooooooooooooowned

[Mitillos]

I didn't know Rach was town, at the time. It was a bad wagon, in hindsight. If you see what I mean.

[Cheery Dog]

Well therefore the same thing is here that we don't know that you're a bad wagon at this stage, so that argument is invalid.

[N]

Jalyn has been prodded.

Vote Count 3.07

Mitillos

( 3 ) CF Riot , Jalyn , Human Destroyer

kmd4390

( 2 ) ProHawk , zabriel

ProHawk

( 0 )

mcqueen

( 0 )

Cheery Dog

theslimer3

( 0 )

zabriel

( 0 )

CF Riot

( 0 )

Jalyn

( 1 ) kmd4390

Human Destroyer

( 0 )

Not voting:

Cheery Dog , Mitillos , mcqueen

With 9 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.

Deadline is in

(expired on 2013-03-14 22:03:47)

[CF Riot]

Cheery stop being scummy and vote Mit for forgetting he was supposed to think Rach was scum.

[Mitillos]

I did think she was scum. I was wrong. As you are right now, for thinking that I am scum. Which is kind of what I was getting at.

[zabriel]

Why was it necessary to bring Rach into it at all?

[Cheery Dog]

Cheery stop being scummy and vote Mit for forgetting he was supposed to think Rach was scum.

I've not fully convinced that her doing that was a scum action yet though.

I did think she was scum. I was wrong. As you are right now, for thinking that I am scum. Which is kind of what I was getting at.

what about in relation to chkflip?

[Kmd4390]

Not that mit is a terrible lynch, but I think there are about three better ones...

[CF Riot]

Jayln is the worst one you could be voting. She gets temporary townpoints for not voting McQueen today.

[Mitillos]

@zab: It wasn't necessary. I was making a point.

@Cheery: A mislynch is a mislynch.

@CF: Because she somehow should have known his alignment, before you revealed your investigation results? That's a terrible argument. mcqueen hammered without waiting for a claim. Anyone who did vote him, before your claim, should be getting townpoints, instead.

@kmd: I am a terrible lynch, but there certainly are 3 people who are scummier than me. The scumteam. I think you're wrong about Pro, though.

[Cheery Dog]

@Cheery: A mislynch is a mislynch.

So why did you only bring up the one on Rach?

[Cheery Dog]

and the odd thing is you put both of them onto L-1. (which I don't feel like doing to you when I don't trust this playerlist to not quicklynch again)

[Mitillos]

*shrugs* Just picked one and brought it up. And yes, I was the penultimate vote in both the previous lynches.

[CF Riot]

@CF: Because she somehow should have known his alignment, before you revealed your investigation results? That's a terrible argument. mcqueen hammered without waiting for a claim. Anyone who did vote him, before your claim, should be getting townpoints, instead.

1) That's not the argument I'm making.
2) Chk responded to our intent to hammer with "I'm not claiming."
3) Until lynching town stops being something scum tries to do, lynching town is a scumtell. Jalyn was one of the few who didn't come out today guns blazing against a confirmed townie, so in that regard she's less scummy than all the ones who did.

[Jalyn]

Wait.

Jalyn has to be scum unless:
A) all three scum can be found in the mislynch wagons (unlikely)
B) CF is scum who lied about clearing mcqueen (still possible, but it's early enough not to worry about that chance)

unvote, vote jalyn

Interesting. Especially as Cheery Dog's former incarnation also wasn't on either the RachMarie or the chkflp lynch. So, why would you miss another player that fits your criteria? And, really, I have to be scum because I thought that there was a better lynch than RachMarie on D1 and never got in to talk on D2? That's an amazing analysis.

And what does B have to do with your argument? CF & mcqueen were each on at least one of the mislynches, so I don't understand your point.

Of course, since I lasted posted, Mitillos gave us such an awful "Obviously I wouldn't have been on both mislynches if I was scum" argument that I'm quite happy with my vote. (Which is not lacking in evidence - You voted for someone after they had requested to be replaced out and then used that replacement request as evidence against the person that cast the final vote. I tend to find using evidence that applies to you as evidence against someone else scummy.)

[Kmd4390]

Mit, if I'm wrong about prohawk (or zab/jalyn), you are next in line. And chances are I don't have the entire team nailed. So you really aren't a bad vote.

Also, your rach comment doesn't come off as "just picking one". Nothing you've said comes off as someone who thought the chkflip was terrible as well. And even if it did, this is horrible coming from someone who voted both.

unvote, vote mitillos

L-1

--------------

Jalyn, forgot about slimer. My bad.

As far as CF, I'm assuming him town for now. I was just accounting for the possibility I'm wrong.

Chk looked pretty ridiculously scummy to me. I didn't want to see someone replace into a 50ish page game in a scum slot and then get the old "*unvote* so the replacement can catch up" and then everyone forgets about him.

[Kmd4390]

although I gotta say you were pretty quick to show up when I voted you in comparison to your activity so far. Beetlejuice tell?

[Mitillos]

@CF: 1) So, what is the argument? 2) I already responded to that, when mcqueen said it. 3) He was NOT a confirmed townie, before you made your claim. At that point he had been a mislynch hammerer.

@Jalyn: Again, voting someone who's being replaced and hammering them are two different things.

@Kmd: Meh.

And because there have already been two rushed hammers:
Claim - Doctor, N3. That was why I picked Rach's mislynch, to bring up.

[zabriel]

Your point was that you were trying to softclaim N3 Doctor? The game is repeating itself and all that?

[Mitillos]

Trying. And failing, obviously.

[N]