Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Legacy (Game Over)

[pidgey]

How much weighing in do people need to do?

Scum = Yates/AngryPidgeon/Nero Cain

could he just be right

[pidgey]

sleep

[jasonT1981]

All right.

Im just suddenly really fearing an AP/Myk team, like in the back of my head its knocking like "Yo......."

Though its probably Acos+Someone. Pretty sure.

Explain why no one targeted me with an ability to confirm my role for the entire game, then. I claimed day 1, my first post.

I am confirmed town by that.

This game is garbage. Let's go with some kind of decision.

you're NOT confirmed town.

Saying it 200 times doesn't make it true.

Why would a town role risk killing themselves just to test a PGO claim
Why would scum risk death and lowering their numbers to confirm you.

Stop changing the reason why you are confirmed.. first it was MyK actions now its no actions have been made on you....

[jasonT1981]

In fact, asking a power role to target you to confirm you would be scummy in itself as you would be asking town to sacrifice a power role just to confirm you...your role is claimed, and virtually useless in that respect, but you expect town to sacrifice a useful role to confirm your useless role no one would target anyway?

you know no one would do it hence your claim, you're scum.

[pidgey]

Ok so i've been thinking for the past half an hour. Im pretty unsure on who to vote for, and even if I choose correctly im dying tonight cause im confirmed at the moment.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uBvOK2ebPBo hearing this btw

I made a list of pros and cons in a notebook i was keeping with notes from each of the players. There are many things that make me doubt my reads, but right now my biggest town read seems to be jason after a reread. These are just bulletpoints.

AP kinda buddied Yates a whole fricking much at the beginning of his play and this is what has made me redoubt this player. That, and he was in practically every lynch besides zabriel, but cmon, that guy was getting lynched no matter what. So my big townread on AP has dissolved a bit, but i still dont think he is the most likely to be scum out of everyone that is alive. Still, dont count him out at all in endgame.

Nero Cain has a bunch of failure at times but at other times he's looked town too. One thing he has been a lot is consistant but that could also be some easy scum play, so i dunno. The automatic neighborizing shit, not using his power on the cop, not trying to confirm aco, and other stuff here and there really pissing me off. So I could easily see him as scum, plus I've also seen a lot of scum players saying the line "Unless he is trolling" when someone HAS to be confirmed town from their point of view. Like, many times.

Jason's claim still sucks but im not sure if thats an indication of a lazy player that doesnt really have any sort of curiosity of his role. I keep comming back to how awkward his claim was and also to how he discovered yates, and kinda isoed him and shit which looked dumb, so again, i wouldnt put my money on it, but I guess he is my best bet on town right now.

Mykonian has sooo many negatives, I think. Telling tammy constantly that the cop should be shot if he really was town, the fights with me which were ridiculous, and not confirming acosmist for one. There are many more I can think off but im too lazy to type them at the moment, but the general feeling im getting in this endgame is "who gives a fuck".

Acosmist though, I think is lying. Not only does he look desperate for a lynch and has also ridden a lot of damn wagons, but his attitude in general has been really scummy. I do NOT like that yates was on his ass, so im not sure if voting him is the best decision, but yates could have just been a busser to the rest of his scumbuddies since he was a simple goon. But the fact that remains that if Acosmist was really a PGO, then the scum would have basically lost the game really easily. Also, i feel we have never been provided the information we needed regards his role. He never really asked his death flavor, and other points like that. I dont know how much pappums would have liked MGS to make this role actually happen.

With all that said,

vote: Acosmist

This puts him at -1.

Death QT forgive me if Im failing, i really put my heart the last days.

Let's see how this goes...

[pidgey]

unvote

Wait has myk even claimed a character

[pappums rat]

Votecount 8.10

"It's spooky! She knows more about you than you do!" -Ronald Weasley
"Who doesn't?" Harry, Harry Potter and the Philosopher's/Sorcerer's Stone

Nero Cain - 2 (AngryPidgeon, Acosmist)
Acosmist - 2 (jasonT1981, mykonian)
mykonian - 1 (Nero Cain)

Not voting - pidgey

With 6 alive it takes 4 to lynch.

The deadline for Day 8 is 11 PM EST on January 20, 2013.

[pidgey]

Id want myk to claim character before revoting

[Nero Cain]

In fact, asking a power role to target you to confirm you would be scummy in itself as you would be asking town to sacrifice a power role just to confirm you...your role is claimed, and virtually useless in that respect, but you expect town to sacrifice a useful role to confirm your useless role no one would target anyway?

So why is Aco scum for this but AP isn't?

[mykonian]

unvote

Wait has myk even claimed a character

I only claimed my role. Well, AP did, which is why I never claimed my flavour.

I'm perkamentus, using felix to bring the messages around.

[jasonT1981]

In fact, asking a power role to target you to confirm you would be scummy in itself as you would be asking town to sacrifice a power role just to confirm you...your role is claimed, and virtually useless in that respect, but you expect town to sacrifice a useful role to confirm your useless role no one would target anyway?

So why is Aco scum for this but AP isn't?

Does AP claimed role kill whoever targets him though?

[pidgey]

Wtf is perkamentus

[Nero Cain]

no but he was screaming and yelling for me to target him and when I didn't want to he

half heartedly

pushed the messenger to do it. So I don't see much difference in the two.

perkamentus is one of the teachers at hogworts. He has a really big beard.

[pidgey]

So dumbledore from my google

vote: Acosmist

[AngryPidgeon]

VOTE: Acosmist

[Nero Cain]

GOD DMNIT!!! FUCKIN' SCUM ap HAMMERED!!

[AngryPidgeon]

Beat you to it

[mykonian]

Fuck. That's a scumclaim. Who was your partner AP. Pidgey?

Wtf is perkamentus

yeah, sorry, that's the Dutch name. I did it from top of my head.

[AngryPidgeon]

I just cant believe how much bussing happened all game.

[Nero Cain]

god damn all you silly ass wankers that had a town read on this guy. This also means I was right about atleast one of the vts being scum.

[AngryPidgeon]

pidgeys town obviously >.>

[mykonian]

god damn all you silly ass wankers that had a town read on this guy. This also means I was right about atleast one of the vts being scum.

sorry nero. I don't think you could have convinced me. He looked so town, so obvious. I didn't want to doubt that.

[Nero Cain]

its Myko isn't it? Maybe I could buy Jason.

[mykonian]

It wasn't me. And if you are playing like this and still scum you are a fat bastard. So yes, I assume it's jason.

[AngryPidgeon]

I thought Yates Voteparking him for a shit reason all Day on the NL was a give away. I was so ready to bus that.