Mini 1404 - Monopoly Mafia - Game Over

[MonkeyMan576]

1. Did you write this post as you read the thread?
2. You missed NumberQ. Any thoughts on his play?
3. I don't see why you place Medhi as town. Can you give me why this is?[/quote]

as per #505 I have two property cards. I also have a worthless community chest card I got last night.

I just got a pm from the mod saying I got a third card during the night he forgot about.

Can you please elaborate more on this?

[/quote]

1. Yes
2. He hasn't posted much, but he voted Lurker, who ended up being scum, so he's probably town.
3. He seemed to post useful content until he got caught lying.

I got boardwalk, it gives me the vigilante power to kill one player each night. I just got this today so I haven't used it yet.

[guille2015]

I got boardwalk, it gives me the vigilante power to kill one player each night. I just got this today so I haven't used it yet.

That wasn't the intent of my question, but given that you are at L-1, this is as good as claiming in this game.

I wanted to know why you said: "As of #505..." That confused me. Then you said that the Mod forgot to tell you you had a card. I want to know how that event transpired. Paraphrased of course.

[SafetyDance]

Why is there a giant wagon on mehdi? 0.o

People like to follow roles blindly without scumhunting or using any logic.

(see: policy lynching millers)

I found two guys who haven't read a thing this day! Ignorance slip *hi5*

I got boardwalk, it gives me the vigilante power to kill one player each night. I just got this today so I haven't used it yet

.

You're going to have to explain this. A lot better. Today as in 01/17/13 or today as in this current day this mafia game is on?

[MonkeyMan576]

I explained this exactly how it was supposed to sound, today as in the game day. I actually got the card on 1/13/13.

[MonkeyMan576]

I got boardwalk, it gives me the vigilante power to kill one player each night. I just got this today so I haven't used it yet.

That wasn't the intent of my question, but given that you are at L-1, this is as good as claiming in this game.

I wanted to know why you said: "As of #505..." That confused me. Then you said that the Mod forgot to tell you you had a card. I want to know how that event transpired. Paraphrased of course.

The mod basically sent me an oops! post and said he had forgotten a card, and sent me boardwalk. :shrug:

[MonkeyMan576]

So yeah, you might want to unvote me unless you want to risk mafia getting the killing power.

[Lord Mhork]

Hang on, so is it actually possible the mafia has no killing roles? Is that balanced?

[SafetyDance]

Tonally Town, content post-early D1 is Town,

1-shot Doc claim is Town

. Tracker result is weird, but I'm chalking it up to a roleblocker.

Ya rly?

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.ph ... 1#p4348301

[SafetyDance]

This is annoying. If it wasn't for Mehdi's night action claim then I would totally be up for lynching between Monkey and Jal right now. There's gotta be some bad claims in amongst this and I think this one takes it. AI's play from the start was bad too.

Anyway, there's no rush to hammer, not that I'm adverse to get a lynch out of the way before a deadline, but we need to discuss everything and all permeations because I don't doubt that all tracker/watcher claims are going to get out of the night alive, or at the least not roleblocked so we need to be prepared and make sure we're at least set up so that if anything happens we can catch it. At least take this up coming weekend to discuss everything, I have plenty of thoughts I need to put down and working out to go through as well.

Hang on, so is it actually possible the mafia has no killing roles? Is that balanced?

Seriously, where have you been for the last day of play? You're one of the lurkers or coasters here but your reads have looked pro-town, especially on Lurker early on but now you're either claiming stupidity or feigning ignorance. Massive game-play change.

[Jake from State Farm]

People like to follow roles blindly without scumhunting or using any logic.

(see: policy lynching millers)

Policy lynching millers is one of the best policies ever

[guille2015]

I got boardwalk, it gives me the vigilante power to kill one player each night. I just got this today so I haven't used it yet.

That wasn't the intent of my question, but given that you are at L-1, this is as good as claiming in this game.

I wanted to know why you said: "As of #505..." That confused me. Then you said that the Mod forgot to tell you you had a card. I want to know how that event transpired. Paraphrased of course.

The mod basically sent me an oops! post and said he had forgotten a card, and sent me boardwalk. :shrug:

Why did you say, "As of #505"?

[MonkeyMan576]

Because I had reported two property cards, then after I posted that the mod sent me a third one.

[guille2015]

But 505 is not yours. and it was on day 1. Prior to you saying "as of 505" you had not Reported any card for the day, hence your answer makes no sense.

[MonkeyMan576]

That was my predecessor's post, so I was just reitorating it.

Yes, I have two cards and both said for now.

[Jake from State Farm]

But 505 is not yours. and it was on day 1. Prior to you saying "as of 505" you had not Reported any card for the day, hence your answer makes no sense.

505 was the person he replaced I believe

[guille2015]

He could have said "I currently have 2 cards"

[MonkeyMan576]

I said "as per #505", not "as of #505", if you're going to nitpick my post.

[guille2015]

Ah, I have miss read. So now it makes sense. I'll explain. "as of" implied that you were not going to state how many cards you had after 505. So, it didn't make sense to me. But now I get it.

I'm going to post a revision of my reads after I come from lunch. Nobody lynch yet, it's not worth it yet.

[Xisiqomelir]

@Medhi2277

:

I was unsure whether to reveal this but considering it doesn't reveal my role sure, I also got a chance that gave me a 1 shot doc. I can reveal who it was on, but the main point is chance/community chest cards can give other role powers beyond things like a vote.

Who was it on?

Tbg was the person I chose.

I considered jal but I was expecting UN alive and assumed jal might be kept alive by scum to have un keep on fosing her.

Lastly no motivation ever given for me to fake claim protecting someone with a 1 shot doc I believe.

I said I protected x. Safety says I didn't and I'm scummy for what?

...

[Jal]

I just got a pm from the mod saying I got a third card during the night he forgot about.

Your slot got the card during the night. If this is so, your slot may have killed someone during the night.

Please confirm.

[Jal]

TBG my reasoning is essentially in here:

When I made my first post of the day, it was actually before I got my card. About a minute before to be exact. I would have still have said the same thing about the vig stuff, I think because a Baby Spice scum kill is weird. Also, not really being sure if cards recirculated I think. It really does point to Medhi if so, but now I'm really not sure about the kill flavor of my card anymore I thought it mentioned it. What peaked by interest about Uber maybe being the vig was Cheery saying Uber didn't go anywhere which I thought was weird and refer back to the weird Baby Spice scum kill bit.

I thought it was a possibility Cheery was lying so I brought up how I got vig during the night.

[MonkeyMan576]

I'm not aware of killing anyone.

[Jake from State Farm]

@ Mehndi - Why did you think UN would be alive if you think his reputation makes him a more likely night kill target? You said yourself if you were scum you would kill UN, so why not use that and protect him over TBG?

[Jal]

I'm not aware of killing anyone.

Have you asked the mod whether Agent Ireland did?

That is a good question by Jake.

[Jal]

I made a mistake there - I got mine during the day. Monkey was the one who said his slot got it at night.