Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Legacy (Game Over)

[mykonian]

know what.

vote acosmist

This works always.

[Acosmist]

scum or the worst town ever? only excruciatingly long time will tell!

[mykonian]

sure dude, stay in your role.

[Nero Cain]

I mean we have a cop, doc, tracker, 3 shot nieghborizer.

We have a claimed ghost, PPO and confirmed messenger.

Against one goon, one roleblocker, a one shot extra kill role and a possible strongman. that doesn’t look like a weak scum team at all.

and don’t forget that we were up against an unblockable SK

But we have 11 vanilla townies, 2 investigation roles, a protection role and a networking role. Against

that

.

AND

ya’ll are claiming that 2 of Jason, Aco, Myko are lying? Making a weak town even weaker? I just find that hard to believe.

I’ve already explained my read on Aco. Ben had a town read on him day 1 when he play was similar. And I think his role makes some sense.

Aside from vt, Myko has the weakest claimed PR and AP claiming that Myko’s is more powerful is borderline WTF. don’t care what anyone else says, AP’s play was scummy and shitty. I mean, AP is playing like 3rd party, his play is scummy as hell but him acting like he’s afraid of the scum night kill doesn’t look like scum but it doesn’t exactly look townie either.

So yeah, ets go with the Myko/AP team.

[mykonian]

heh, now pidgey didn't hammer him he has to call him town. This is just amazing.

[Nero Cain]

So why would Pidgey as scum not hammer me?

[mykonian]

suppose you are town, he would have. which is why it's just funny how you have to switch your pair around again now. He forced you to. You can't suspect pidgey anymore... heh.

[Nero Cain]

how can you ignore viewtopic.php?p=4652911#p4652911

Its a fair point I guess but even if he's scum then he'd have to have a buddy right?

In your opinion, do you think Myko and AP buddying each other back and forth is town on town? Scum on town? scum on scum?

[pidgey]

No fkn idea but i think AP is town.

Right now im just glad if we lynch one of the scums.

Me and nero arent scum together or we would have hammered acosmist right now btw.

So im like, incredibly clear right now.

[pappums rat]

Votecount 8.9

"You're crocked, aren't you?" -Big Boss
"I am merely drowning my sorrow." -Granin, Metal Gear Solid 3

Nero Cain - 2 (AngryPidgeon, Acosmist)
Acosmist - 2 (jasonT1981, mykonian)
mykonian - 1 (Nero Cain)

Not voting - pidgey

With 6 alive it takes 4 to lynch.

The deadline for Day 8 is 11 PM EST on January 20, 2013.

[Nero Cain]

suppose you are town, he would have. which is why it's just funny how you have to switch your pair around again now. He forced you to. You can't suspect pidgey anymore... heh.

So you're suggesting that Pidgey is just trolling me? No, if he were scum he'd of hammered me. If you want to call it backtracking or whatever you want then fine but I highly doubt he'd just fuck with me as scum. Therefore he's town.

p-edit you need to vote myko, Jason too

[pidgey]

Im not sure we have until sunday, ill try to gather my stupid thoughts...

[Nero Cain]

Pidgey, what do you think of my setup speculation that 11 vts seems unlikely?

[mykonian]

you had them half a page ago. Damnit pidgey, stop second guessing.

At some point in mylo or lylo, you add up everything you know, you stripe people away who really aren't it and stop doubting them, and at some point you pick the guys who have to be scum then. That's your best effort, and you couldn't do more. And yes it sucks if you lose because you made the wrong decision, but at that point you believe you can't make a better one.

[pidgey]

I think its very likely.

I believe the extra kill comes from the SK, though obviously there is no way to know this. Though my theory gathers strenght from the fact that Tammy was on Zabriel D1 so maybe she planted it n1 and just kinda parked her vote there to not be the hammered.

So I dont think the scum has that.

So its a goon, a RB, and 2 unknowns. More than likely a rolecop because of how quick they got the Doctor etc. Probably a strongman or something because they got the cop fast too (or the doc was an idiot)

And we only have 3 confirmed roles (possibly 2 more) so yeah, I think that more than having 11 VT is OP, i think that having a damn PGO is OP.

[pidgey]

Myk can you repeat who have you messaged everyday? Im sorry if its annoying, but I just want to know that while I reread and I really dont remember all your targets

[mykonian]

I do.

tammy, mastin, mastin, ap, ap, missed, ap

we've had 7 nights? yes, then these are the ones.

[mykonian]

I think I'd even be allowed to quote them... it's not from a QT nor posted by the mod. Might be a bit liberal in my interpretation of the rules.

mod, can I?

[Nero Cain]

IDK, Thor kill seemed kinda random. Although a rolecop on his slot makes some sense too. Which brings me to one of the other stupid things AP has said this game. In a random post he said something like "I doubt mafia has a role cop unless there are two teams." Other then being pants on head there seems to be little point. Do you think this maybe him trying to hide them having a rolecop?

[pidgey]

All right.

Im just suddenly really fearing an AP/Myk team, like in the back of my head its knocking like "Yo......."

Though its probably Acos+Someone. Pretty sure.

[Acosmist]

All right.

Im just suddenly really fearing an AP/Myk team, like in the back of my head its knocking like "Yo......."

Though its probably Acos+Someone. Pretty sure.

Explain why no one targeted me with an ability to confirm my role for the entire game, then. I claimed day 1, my first post.

I am confirmed town by that.

This game is garbage. Let's go with some kind of decision.

[Nero Cain]

I know the extra kill and the sk was the same kill flavor but daysk with an extra kill seems unlikely. Giving mafia an extra killing role is quite common these days, so I think it was just generic bomb flavor.

[Nero Cain]

Remember that AP also had a town read on Aco but wanted me to target him and kill myself and didn't really want the messenger (the weakest pr) to target him.

[pidgey]

Ive seen scum claiming PGO before and get away with it. Ive also seen millers.

No matter if you are scum/town, you got away with it because people were too dumb to not test it. I know I would have.

Though if you are scum it would be weird why you and not the goon mafia claimed PGO.

Again, lots of doubts.

[mykonian]

Ive seen scum claiming PGO before and get away with it. Ive also seen millers.

No matter if you are scum/town, you got away with it because people were too dumb to not test it. I know I would have.

Though if you are scum it would be weird why you and not the goon mafia claimed PGO.

Again, lots of doubts.

Make a list for them and write down what makes you think these things. Order stuff. Just stop running around in circles, it really isn't helping us.