Mini 1404 - Monopoly Mafia - Game Over

[Guy_Named_Riggs]

Current Vote Count 2.04

MonkeyMan576 - 4 (TehBrawlGuy, LordMhork, Mehdi2277, Jal) (L-2)
Mehdi2277 - 4 (SafetyDance, Cheery Dog, Jake From State Farm, MonkeyMan576) (L-2)

Cheery Dog - 1 (Xisiqomelir) (L-5)

Not Voting: guille2015

With 10 alive, it takes 6 to lynch
Deadline is in

(expired on 2013-01-29 14:35:00)

[Jake from State Farm]

Looks like monkey got a little too excited

vote: monkey

[Jake from State Farm]

That's l-1 btw.

[Jal]

Jake, you're using the same method I am: deducing what makes the most sense. You're doing it by deciding, on no additional information available to you, that Uber isn't the scum kill.

Baby Spice was under lots of suspicion yesterday, so no, it doesn't make any great more sense for the scum to get rid of great mislynch material than Uber. Listing me as maybe the next best kill after Spice? No, doesn't make sense. Based on just from a townie perspective and assuming they're not scum, TBG would have made more sense as a scum kill alternative than Spice. Spice did have their suspicions, though, and that would be the only thing to go on.

Why did you claim it, anyway?

I've already explained.

Secondly, I'm most definitely allowed to say "I don't like X" without being sure enough to vote on it. Getting defensive and threatening towards that

does not

help.

Say it all you want. Doesn't take away how you look scummy as shit for doing it. Threatening? You really are a dramatic one.

So, TBG, what is your opinion on Medhi?

[Jal]

I don't like that vote either from you bleh.

Medhi, do you think all of scum's powers come from cards?

[Jake from State Farm]

dude has ignored my questions and has showed up and put what he thought was an L-1 vote while speaking nonsense, I don't care if you like my vote, he's basically slipped imo

[Jake from State Farm]

and Baby was under no real suspicion day 1, she never had more than 2 votes on her at any given vote count.

[Mehdi2277]

No. It's too swingy and while I know the game is meant to be swingy it's still too much (I expect at least one factional night kill and potentially other factional abilities and such). If scum got my cards not together + agent I's + rail roads which seem useless if separate they'd be really weak. Some of the card powers are a lot stronger then others. At the same time powers they have beyond the cards might not be something clear and could just be set up. The way the cards are randomized at death isn't known.

Vote counts don't decide suspicion (especially when you vote the person you suspect most and lurker beat her by a lot at the end). I think it was fairly obvious I'd likely tunnel her if she hadn't died. Jal likely would have pushed her too.

[MonkeyMan576]

I haven't had time, I've been designing another game and have a family and work. I'll try and get to Jake's questions tomorrow.

[Jake from State Farm]

but you had time to read everything else and know all about what mehndi has posted and deserves to be voted? yeah no that doesn't work anymore.

I don';t need you to answer my questions now, you done slipped and my vote stays on you. this homeboy needs rope.

[MonkeyMan576]

Lol I didn't slip dude keep your panties on. I stated my intention to switch my vote a couple pages ago.

[Jake from State Farm]

that vote looked worse than SC's day 1 vote. it reaks of opportunisim

[MonkeyMan576]

Um...no.

[Jake from State Farm]

so you just happen to show up out of the blue and put mehndi at L-1 and that's not opportunistic? ROFL

[Mehdi2277]

And lack of comment on it or response to my posts towards you both before and after the vote whenever you suspect me are fine things?

[Jake from State Farm]

And lack of comment on it or response to my posts towards you both before and after the vote whenever you suspect me are fine things?

I don't understand what you are saying/asking.

[Mehdi2277]

I'm talking to monkey. I've responded to his vague suspicions with 0 response both after the vote and before it when he just said he found me collapsing.

[Mehdi2277]

Jal if monkey is lynched right now who do you think you'd shoot? And what's your opinion of guille?

[TehBrawlGuy]

I've already explained.

I don't recalling seeing it, could you link me or re-state?

Secondly, I'm most definitely allowed to say "I don't like X" without being sure enough to vote on it. Getting defensive and threatening towards that

does not

help.

Say it all you want. Doesn't take away how you look scummy as shit for doing it. Threatening? You really are a dramatic one.

So, TBG, what is your opinion on Medhi?[/quote]

I try.

Tonally Town, content post-early D1 is Town, 1-shot Doc claim is Town. Tracker result is weird, but I'm chalking it up to a roleblocker.

[Lord Mhork]

Why is there a giant wagon on mehdi? 0.o

[TehBrawlGuy]

People like to follow roles blindly without scumhunting or using any logic.

(see: policy lynching millers)

[Cheery Dog]

Medhi, what does this say to you:

Jal and I have claimed to have cards at the start of the day, presumably from the people that died during the night (since neither were ones Lurker had claimed to have) I would say there are another two people that gained cards at the start of the day as well (

based on the probable 2 cards to everyone except

two which have 3

distribution

, but then the fact that Jal who claimed to not have 2 cards yesterday gained one makes me wonder about it)

My wondering is why people already with the most cards gain another one. When I decided to use the deed counter on you I was thinking you had 3 cards as it did make the most sense.

[MonkeyMan576]

Why is there a giant wagon on mehdi? 0.o

Safetydance caught him lying about his role. Lynch all liars!

[guille2015]

Guille does none of my posts referring to you explain why?

No. You only mention NQ as a lurker. But you mention me several time with intent on voting but no reason whatsoever. Just once you say: "Finally for the mock lynch Pseudo vote: guille. Early nice posts help but only if sustained and currently you remain one of the people I suspect most." in Post 1138. But that's vague and I don't know what you mean with vague.

From what I can tell, your entire suspicion of me is based on Number Q's inactivity.

[guille2015]

Monkey please answer the following:

So, I'm kinda rereading everything that happened since I joined in. Let's start with monkey.

Did a readthrough and my scumreads are at the end of the post.

Spoiler:

Post #92 – Don’t like Robert’s stance on no lynching.
Post #138 – Good town post regarding Luker’s activity from Jal.
Post #148 – Baby Spice posts stats, but doesn’t want to back them up.
Post #157 – Good defence post from Lurker
Post #168 – Bad OMGUS vote from Lurker
Post #174 – Like Mehdi’s position on no-lynching.
Post #176 – Robert fence sitting on no lynching, this gets even worse.
Post #195 – Mog starts to go hard on Mehndi. Good scumhunting.
Post #210 – Mehdi is coming off as very defensive as Mog continues to attack.
Post #266 – Jake starts to attack StrangerCoug.
Post #273 – Disagree with mog on L-2 claims.
Post #286- Disagree with SC, Jones should be pretty town.
Post #325 – Discussion on hammering Lurker. Pretty sure I don’t like this wagon.
Post #342 – Liking Jal’s anti-Lurker wagon.
Post #374 – Lurker doesn’t seem scummy to me, SC continues lurker attack.
Post #385 – SC says Xis and Mhork are town, since SC is looking scummy, this does not make them look good.
Post #399 – Agree with jake that Baby Spice’s town list is bad. Esp Robert and SC.
Post #414 – BabySpice reveals she is an alt reluctant to give information on her other aliases.
Post #430 – Q defends SC…don’t think this is good. Votes Lurker, don’t think this is good either.
Post #462 – Jal defends Lurker
Post #501 – Defensive post from BabySpice
Post #508 – SC attacks and FOS’s Mehdi. Mehdi’s reaction seems more protown than SC’s attack.
Post #518 – Good baby spice vote by jal.
Post #526 – Finally SC does something townish and votes Baby.
Post #536 – Baby coming off as defensive again.
Post #552 – SC requests replacement when there’s a wagon on him. Scummy.
Post #578 - Even more defensiveness from babyspice, why not scumhunt?
Post #627 – Baby is obvscum. SC is obvscum.
Post #684 – Xis attacks babyspice. Good post
Post #695 – Lurker self votes. Pretty scummy. But I still think he’s probably desperate. town.
Post #705 – Good logic post from Jal
Post #709 – Brawl defends Lurker.
Post #726 – Jal Votes Lurker. Coming of as very wishy washy on him.
Post #737 – Liked Jake at the beginning, but his posts are becoming increasingly antagonistic towards townish people.
Post #749 – Jal unvotes, not liking the fencesitting, but still townish.
Post #769 – Good meta research by Uber, usually townish behavior.
Post #829 – Uber votes Jal, don’t agree with him, but I like his scumhunting.
Post #840 – Good alignment post from Uber.
Post #845 – Don’t agree with jake’s response to Uber.
Post #865 – Lurker claims scum? Will have to reevaluate some of my reads.
Post #886 – End of day 1. Looking back this makes Jal and SC look more town.
Post #915 – Jal makes a good point on Jake. He did get scummier as the lurker wagon progressed.
Post #947 – Good lurker vote from Mehdi
Post #953 – Good meta research from Mehdi.
Post #967 – Jake votes safety. Definitely something to watch later on.
Post #971 – Good post from Jal on why Robert is town.
Post #879 – Safety gets a night action result on mehdi.
Post #984 – Mehdi wagon continues

Current reads
Town
Safety
Jal
CheeryDog
Mehdi2277

Nuetral
Xisqomelir

Scum
Brawl
Jake from State Farm

1. Did you write this post as you read the thread?
2. You missed NumberQ. Any thoughts on his play?
3. I don't see why you place Medhi as town. Can you give me why this is?

as per #505 I have two property cards. I also have a worthless community chest card I got last night.

I just got a pm from the mod saying I got a third card during the night he forgot about.

Can you please elaborate more on this?