Diffusion of Power (Open 478) over

[N]

Vote Count 1.25

Disturbed_One

( 3 ) Wisdom , RachMarie , zabriel

Mitillos

( 0 )

kmd4390

( 0 )

RachMarie

(replaced Siveure DtTrikyp)

( 5 ) kmd4390 , CF Riot , BeautyAndTheBeast , Human Destroyer , ProHawk

ProHawk

( 1 ) theslimer3

mcqueen

( 0 )

theslimer3

( 0 )

BeautyAndTheBeast

( 0 )

Wisdom

( 3 ) Disturbed_One , mcqueen , Jalyn

zabriel

( 0 )

CF Riot

( 0 )

Jalyn

(replaced The Puck)

( 0 )

Human Destroyer

( 1 ) Mitillos

Not voting:

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

Deadline is in

(expired on 2013-02-28 20:30:20)

zabriel is V/LA until 28th of Feb

[RachMarie]

Also keep in mind that early on was a bit fluffy as I tried to get my bearings after all I replaced in after 35 friggen pages on D 1... That was a LOT to go through, especially with so many replacements.

[zabriel]

Doc might as well be VT when all you've got is Cop and Doc to choose from.

McQueen's vote bothers me too actually. I dislike when people vote for people they claim to have town reads on.

PEdit: No, that game is over isn't it?

I'll go flip through some of her town games to see. Rach, do you have any more games you replaced into you can share?

[Wisdom]

@mod

mcqueen is voting RachMarie

[zabriel]

Wait, you were MZB in Author weren't you?

[RachMarie]

You missed a vote N

McQueen put me at L-1

nope it is still ongoing Zab

[RachMarie]

Yes I was MZB in Author

[RachMarie]

I posted a rather large list of town and scum games that I have completed with their links Zab

[Wisdom]

So Rach can you sum up what your scum reads are at the moment?

[zabriel]

Could have sworn that game was over.

Yeah, nevermind then. I'm just remembering the whole "God is sexist" thing from Author.

[N]

I did not count mcqueen's vote in 1083 because he did not format it correctly.

When making votes, please use the vote or bold tags.

For a vote (or unvote) to be counted, it must be at the start of a new line.

[Wisdom]

Oh, okay.

[RachMarie]

In order from Town to Scum

Town
Wisdom
HD
CF
Milt
Slimer (even if he is useless)
Hawk
Jaylyn (not much here but what he has posted feels like Town)
Zab
Kmd (even though he has done squat so mainly gut here and weak read).
McQueen (beginning to have real doubts here so moved down).
DO (beginning to doubt he is scum) So moving up the list. (though maybe a bus going on here).
B and B

and with that

VOTE: B and B


(though I will switch back to DO if needed to prevent a NL).

[Wisdom]

Why is B and B scum?

[RachMarie]

Gut mainly... And the sudden pressure since I claimed to try to get me lynched anyways. Reminds me of Majiffy in Cult Mafia when he was the SK....

[Wisdom]

Can't he just be tunneled town? I have seen Majiffy tunneling (on me) as town.
Weird that you put him as your top scumread just for that.

[RachMarie]

Yes and I know Majiffy could be... But like I said usually he pokes at me and then moves onto another person when he is Town. I wish I had a bigger sample size though of him being scum in games with me, then it would be stronger. Also can't forget Mollie in this, She rarely thinks I am scum. So the real push, especially after I claimed and stating outright that my claim is fake... Majiffy is usually smarter than that and so is Mollie. Why would they push so hard to get me lynched as Town after I claimed. After I even offered to be tomorrow's lynch if ya all still feel I am that scummy, so I can do my protect tonight?

Like I said more gut than case at this point, but it is bothersome that they are being so determined. Both of them have played enough games with me to know I suck on D 1. I am a big picture person and it takes me a good while to really sort peeps out completely. They also should know that I generally do not try to fake claim a PR as scum cause I know that backfires on you badly. You may get off one day, but it comes back to bite you in the butt soon enough. Overall when I am scum I keep to the truth as much as I can and still stay in my wincon.

[Wisdom]

So what would you claim if you were scum?

[RachMarie]

I usually claim VT

[Wisdom]

There's no VT here though

[RachMarie]

In this set up I would have avoided claiming. I certainly would not have claimed up front before I was even at L-1 with intent to hammer.

Most likely would have lurked til after I was hammered.

[RachMarie]

I most definitely would not have claimed a N ONE Doc hello? Scum would have wanted to claim at least Night 2 or 3... And more likely Cop instead of Doc.

[ProHawk]

I most definitely would not have claimed a N ONE Doc hello? Scum would have wanted to claim at least Night 2 or 3... And more likely Cop instead of Doc.

There are different scum-motivations for claiming what they claim.

1) Make a believable claim that people won't want to lynch.
2) Force a counter-claim.

The problem with 2 in this setup is that there is a possibility that roles can double-up. So there is no surety that there aren't two of the same roles. That makes counter-claiming that much more risky. Hence, the more tactically sound claim for scum would follow the first motivation, which is exactly what your claim was attempting.

So either you didn't do any real research on the setup, or you are trying to make a play on players who aren't familiar with the setup to avoid being lynched.

[theslimer3]

Inb4 I get NK'd

[RachMarie]

pfft Slimer

hawk this is the first time I have played in a setup like this. Only other setup where I played and it was all PRs was Medical Mafia and I was a Nurse turned Doc the first time, and a Doc the 2nd time. And no I really did not take much time to look at the setup, I was too busy catching up on 35 pages of posts.