Mafiastuck (GAME OVER TOWN WINS!)

[Nachomamma8]

I am noting the mutual circle jerk/whiteknighting between Phil and Robo

shooooosh

[Tazaro]

Do you mean shush?

[Phillammon]

Whether it's a joke or not, your accusation of "ACTIVE LURKING" was odd. How do you choose to react to the other 2 points I made? I'll accept that you can't really say anything about 1 for obvious reasons, but your interactions with torg still come off as scummy, and your reactions to my accusations as of yet allow me to add a point 4 to the list: Attacking the player over the arguments. Which, looking back, you have been doing a fair amount of.

PEdit: I don't give a damn about robo, he is still one of my scumreads for various reasons. It's just that there is an obvious scum digging their own grave who happens to be interacting with him.

PEdit 2: Lo, the bard of rage.

[Nachomamma8]

Do you mean shush?

No, I mean calm down a bit because you are jumping at shadows that are not there.
The mutual circle-jerk between robo and Phil to which you were referring was actually robo commenting that Phil was burned by you. The fact that I can gather this in my skimfest and you're missing it tells me that you're getting a bit too jumpy, and you will be useless in finding scum if you jump on every single thing.

[Epic]

Finally done with an absurd paper assignment, going to read the thread more closely and effortpost from now on and stuff.

[Tazaro]

Going to recede for a while for fear that scum love to exploit jumpiness

[Phillammon]

Spoiler: Mild Spoilers within, showing reference

PEdit: I like how that post can be summarized as "No, YOU'RE the scum because your reasons!"

As, now I realize, once more, are a fair number of your rebuttals.

[Robocopter87]

Whenever buldermar double posts I think it is two people because on the blue background it looks like the vase and on the light blue it looks like two faces. But the red reminds me its the same person.

This was not a joke, Phillammon.
There's a rebuttal to your jaundiced view of me, there.

Except for the fact that it was a joke.

[Tazaro]

Noting that it looks like two different things in two different modes of viewing is not really jokey. It comes from a trivial observation about perspective, which you decided for some reason to incorporate into a statement in which only the last sentence is actually possibly funny in any way as an add-on to act like it's a joke when the observation really is a nerdy thing of fact.

[Tazaro]

It is what it is, for now.

[DeasVail]

Taz, my wagon is kind of fail. It's not really helping you to be on it. Vote Maenara instead!

[buldermar]

Trying to pass it off as humor. I am noting this.

I'm merely stating what is obvious for most people; ask around.

[Tazaro]

It is what it is .

[buldermar]

Noting that it looks like two different things in two different modes of viewing is not really jokey. It comes from a trivial observation about perspective, which you decided for some reason to incorporate into a statement in which only the last sentence is actually possibly funny in any way as an add-on to act like it's a joke when the observation really is a nerdy thing of fact.

It was a joke and it was funny to me because it asserted that my usage of colour is useful when most people consider it a nuisance. You're being a huge vote magnet by behaving like an obnoxious little shit. If you want to avoid getting lynched my advice would be that you shut up or at the very least display more deliberate thinking in your posts.

[Tazaro]

Going to recede for a while ...

[Nachomamma8]

I think it's time, boys and girls.
The first official reread of this thread.

Titan gets to be the first official townread in this official reread; the Vote-HeavyFoS on Phil combines with the later voteswitch on Phil is pretty baller. He takes a real effort to salvage something from the confirmation phase (at this point, don't really give a shit about it anymore), so that's +++ points for Ser Arthur Dayne.

Vifam is town for early game hunting; he drops a lot of wagons before he has to as scum, and he's cautious to avoid angry initial kneejerks. Phil is town because my god does he feel town. He's scumhunting, he's posting all lighthearted and free, not like his dirty scumfuck posting.

Epic made me laugh in #245, which is a good call for him because I usually laugh at town shit. #248 is also interesting because he calls Phil out for spouting wiki tells (which is fine; it shows he's using a resource to help him scumhunt better. he's a big enough boy to fake scumtells.).

Pasch taking an obvious claim seriously is not a scumtell. It's a little strange so *might* come from scum, but I doubt it.

Robocopter is town, which is good. I didn't really want to lynch him anyways.

Skyman is so brutally honest; he reminds me of Metabot. Probably not scum, though. Probably will be lynched regardless of what anyone does, though.

Porfervor might be town, despite whatever I said when I was reading the thread. Jury's still out on this one, but I like how he's the first one to bring back Alduskkel into the discussion, and I like how they have the "I'm a loose cannon, they're the waller" synergy going when my scumhydra tactics usually amount to "lynch the fuck out of anything that moves".

#344 is the final town nail in the town coffin. Or whatever the hell that expression is for not killing people.

I don't think that Tammy would let Arthur be regarded as the dominant head over herself in a scum hydra. Not for a second, nope nope.

Pasch ignores what would be an easy lynch in Cheery Dog, ignores what would be an easy lynch in DeasVail, ignores what would be an easy vote by keeping his old one on Alasark, and decides that Rubik and I need more scrutiny. Doesn't exactly seem like scum in over their head to me, personally.

Cheery Dog - "I don't see problems in this thread except what people have already questioned" This implies that he has scumreads, or people that are asking the questions he wants them to and thus should have people to sheep. But instead it's just an excuse for not posting anything. Burn it with fire.

BROOD - Throws a little bit of suspicion here and there, wagon hops without shit. Sounds like he needs a good roping to me.

good as any at the moment.

VOTE: Comvinatoriall

BURN THIS SHIT NOW
BURN IT NOW

actually cheery dog does look fucking terrible in light of mini 1368. it's like he hit his head or something

he hit his head on the SCUM BAR OF JUSTICE
so lynch him, ty

Hmm ok.

Unvote: Vifam

Vote: Cheery Dog

this is so town that I had to let out a hearty chuckle
oh deasvail
they should make a sitcom for you
and your towniness

Nikanor is on town crack.

I'm decidedly undecided on BT. I bet myself a dollar he wasn't actually going to catch up when he said he was, but he... did. And his posting was pretty good when he did. So I would call him town if I wasn't pissed at losing a dollar to himself.

Toro, I expected you to do better with reading Robo. He's playing to a specified playstyle (like you), except he's not hiding behind a gimmick alt like you are. Not that hiding behind gimmick alts are bad, of course, it's just a different risk to pull that random playstyle out of your ass when people can be like "oh, he doesn't play like this normally. let's lynch the fuck out of him."

ISO Pasch and laugh. Please just do it.

unvote, Vote: Paschendale

I don't think I need to iso him for that to happen.
UNVOTE: ]
VOTE: paschendale

I think I just threw up in my mouth a little.
...a lot.

Why aren't you killing Nacho? He's doing the exact same thing except not even voting. He just says "hmmm, that's interesting." I'm reaching actual conclusions.

WAIT WAIT WAIT
THIS ISN'T AS BAD AS YOU THINK
For one, he's trying to deflect the lynch onto me when he is afraid of me as town and him scum.
For two, this is a follow up on his earlier suspicion of me.
And the suspicion makes sense! We've played together twice, and both times it was a newbie game so I played my typical newbie town self and not a fucking troll for the first half of the first day.
So he's town!
SO QUIT FUCKING VOTING HIM

Alright, time to lurk like a pro at the back of the pack.

Oh hey Nacho hows it going

oh look at robo calling me out
this is good shit, good shit

I legit have no idea how you guys are finding me scummy here. I'm really completely at a loss for how you discern alignment out of a game so stuffed with garbage that nobody even looks like they're trying.

I'll just replace out and you guys can play with someone who understands how these big games work. And I'll probably avoid them in the future. They're not nearly as fun for me as I thought they would be.

Mod: I'd like to be replaced.

so town
so completely and totally town
you have no reads and everyone is wagonning you, so you replace out
if you're scum, you're curious how everyone is picking up on your scumfuck self so you eat the lynch

malp is def town. buldermar is def town. kanaya is def town.

CHEERY DOG IS STILL FUCKING SCUM HOLY SHIT.

FUCK YEA I WAS RIGHT ABOUT SKYMAN BEING TOWN
SUCK IT

fox protecting the hound is still town deas, even though he is wrong as fuck
that sounded oddly familiar, but w/e

Cheery Dog lurks and wagonhops while not under pressure, doesn't find anything to comment on while not under pressure, but when he is under pressure, he suddenly finds shit to comment about and, lo and behold, it's still scummy as fuck.

Aldu is scum, lynch him whenever.

Cheery dog is hitting my sympathy button.

I think you're confusing it with that other s word that I really like.

Tazaro busts in this bitch, starts calling everyone's townreads scum and begins spamming the thread half up to hell.
Sounds like townzaro to me, please do not lynch.

Going to recede for a while ...

pap

[Nachomamma8]

TOWN:
buldermar
DeasVail
TAZARO
Vifam
Titan
Epic
Skyman
Robocop
Porfevor
Wutlolski
Malp
Sunshine and Rainbows

SCUM
Alduskel
CHEERY DOG
Brood
Faraday? Maybe?

obviously there are more townreads than scumreads
don't lynch my townreads
will probably be down for whatever the fuck else

[DeasVail]

Who is Skyman?

[Nachomamma8]

xtopherusD

[buldermar]

you have no reads and everyone is wagonning you, so you replace out
if you're scum, you're curious how everyone is picking up on your scumfuck self so you eat the lynch

I think some people find being lynched on day 1 as scum shameful and will thus opt to replace out with some (from their perspective) dignity when they realize that a lynch is likely unavoidable. Why do you rule this out?

[Pandorica]

I don't think that Tammy would let Arthur be regarded as the dominant head over herself in a scum hydra. Not for a second, nope nope.

nah she totally would.

[Pandorica]

WAIT WAIT WAIT
THIS ISN'T AS BAD AS YOU THINK
For one, he's trying to deflect the lynch onto me when he is afraid of me as town and him scum.
For two, this is a follow up on his earlier suspicion of me.
And the suspicion makes sense! We've played together twice, and both times it was a newbie game so I played my typical newbie town self and not a fucking troll for the first half of the first day.
So he's town!
SO QUIT FUCKING VOTING HIM

pretty sure you're reading this incorrectly. he doesn't even as much as acknowledge the playstyle different between the 2 games, it's fairly obviously not what he's going for.

cheery dog is also scum, yes. maenara is also probably scum. but tazaro has a bigger wagon so it's all good.

[Nachomamma8]

you have no reads and everyone is wagonning you, so you replace out
if you're scum, you're curious how everyone is picking up on your scumfuck self so you eat the lynch

I think some people find being lynched on day 1 as scum shameful and will thus opt to replace out with some (from their perspective) dignity when they realize that a lynch is likely unavoidable. Why do you rule this out?

mmmmmmm
I don't think Pasch thought the lynch was unavoidable.
I think Pasch just got frustrated because I prefer shaving with Occam's Razor.

I don't think that Tammy would let Arthur be regarded as the dominant head over herself in a scum hydra. Not for a second, nope nope.

nah she totally would.

ok well titan is still town for other reasons
so there

[Nachomamma8]

pretty sure you're reading this incorrectly. he doesn't even as much as acknowledge the playstyle different between the 2 games, it's fairly obviously not what he's going for.

he didn't, no, because he's not a good enough town player to realize when transparency is a good thing.
doesn't mean it's not what he's going for. he obviously isn't very confident, but he sees the difference and wants people to discuss it.

[xtopherusD]

:33 < look at that post!