Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Legacy (Game Over)

[Benmage]

more odd that he thinks Nero is a good scumhunter.

The reason Nero offered to hydra with me before is that his scumdar's better than mine, but his power of persuasion is weaker than mine. Nero's the best person in this playerlist at catching scum; I've yet to see him in a game where this hasn't proven true. Unfortunately, he's one of the weaker players when it comes to convincing others he's right. So in that regard, and in that regard only, is he not a good scumhunter.

(STOP NINJA'ING ME, PEOPLE!)

Convincing people is the most important aspect of scumhunting. That said, my experience with him, I have not seen him well at all. You can look at the game by CMAR which just got abandoned... He was dreadful... as I said, my experience.

unvote vote Tammy

No longer interested in snifit... Will lynch off the probscum list.

[mastin2]

Also, add ThAd to the list of "needs-a-look".

---

Benmage, where am I on that list?

[Benmage]

Oh thats weird guess i didn't replace cyber after erasing .But Cyber/You should be in the probtown list.

[Kublai Khan]

Down for snifit.

Or confirmedscum Tammy ....

vote snifit

Prob town:
snifit

Why did benmage vote snifit over "confscum" Tammy?

[Benmage]

^Whose that question directed to?

Anyways the answer is because I thought he was scummier than he is + a plausible lynch.

But relooking he isn't as scummy as I think.

So I am voting confirmedscum Tammy. But I'm okay with lynching anyone in my probscum list, as one cannot always get the lynch they'd like.

[AngryPidgeon]

Why is Tammy scum? I really don't feel one way or the other abut her.

[Benmage]

KK

what is your read on Tammy anyways?

[Benmage]

Why is Tammy scum? I really don't feel one way or the other abut her.

I don't have the time to go into this.

Shouldn't her not being a shinning beacon of townliness have been telling enough??

BTW, I think she should claim who messaged her... What was the message again? Did we get that yet?

[Kublai Khan]

^Whose that question directed to?

Anyways the answer is because I thought he was scummier than he is + a plausible lynch.

But relooking he isn't as scummy as I think.

So I am voting confirmedscum Tammy. But I'm okay with lynching anyone in my probscum list, as one cannot always get the lynch they'd like.

Nobody in particular. Sometimes I like to see who answers an unaddressed question.

What was the catalyst that caused you to change your read on him? Because to me, it looks like you jumped on a convenient runaway wagon-train but bailed when the conductor (mastin2) pulled the brake. We are 24 hours removed from the start of Day 2. Why are you already giving up on getting the lynch you'd like and going for the convenient wagon?

KK

what is your read on Tammy anyways?

Not on the town list. Her excuses are annoying, but I'm waiting to see how the mailman stuff plays out.

[Benmage]

I've been away from the game for sometime. Even before night/my power problems I had fallen behind some pages. Now and probably for the next few days I'll have limited time.

My read on snifit I don't think was always very strong either way. He was lurky if I recall correctly, and so I hopped onto the moving train.

Come now, because Mastin unvoted, I'd jump ship . I hopped off because I read the post/reply to mastin right above mastins unvote where snifit says he didn't even want to join the game and told mastin to fuck off.

It read genuine.

[pappums rat]

Votecount 2.3

"Foolish man. He prayed for death, and it found him. You see, Snake? You can't protect anyone, not even yourself!" -Liquid Snake, Metal Gear Solid

snifit - 4 (Nero Cain, Kise, zabriel, ThAdmiral)
Kise - 3 (Kublai Khan, mastin2, AngryPidgeon)
rapidcanyon - 1 (snifit)
AngryPidgeon - 1 (jasonT1981)
mastin2 - 1 (mykonian)
mykonian - 1 (Yates)
Benmage - 1 (Acosmist)
Tammy - 1 (Benmage)

Not voting - BloodCovenant, PeregrineV, pidgey, Zoroaster, Tammy, rapidcanyon

Searching for a replacement for rapidcanyon

With 19 alive it takes 10 to lynch.

The deadline for Day 2 is 3 PM EST on November 15, 2012.

[pidgey]

Can you guys not end the day prematurely btw? Seeing a lot of votes on snifit so just want to make sure to read and post before end day.

Benmage lol cool man why am i prob scum how did you get that awesome read?

[pidgey]

Oh he just has 4 votes nevermind.

[ThAdmiral]

Also, add ThAd to the list of "needs-a-look".

Was already there.

[Yates]

The whole backtracking malarkey smells of scum as well. Hence; vote.

Thanks. This is what I was looking for.

[mastin2]

Might as well make this public:
3. zabriel
5. Kise
8. PeregrineV
13. Benmage
15. ThAdmiral
20. rapidcanyon

Suspect list, with three names in null--snifit (ambivalent-type; leaning town), Tammy (limbo-type), and pidgey (replacement dissonance-type).

[Yates]

I would entertain a ThAd case if it weren't for the fact he is Lurky McLurkerson and has so little content. That is *my* entire case on ThAd.

[jasonT1981]

Why is Tammy scum? I really don't feel one way or the other abut her.

I don't have the time to go into this.

Shouldn't her not being a shinning beacon of townliness have been telling enough??

BTW, I think she should claim who messaged her... What was the message again? Did we get that yet?

no, you really should need to go into this.

[AngryPidgeon]

Yeah I didn't know if I should say anything, but in the MGS games, FOXDIE killed people with nanomachines in their bodies, so it feels like an idea for PGO that would be MGS theme exclusive. Outguessing the mod(s) may be healthy after all. I trust Faraday's knowledge of the MGS games.

I'd like Kise to explain his reason for posting this.

If Acosmist is a PGO, then he is town. Therefore, why do we care about outguessing the mod about his role?

If Acosmist is scum, then he is lying about being a PGO and then the above statement is moot (because he isn't a PGO)

Unless scum PGOs exist?

[AngryPidgeon]

Actually on 2nd thought I guess I see it? If Acosmist is town, then Kise is saying that is possibly confirmable safely? I'm dumb. Ignore the Pidgeon behind the curtain.

[mykonian]

benmage, do you always make lists?

And uhm, I think I'd prefer snifit over tammy.

[mastin2]

And uhm, I think I'd prefer snifit over tammy.

You have interest in a snifit lynch? Your words say otherwise.
(Yes, I know, comparing snifit to tammy != preferring snifit as a lynch, but it implies as much when you don't offer alternatives to both--such as, say, Kise, RC, Zab...*)

*In a sentence, myk: who

would

you prefer to lynch?

---

Also, before I forget:

Mod:

Note that I'm never available Sundays thanks to Round Dancing, and while I can theoretically make time for ms.net on Saturday, it's tedious for me to do so, and I prefer not to, especially with my Focused Playing theory. (See the MD thread.) And if that wasn't enough, I know for a fact that this weekend will be MUCH busier than normal, so even if I wanted to, it'd me far more difficult than most weeks, due to how much I have to do tomorrow.

tl;dr,

V/LA over the weekend.

Sorry. Shouldn't be much of a problem, though.

[AngryPidgeon]

Well, hes voting you >.>

[mastin2]

And I'm not getting lynched. Nightkilled, sure, lynched, never.

But even if a lynch on me were possible, that'd still just be one of his suspects--in a game of this size, there's going to be 4-5 scum, so he should have 3-4 suspects other than myself.

[AngryPidgeon]

Just saying the answer to "Who do you want lynched today" was pretty obvious.

Also I think I had a little bit of an epiphany that makes me happier with Mastin=town.