Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Legacy (Game Over)

[jasonT1981]

you had yates as scum yesterday though before you hammered... is the calling out of the hammer enough for you to completly flip on him?

I put the game at L-1 in the very early stages....not on page 37 though

[mykonian]

no, it's the AV flip that changed stuff. Last post before I shut up and read.

And the "you" was in general. The rest of the game.

[jasonT1981]

Im not Questioning the hammer, just wondering why you didn't vote him earlier when you said you wanted him dead.

[AngryPidgeon]

I ran some ISOs after the flip, but then my other games opened up and I forgot to take any notes >.>

I guess I should adopt your QT strategy.

Re Yates: IDK, hes kind of drifting into nullville for me. His original back and forth with Jason looked town. He kept pushing his point despite getting votes for it, and AV had parked his vote on him early on. His reaction to my townread on him seemed a little forced and apparently was not a reaction test like I originally thought it was. And he has been fairly lurky since I replaced in. Honestly, Yates votes are a little weak right now. RC and Kise are probably scum. Not going to quote it, but that post where BC responded to me saying he could be scum with Mel rubbed me wrong. His reaction did not look town.

VOTE: Rapid Canyon

His alignment did not change over night.

Actually, I like where Mykonian is going.

UNVOTE:

VOTE: Mastin

[mastin2]

Hmm, fair 'nuff. Makes Zoro look town as well, by the way.

Unvote,
Vote: Zabriel.

[Yates]

quickhammer?

I obviously don't have a problem with the vote itself since it was the same wagon I was on. I also appreciate that it was a long day and ultimately that was the vote that was going to go through. However, RC put Mel at L-1 at noon. You hammered 80 minutes later without giving Mel a chance for a last post. I just want to know your thinking there.

[Yates]

His reaction to my townread on him seemed a little forced and apparently was not a reaction test like I originally thought it was.

Who says it

wasn't

a reaction test? Also, lol at "lurky." You can accuse a lot of people in this game of being "lurky," I however am not one of them.

[AngryPidgeon]

What makes Zoro look town?

Why Zabriel?

P-edit: That is reasonable, but I still don't think Mykonian's hammer was scummy. Did you honestly expect Melmond to get back in here and post in a time frame?

P-pedit: Lol, don't give me that BS. Was it or wasn't it. Pop quiz: If it was, then what did my response mean to you? Go!

[AngryPidgeon]

in a reasonable* time frame.

[Benmage]

I have no power as I live on long island NY... so yeah bare with be the next few days, also limited car charge time for phone as I burrow.

[AngryPidgeon]

This is taking way too long Yates.

[mastin2]

Vote: Jason

Overreaction to Nero, terrible reaction to Zoro.

Eh, replace Zoro with whoever he voted for claiming Snake. Acosmist?

You think AV-as-scum would confuse his scumbuddy with the actually-claimed PGO?

[AngryPidgeon]

What if The PGO is his scum buddy

I'm going to make the same point here that I did RE jason 'slip': That could easily be a 'slip'

[mastin2]

As for zabriel, it's entirely gut. Like I said, I haven't read the game, yet. Right now, I've got three in limbo (AP, Benmage, and Tammy) who I'm purposefully holding back on getting a read on for the moment, and six names to look at:

3. zabriel
5. Kise
8. PeregrineV
15. ThAdmiral
17. snifit
20. rapidcanyon

The others I see as town. Amrun and BC both had isos which looked town to me, hence why I eliminated them.

Ultimately, the goal should be to get down to 4-5 names, and right now, it's six-plus-three. (Consider limbo to be null.)

[Yates]

Did you honestly expect Melmond to get back in here and post in a time frame?

Yes. Why wouldn't I?

P-pedit: Lol, don't give me that BS. Was it or wasn't it. Pop quiz: If it was, then what did my response mean to you? Go!

To quote some 5 year old, "that's for me to know and you not to." Poignant words from someone that DID, in fact, wet their pants.

I have no power as I live on long island NY... so yeah bare with be the next few days, also limited car charge time for phone as I burrow.

Good luck, dude. I've got family in East Islip with sea water in their sun room. They are being told likely no power for another week.

[mastin2]

That could easily be a 'slip'

Could be? Yes, it could. Actually is? I sincerely doubt it. Occam's razor suggests he simply got two people mixed up, and simple logic dictates it's doubtful he mixed up a scumbuddy with someone who's not a scumbuddy.

Anyway, right now if you couldn't tell, I'm skimming isos to get a better hold of the game.

[Benmage]

We can lynch the pgo thats cool.

Yates I think... and definitely Tammy work.

No kill, guess I was doctored cool! Do it again.

No multiball aye?

[Yates]

No multiball aye?

I never thought we should consider that possibility until we saw evidence that suggested otherwise. Still - there is an outside shot it's an odd night/even night type of deal I suppose. Doesn't really change the way we scum hunt.

[AngryPidgeon]

Not saying I definitely believe it is. But I'm hesitant to draw any conclusion from it when AV was clearly somewhat aware of what he was doing. Its just WIFOM. I do think his Yates vote is probably on town though.

P-edit: You think Yates is town? Why were you asking about him then?

Anyone thinking Zab slipped about multiple teams is almost certainly wrong. I guess that has nothing to do with your vote. Mastin if I know anything about you, all those reads will change back and forth by the end of Today

I'm allowed to be mean since you called Nero a better scum hunter than me.

Just noticed Snifit in your reads list. I forgot about him, but he could be scum too. His behavior this game is just weird. Voting the Cyber wagon for being the smaller wagon is ? Mastin, you replaced Cyber right?

P-pedit:

Heres a theory Im working on. Mastin replaced in, was going to read the thread, saw the scum card, and now is pretending to not have read so he can justify not participating and responding to pressure or something.

@Benmage: Do you think Acosmist is scum, or is it just policy?

P-p-pedit: Yes, but it makes the zabriel case OBVIOUS BULLSHIT. Anyone talking about his 'slip' needs to die.

[mykonian]

Hmm, fair 'nuff. Makes Zoro look town as well, by the way.

Unvote,
Vote: Zabriel.

Someone is very eager to move away to a "save" wagon. I'm staying on mastin.

quickhammer?

I obviously don't have a problem with the vote itself since it was the same wagon I was on. I also appreciate that it was a long day and ultimately that was the vote that was going to go through. However, RC put Mel at L-1 at noon. You hammered 80 minutes later without giving Mel a chance for a last post. I just want to know your thinking there.

I didn't want a claim, didn't think it would change anything.

[Yates]

Yes, but it makes the zabriel case OBVIOUS BULLSHIT. Anyone talking about his 'slip' needs to die.

Oh. That's a good point. I just haven't been paying attention to that noise.

[mastin2]

By the way, preliminary scumteam of Kise, Snifit, Zabriel, with one of/both of Benmage/RC (depending on 4/5 scum) is what I've got so far. Admittedly, the only one of 'em I've iso'd is Kise (and he's only mildly scummy), with the rest by PoE and sheeping Nero's last scum list, as far as I could tell.

Also, kinda sorta think AP's outta limbo and into town, 'cause I did an iso of IaI. Wasn't much, but what little was there looked town, which'd make AP in that same slot town.

[AngryPidgeon]

Oh my god, did someone just call me town from an IaI ISO. Mastin...I...I want you. I want you so much right now. I'm about to cry. But seriously, why did you list Yates as possible scum, VOTE HIM, and then not include him in your formal scum list and then unvote him. In fact, you flat out called him town.

[mykonian]

because he actually doesn't know.

[Yates]

because he actually doesn't know.

Is this your subtle way of calling Mastin Town?