Mafiastuck (GAME OVER TOWN WINS!)

[AurorusVox]

Vote: Cheery Dog

I would have voted Noir but he died.

[Cheery Dog]

My read of Nacho yesterday still stands.

VOTE: Nacho

[Porfervor]

a big fuck you to the scum who roleblocked me

VOTE: xtopherusD

[Porfervor]

sunmans is still badmans

vote aldskuhel

this too also who gives a fuck on which scum were voting as long as they arent town i certainly dont give a fuck more votes on xtopher

[Zdenek]

Hi thread. I see you are open. I'll catchup today.

[ActionDan]

a big fuck you to the scum who roleblocked me

VOTE: xtopherusD

If scum were going to roleblock you, I'd imagine they'd kill you also to avoid this sort of situation. Considering the set-up and the number of people playing (30), I'd imagine it's 4-4-1-21 (certainly scum is 4-4 as Midnight crew is 4 people). In this case you might have hit BP SK. Of course he'd have likely killed you if that were the case.

Skyman should at least claim whether he's BP or not.

[Maenara]

Realized I was deliberately trying to look town yesterday, which was stupid as hell. Will try to be less useless.

Alsark was acting real weird before he replaced out, and Pasch's actions could quite easily be construed as a bad attempt to distance. Alsark was also on DV's wagon, which is another point not in his favour (And yes, so was I, but I had to check.) Zdenek has said nothing, so there's nothing further to work with yet. I don't see him on the same team as Pandorica, though, seeing as they both made bullshit claims at about the same time, which would be a bit odd for scum.

xtopherusD has an incredible busywork-to-stancetaking ratio, and not in a good way. I'm particularly drawn to the post Epic pointed out, wherein he wanted the day to end with about two weeks to deadline.

Yeah, I can get behind pressuring him.

VOTE: xtopherusD

Also, hello to you too, S&R. My defense: Yes, I was useless.

[BroodKingEXE]

It has been pointed out that xtopherusD voted for Tazaro for very shitty reasoning. Im pretty down eith pressuring him.
VOTE: Xtopherus

[BT]

VOTE: Cheery Dog
Note that Cheery Dog is conf. not on Tazaro's team (further proof is Pandorica pushing for Cheery Dog while admitting Pasch was bad when the wagon on the latter was starting), as far as conf. goes. Biggest reason for this vote is the reactionary play when and only when his wagon was a possible thing.

I would actually reread the thread but I don't exactly have time to pour into this game for the next while. Minimal contribution will have to do.

[BT]

I guess first order of business when I have the time is looking into xtoph? I never re-looked at him yesterday.

[Sunshine and Rainbows]

everybody iso maenara and vote him once you realize how terrible he looks

- dan vote is forced and has nothing to do with dan being scummy
- switches from encouraging giving taz a second chance to wanting him to be scum, no other interaction but tried to push deas counterwagon in a really weak manner
- pasch's alsark vote is Obviously Not Distancing im sorry. just consider pasch's overall actions this game and the context of his alsark vote
- even that most recent post is talking about pressure and not who's scum. do you even scumhunt? because you haven't at all this game

this guy is scum and i'd go as far as to bet that he's limescum too. his interactions with pasch's slot are classic scum just managing to avoid clearly touching on a scummy buddy and the rest of his content is weak as hell

[Sunshine and Rainbows]

will probably sheep fate when he votes

You are terrible js

[Sunshine and Rainbows]

avox wagon's good

need to read cheery dog but my partner doesn't think he's scum so w/e

[Sunshine and Rainbows]

fuck man i don't know what to think about nacho about this point, his actual content leans town but his rhetoric is forced as shit. like there's nothing even implying fate's slot is town

[Sunshine and Rainbows]

cheery dog actually doesn't look like scum to me but also his posts have a lot of fluff and are annoying to parse so i 100% endorse vigging him since he's probably gonna be a big push all game and i don't want to have to read him.

[Zdenek]

The first 30 pages:

Welp, Strider rolled vanilla townie.

why would you post this
I would vote for you right now if 1) it weren't the pregame and 2) I weren't planning on voting for the Mod and the Co-Mod to see if they are in any way participants in the game (e.g. Gorrad is Andrew Hussie/Lord English/whatever)

Oh dear lord, you are not going to vote someone you think is scum because you were planning to vote for the mod - hi, I'm not going to be aggressive because I was planning to be not aggressive.

Epic, I don't know what you are doing or why you are doing it but it would be mighty fine if you could not do it.

Why are you intervening on behalf of Alduskkel?

Hmm, this game might actually be partially broken depending on how the mod distributed roles/alignments, but I'll whistle innocently the other way and ignore it.

I like your mind set, but come on.

i find good mans and bad mans

VOTE: Alduskkel

So Torg could hide behind his post restriction but he's not, so that's a plus.

"I have a made-up post restriction where I always make a bunch of worthless posts in a row."

FTFY

Well, comb. enig. has a slightly lower chance of being scum with Pardorica, Malpa too, for the bullshit ^ post.

god confirmation phase is boring
i want to vote people, shit

Gah this is actually pretty bad

UNVOTE:

VOTE: Nachomamma8

Vifam's vote/unvote/vote on different people, shows trying to scumhunt, so that's a plus.

And yeah, I'd have to agree that they managed to seem the scummiest during confirmation. Though I'm not sure if Phil is worse than Nacho.

So you have two scum reads, and you don't vote either?

I'd just like to see Noir make a content-ful post.

VOTE: Noir

EBWOP: I've got my eye on Nacho because of that, and it is pretty fake, but I'm giving him the benefit of the doubt for now.

It might be worth seeing how this develops.

If it feels so fake, then why aren't people voting me for it?
You're voting Noir because you want him to make a post with content even though it's pretty early Day 1, and Vifam is voting someone else because he was told to.
Don't back down from your suspicions.

Okay, this post looks town. Consider my suspicion of you retracted.

That post is pretty much null. What make you think it looks townish?

it's not that post in particular his posts are just overly vehement. feels like he's putting on a show of being aggressive.

I agree with this because most of it came during conf. stage.

arthur you're fucking dumb if you continue this argument

Titan's a little less likely to be to batter witch aligned.

xtoph's 262 is a massive waste of time, and his vifam vote is stupid.

torg 270 - he's a little less likely to be batter witch due to his response to Paschendale's stupid case and vote.

Robocopter's self-vote is horrible, and considering that it came just after Paschendale's stupid case, and he avoided commenting on that, and could easily have been trying to distract from it, he goes on the scum-list.

xtoph - 275 is him defending himself and he ignores the goings on in the thread. 284 - it's how I talk nonsense.

Combatenigma and nacho voting for Noir and calling each other scum is pretty scummy. Noir hasn't even started the game, so I dont know how they expect him to step up his game.

Defending Noir.

I like perfavors opinion on xtoph. 337

Alsark is pointing out confirmed Town (no matter how illogically), which is something that helps scum more than town.

If it's illogical, he's not confirmed, so this is really bs attempt to paint someone as scummy.

339 makes perfavor read as town to me.

Noir cross-votes with Comb. enig. Another thing to keep track of, 378 makes me think maybe not bussing.

Zeta votes pasch in 395 without giving a reason.

In fact a little wagon Comb. Enig get's going.

Gut tells me that CheeryDog's not Pandorica aligned.

Malpa votes for Pandorica.

I like the stuff that S&R chooses to comment on in 435.

I can't really tell if Malpa really thought Pandorica is scum in their further interactions or if he's pushing bs argument (at the time) too hard.

Based on the exchange between Noir and Pandorica around 455, I'd be hesitant to string up Cheery Dog. At this point he's done little to warrant that much attention.

512 - hurts my town read on perfav

Hmm ok.

Unvote: Vifam

Vote: Cheery Dog

Vote: DeasVail

you suck zen

This makes no sense considering you were voting Cheery at the time.

I'm pretty torn on perfav after this, the cognitive dissonance in their attack on Deas for voting Cheery is clear. On the other hand, I have really mixed feelings about scum claiming vig so early. On the other hand, they really over did it.

530 gets malpa on the town list.

zeta kept pushing Paschendale in 540

numberQ's 552 was really underwhelming.

I have mixed feelings about Phil's reads list, but it shows effort, so for now, ok. Also fourth reactions to people attacking him seem ok.

Did Wutloski ever talk about Paschendale early? I'll have to check this eventually.

I like BT's 575.
GNR's 579 is horrible, and he die.

I'll need to look into Epic's suspicion of Titan.

Paschende votes deas.

There's is almost no chance that Malpa is Batterwitch aligned.

By 671 and Robocopter still not talking about Paschendale, I really want him dead.

I'll need to come back to posts around 700. I've got town reads on Titan and Vifam, but they're sort of defending Paschendale here, which could be an issue. At the moment, I still don't see Titan as Pandorica aligned, and they didn't push Malpa too hard, so it's probably irrelevant.

Reads:

Town (these are pretty much gut/ because of their reactions to certain things, which is semi-irrelevant in multiscum, but it's good enough for me for now):

Nacho's deasvail vote is horrible.

Comb's 741 is ok, I don't really see him as scum with Noir agreeing that his Noir vote was bad.

Titan
Torg
Vifam
Deasvail
Sunshine and Rainbows
Malpa
Nikanor
Phil
BT

Town because of scum interactions (which might be a really shitty reason to think someone is town, depending on your point of view):

Cheery Dog
Comb. Enig.

Scum:
Alduskkel
xtoph
Robocopter
numberQ
GNR
nacho

[AurorusVox]

Vote: Sunshine and Rainbows

[Sunshine and Rainbows]

Vote: Sunshine and Rainbows

can't wait to see u drop that with no mention of it ever happening next time you post, like you've done with everything else

[Sunshine and Rainbows]

cE hasnt really stopped being scum, there's no new content from him but his "mindspew" post thoughts on pasch are pretty laughable (i think it's more likely cE is non-limescum who thought pasch was idiot town than that cE and pasch are buddies tho)

[AurorusVox]

fuck man i don't know what to think about nacho about this point, his actual content leans town but his rhetoric is forced as shit. like there's nothing even implying fate's slot is town

If you continue pushing piss like this then I won't be dropping it so soon.

[Sunshine and Rainbows]

fuck man i don't know what to think about nacho about this point, his actual content leans town but his rhetoric is forced as shit. like there's nothing even implying fate's slot is town

If you continue pushing piss like this then I won't be dropping it so soon.

scum post

[DeasVail]

I'll get to this tonight.

[buldermar]

VOTE: Cheery Dog

[Fate]

HEAHAHHAHAHAHHAHAAAAAAAAAAAAAA

IS THAT 3 SCUM I SEE ALREADY?

CAN HAZ FREE WIN?

No I didn't read and no I'm not going to

[Fate]

Vote: Cheery Dog

will probably sheep fate when he votes, but the dog is still scum

uhh

I was hoping to sheep you cause youre p town and have read this game

>_>

<_<

AV is town btw, so that wagons dumb. Faraday was pretty town until LOLMULTIBALL so I guess its good he ded