Open 482: Popcorn Mafia {Game Over}

[Juke]

Explain?

[Cherry Nog]

HadMatter is probtown now I understand where his first post #11 came from. (my first thought when I asked about it was him wanting everyone to quickshoot people)

VOTE: mcqueen
Following N's thoughts about this, and #98 doesn't seem like something town would be posting either.

[HadMatter]

Dear Inno, one thing I'm thinking is that scum want townies shot. But what scum really want is to have townies shot that are likely to shoot town. So look out for scum voting people who are fosing likely townies. And try to shoot someone who is voting for someone else you'd like to shoot. So if you're wrong it's not a total loss.

[Human Destroyer]

Modvotes are scummy.

[Juke]

I just don't understand how they're more likely to come from scum than town.

[mcqueen]

Dear Inno, one thing I'm thinking is that scum want townies shot. But what scum really want is to have townies shot that are likely to shoot town. So look out for scum voting people who are fosing likely townies. And try to shoot someone who is voting for someone else you'd like to shoot. So if you're wrong it's not a total loss.

Are you dumb?

[HadMatter]

Dear Inno, one thing I'm thinking is that scum want townies shot. But what scum really want is to have townies shot that are likely to shoot town. So look out for scum voting people who are fosing likely townies. And try to shoot someone who is voting for someone else you'd like to shoot. So if you're wrong it's not a total loss.

Are you dumb?

Not at all. Are you?

[Bumfuzzled]

awestfie here, I've discussed shortly with Regfan regarding my reads, and this is currently what I have.

HadMatter

: You are currently our strongest town-read. Your concern about the win condition over on Post 9 came across as fairly townie to the both of us, mainly due to the fact that scum wouldn't be concerned about this. I also feel like his interactions with

CDB

, starting on Post 25 shows that they are most likely not partners, for the sole reasons that scum would try and move away from bussing in this setup, especially this early on.

Limo

: I feel like Limo's reaction test over on Post 5 was townie; scum would be less inclined to do a reaction test like this, especially when no one had said anything prior to the test.

Regfan

didn't think much of the test, until I brought this up to him, which he then agreed with my thoughts.

Juke

: We’re both getting town vibes from you because of the fact that you are actively scum-hunting and thinking things through, specifically Post 36 and Post 61, which

Regfan

already pointed out in Post 64 in more details. The only thing I didn't really like about you was Post 19 due to the fact that you didn't want to instantly explain your read, and wanted someone else to figure it out, for some reason.

Mac

: I didn’t like your reaction in Post 8 and Post 16, your reaction itself was bad and you followed it through trying to weaken it by saying it was a joke reaction.

Regfan

already pointed out how I felt about Post 34 in Post 78.

[Mantisdreamz]

prod received, sorry guys

Dear Inno, one thing I'm thinking is that scum want townies shot. But what scum really want is to have townies shot that are likely to shoot town. So look out for scum voting people who are fosing likely townies. And try to shoot someone who is voting for someone else you'd like to shoot. So if you're wrong it's not a total loss.

Are you dumb?

Not at all. Are you?

i think what the problem with this is that you said to look for those who are fosing

likely

townies. how are we going to know if they are likely town? i know there's obv town sometimes, but no one is going to be voting for them anyway.


channelbird said earlier that he didn't now many of the players. same thing with me. though, i have played briefly with mcqueen and juke (who i see is klick). oh, and limo.

[Mantisdreamz]

VOTE: mcqueen
Following N's thoughts about this, and #98 doesn't seem like something town would be posting either.

why?

[mcqueen]

Btw, who is "N?"

[mcqueen]

An Alt of the dude named N?

[Mantisdreamz]

An Alt of the dude named N?

it's a hydra of Cheery Dog and N.

this stuff seems to concern you quite a bit mcqueen

[mcqueen]

An Alt of the dude named N?

it's a hydra of Cheery Dog and N.

this stuff seems to concern you quite a bit mcqueen

im just trying to get to know the playerlist.

i told jal that i wouldnt pay a whole lot of attention to this game at first, as im in a lot of others, atm.

plus, this setup does not appeal to me at all. i have my voice and my vote, and now i dont even have my vote. what the hell am i supposed to do with my voice, im only good with it irl 1v1, im horrible with it on ms.

[Mantisdreamz]

i think it's going to end up being like a normal game. even though there's technically *no* votes... i think the shooter should take the counts into consideration... or go by that.

[Mantisdreamz]

do you still think madhatter is scum?

[Mantisdreamz]

wait... hadmatter

[Bumfuzzled]

I got some offline messages from Awetfie saying that she really didn't like Mantis's entrance into the thread. There's not really any unique content or reads from her at all, just fluff based questions and theory based discussion that doesn't lead anywhere. Think best chance of scum is inside her and Mac at the moment.

Also Reg, if you're town, this is going to be the game where I make up for Timeshift Mafia.

To be fair I still have some making up for that game to do as well. I found Sucroses lylo posts to be very genuine and started getting townish vibes from her which is why I really wanted Sora first but couldn't push myself to be more aggressive in asking for unvotes. Anyway for what it's worth I think Jukes town at the moment - his scumhunting is coming across as incredibly genuine, specifically his reconsideration of his town-read unprompted in Post 36 and his stubborness in letting go of his read on Mcqueen in Post 70 matches what I remember of his town-meta (I should probably go through a few of his games tonight though just to make sure I'm remembering it right though - bug me if I forget to get around to it). Him voting the mod is fairly null, think he'd muck around like that regardless of his alignment.

Could you please sign your posts, since you're a Hydra? Because I have no idea which head posted this. But I don't remember playing with either head of your Hydra, Regfan's name seems familiar, but I recall only seeing his name, not playing with him, and if I have, it's only been a game or two, I don't remember playing with him as Town and Scum.

It should be obvious whose posts are whose if you're reading them (Awestfie can sign her posts and all unsigned posts are mine if it's really that big a deal) and I hunted down the game that we played together because I wanted to give it another read through to remember what your meta was like but it looks like the crash ate the majority of it and only left the cotroversial ending to the game - It's NY 145 where I played as a hydra called Black Panther.

[Mantisdreamz]

I got some offline messages from Awetfie saying that she really didn't like Mantis's entrance into the thread. There's not really any unique content or reads from her at all, just fluff based questions and theory based discussion that doesn't lead anywhere. Think best chance of scum is inside her and Mac at the moment.

why could she not post that herself?
i have no reads at the moment... except, coincidentally i was thinking of voting mac.
so far, mcqueen looks townish to me.
not sure about Cheery Nog. i would like to hear why they thought mcqueen's post looked like it had to be coming from scum (or, not town).

[Mantisdreamz]

also bumfuzzled, speaking of fluff, what about your last 2 paragraphs?

[Regfan]

why could she not post that herself?

She wanted to hydra so she could 'learn' from me which means discussing reads and seeing if we're seeing things eye-to-eye rather than playing the game as two separate players. Can you run me through your Mcqueen town-read please because the phrasing of your Post 112 doesn't come across as you reading him as town.

also bumfuzzled, speaking of fluff, what about your last 2 paragraphs?

There's no way you can be reading that as fluff at all, none. It's a response to Mcqueen asking where we've played in the past and trying to get HD not to shoot a town-read of ours by explaining it to him. Your "Speaking of fluff" just comes of as an attempt to de-credit us since we have a scummish-read on you.

[Bumfuzzled]

Mine. (Sorry mod, won't post from the wrong account again).

why could she not post that herself?

She wanted to hydra so she could 'learn' from me which means discussing reads and seeing if we're seeing things eye-to-eye rather than playing the game as two separate players. Can you run me through your Mcqueen town-read please because the phrasing of your Post 112 doesn't come across as you reading him as town.

also bumfuzzled, speaking of fluff, what about your last 2 paragraphs?

There's no way you can be reading that as fluff at all, none. It's a response to Mcqueen asking where we've played in the past and trying to get HD not to shoot a town-read of ours by explaining it to him. Your "Speaking of fluff" just comes of as an attempt to de-credit us since we have a scummish-read on you.

[Mantisdreamz]

why could she not post that herself?

She wanted to hydra so she could 'learn' from me which means discussing reads and seeing if we're seeing things eye-to-eye rather than playing the game as two separate players. Can you run me through your Mcqueen town-read please because the phrasing of your Post 112 doesn't come across as you reading him as town.

also bumfuzzled, speaking of fluff, what about your last 2 paragraphs?

There's no way you can be reading that as fluff at all, none. It's a response to Mcqueen asking where we've played in the past and trying to get HD not to shoot a town-read of ours by explaining it to him. Your "Speaking of fluff" just comes of as an attempt to de-credit us since we have a scummish-read on you.

i'm not trying to de-credit you. though i do have a tendency to get my back up at ppl who look like their trying to find scum reasons for my posting.
and you *did* talk quite a lot about other games in that post. yes, you said that jukes looked town to you. but other than that it was just ..stuff that didn't have much to do with this game.

@1st paragraph - fair enough.
i liked mcqueen's response to my question.

[Bumfuzzled]

i'm not trying to de-credit you. though i do have a tendency to get my back up at ppl who look like their trying to find scum reasons for my posting.
and you *did* talk quite a lot about other games in that post. yes, you said that jukes looked town to you. but other than that it was just ..stuff that didn't have much to do with this game.

The 'other games' things were responses to people asking me questions about other games ie. Mcqueen wanting to know where we've played together before and wanting our posts to be signed and HD talking about our last game we played together. So again not seeing any possible way you can consider that as 'fluff'. I'll take a look at your games to see if you are more inclined to FoS people that have scum-reads on you as town tomorrow though.

[Mac]

Well, I seem to be picking up a bit of heat here for literally nothing, but I digress. How else am I supposed to react when the first post says to shoot me? I haven't been on this site long but I could only assume that, without me having even posted, Limo was kidding.