Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Legacy (Game Over)

[pidgey]

By the way.

Wats the possibility of a scum team based on metal gear characters killing at night and harry potterians at day?

Are you cop to general scum ben, ormdoes the PM maybe say to a specific faction?

[pidgey]

Thats my last question of the day before vote

[Tammy]

Hey sometimes I get good reads early game, most often I don't. In mafia behind the maiden I noted my suspicions of four of the mafia on day one. That was a rare case though.

I've played with AV before. His play looked nothing like town, so yeah, I had a scum read and I was right.

I had a good reason to shoot Thad. You just don't like it. If Thad wouldn't have written that case that I couldn't imagine coming from town ever, I would have shot BC.

[Tammy]

Jesus. I'm Johnny Sasaki.

[Benmage]

And @MAstin/others

ThaD was a terrible shot. I don't care that you or a few others may have suspected him. It wasn't greater than 4. You had nowhere near lynch worthy support. And some of those oppossed may have been scum. Whereas I (clearly town) found him town. I think some others did as well... He was town(obv). He's an experienced play who could have been an asset to the town.

VS

BLOODCOVENANT A MUCH MORE UNIVERSALLY ACCEPT SUSPICIOUS SLOT. That was also being replaced.

[Benmage]

Hey sometimes I get good reads early game, most often I don't. In mafia behind the maiden I noted my suspicions of four of the mafia on day one. That was a rare case though.

I've played with AV before. His play looked nothing like town, so yeah, I had a scum read and I was right.

I had a good reason to shoot Thad. You just don't like it.

If Thad wouldn't have written that case that I couldn't imagine coming from town ever,

I would have shot BC.

You have to say this.

I don't believe it.

The case wasn't that bad compared to what gets passed as cases all the time here.

This is such a fabricated overreaction.

[Tammy]

EVERYONE THAT WAS THERE KNEW I WAS THINKING ABOUT SHOOTING THAD. NOT ONE PERSON ARGUED WITH ME ABOUT IT OR TRIED TO PROVE HE WAS TOWN.

[Tammy]

Stop calling me a liar when I'm not lying Benmage.

[Benmage]

EVERYONE THAT WAS THERE KNEW I WAS THINKING ABOUT SHOOTING THAD. NOT ONE PERSON ARGUED WITH ME ABOUT IT OR TRIED TO PROVE HE WAS TOWN.

I was against it.

Who was for it? Mastin... he's proven real sane ... and a bunch of other useless people not sure where up is from left ( ) (pidgey)

[Benmage]

EVERYONE THAT WAS THERE KNEW I WAS THINKING ABOUT SHOOTING THAD. NOT ONE PERSON ARGUED WITH ME ABOUT IT OR TRIED TO PROVE HE WAS TOWN.

I was against it.

Who was for it? Mastin... he's proven real sane ... and a bunch of other useless people not sure where up is from left ( ) (pidgey)

[pidgey]

Actually i proposed mastin, others proposed me, some proposed benmage himself. Mastin was a better shot honestly, shes already making full scumteams and interactions HAHAHA.

Only remember AP and you discussing Thead.

Also can you answer before i vote ben just to be sure.

[Tammy]

Also, I do need to confirm this because I'm not sure what I think about it, and whatever you think about me I've honestly been searching for mafia since the time the game started. I don't know why you were so suspicious of me when I was honest with my reads.

But, Nero Cain neighborized me last night. We didn't talk about much but he asked me for my four suspects with reasoning. I'm not sure what to think about it and thought I'd hold onto it while I figured it out. He didn't give many suspects just said he thought Jason was onto something with Kise and thought that Snifit was suspicious too. I gave him all the thoughts I had on players up to that point, but I do kind of find it weird that he wanted to know my 4 suspects with reasons because he wanted to keep track of suspects. Anyway, do with that what you want.

[Benmage]

Stop calling me a liar when I'm not lying Benmage.

You realize a comment like this actually makes me think you the person Tammy, not the player... is dumb for lack of a better word.

If I called out scum for lying, and they say I'm not lying... well geegolly, of course they'd say that. They have to say that. Their whole game is a lie. So you saying your not lying has zero influence on me. You tammy, the person should know this.

[Benmage]

Also can you answer before i vote ben just to be sure.

Me answer something?

[pidgey]

Top of the page

[Tammy]

Stop calling me a liar when I'm not lying Benmage.

You realize a comment like this actually makes me think you the person Tammy, not the player... is dumb for lack of a better word.

If I called out scum for lying, and they say I'm not lying... well geegolly, of course they'd say that. They have to say that. Their whole game is a lie. So you saying your not lying has zero influence on me. You tammy, the person should know this.

But I'm not lying. I really have been looking for mafia. None of my reads or thoughts or anything has been a lie.

[Benmage]

Are you cop to general scum ben, ormdoes the PM maybe say to a specific faction?

Suggests general.

[pidgey]

Vote: tammy

Wingardiummleviosa the hammer on her head.

[Tammy]

Good luck town. I was honest about all my reads.

I seriously do believe the messager was town. Please don't lynch him.

[pidgey]

Are you SK though?

[Tammy]

No.

[pidgey]

We shall see in a bit....

[Tammy]

Okay so with snifit, yesterday I thought he was scum and was a potential partner to Melmond because twice he opted to vote for someone else besides Melmond while at the same time calling Melmond scummy. First it was cybertronix because the wagon was smaller and then it was rapid canyon. I had a town read on both slots so my immediate conclusion was that he was partnered. But I was wrong about Melmond so that reasoning goes out the window. However, his play doesn't read town to me, even though he does have a genuine post or two. I'm of the mind that he possibly was trying to stay off the wagon due to his partner being on the wagon or too close in proximity to a partner. Anyway this is wishy-washy, but it's something worth looking at again based on future flips.

[AngryPidgeon]

By my count that is l - 2.

Tammy, are you on a team with BC?

[Tammy]

I wouldn't totally discount Zoroaster because of Avox's slip. He could have just as easily accidentally listed a scum buddies name because his scum buddies name was on his mind. I don't get scum vibes from Zoroaster though, I just think that the reasoning used to clear him is weak.

Also, Mastin - Why are your four suspects more suspect to you than BC. I notice that you put your four suspects in that grouping and said failing that, I could shoot BC or someone else (can't remember who at the moment and I'm trying to be quick). I think that BC's interactions and posts look for scummier than a couple people on your list.

Also, why are you just looking for four people for the scum team. Do you have any reason to believe that mafia has five players? Wouldn't it be possible that they had more if there was a dayvig in the set up?