Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Legacy (Game Over)

[Amrun]

actually yes they did. But replace "replace out" and "getting called on lurking" and it's much the same. I was straight up lurking and completely ignoring this game for much of the day, but AFTER I try and get my shit together is when I catch flak for it? It doesn't make any sense.

[Nero Cain]

They were accusing me, I think. I never said you should replace out.

edit: Oh Yates said you should?

So why am I "retarded" for *gasps* suspecting you of being scum (which you yourself admit to ignoring the game) but not Ben?

[Amrun]

It wasn't a person-specific "you." It was a blanket "everyone who thinks my lurking has anything to do with this game or my alignment in it."

[jasonT1981]

Assertion that scum don't defend town: false.

Scum can often, you know... defend their partners...

Shocking, isn't it.

[AngryPidgeon]

Scum can often, you know, buddy townies.

Shocking, isn't it.

[jasonT1981]

So, if I am scum... why is your vote on Cybertronix?

[AngryPidgeon]

[Amrun]

Jason isn't scum, ap.

[Nero Cain]

Is AP scum?

[Amrun]

I'm null on him so far. But I am very confident in my jason read.

[Nero Cain]

AP, what did I do on page 1-3 that earned ,e a scum read?

[Acosmist]

ask me stuff too

what's your thoughts on this cyber wagon? who are your top scum reads?

top scumreads: thad, benmage, angrypidgeon

weird behavior: yates

cyber wagon is a distraction from actual scumwagons

[Acosmist]

@ThAd: What changed your mind about BC being scum?

@Acosmist: When can we expect the stuff irl to be over and get real content from you?

Looking at AP's ISO right now, should have a read on him shortly.

How is this not real content?

Wallposts with no content are, by definition, not real content.

I'm not reading them and my presumption is that anyone making one is scum trying to hide stuff behind squid ink.

So, by all means, let the scumclaims continue.

[Acosmist]

Second sentence doesn't make sense, but that doesn't seem relevant to this game.

Yates and I were in a pappums' modded game. If it doesn't make sense now then you're hopeless.

[Acosmist]

I really do not want to be up until all hours but I slept so late it seems likely to happen. Direct questions to me now. I will be away tomorrow morning until Sunday evening for a wedding in Pittsburgh.

[Kublai Khan]

@acosmist - summarize your scum reads.

[Acosmist]

I've been voting Pidgeon for a while and he doesn't acknowledge me at all. Obviously doesn't want to start a fight with my slot. But my vote is on him; how can he not? How can he be so sure that my vote is legit and I'm not scum trying to railroad him?

Benmage was saying things that were objectively bad strategy. Until someone comes along and says that Benmage is really, really bad at mafia, something I haven't noticed in my experience with him, I'm holding him to the standard of knowing the basics of the game. Bad advice is scum advice in cases that aren't borderline.

ThAd's posts (at least some of them) don't engage with the thread at all. It's like he's posting here accidentally and means to be responding to a different game. "Wait, that never happened" is my response to most of them replying to or talking about me. It's like he wishes I said things so that he could criticize them, but I didn't, but, hell, he's committed to the passive-aggression anyway, so RAMMING SPEED.

Yates is off. I'll figure out why he is off eventually.

[AngryPidgeon]

At acosmist: I think youre town and I dont care very much that you are voting me. I gave a reason for it. Plus Im on the side of occams Razor for PGO claim. Not sure if I said that part.

At nero:on phone watching Giants game, but you kept a RV up despite berating others for doing random votes and saying it was over.

[Acosmist]

At acosmist: I think youre town and I dont care very much that you are voting me. I gave a reason for it. Plus Im on the side of occams Razor for PGO claim. Not sure if I said that part.

At nero:on phone watching Giants game, but you kept a RV up despite berating others for doing random votes and saying it was over.

1. That's exactly the answer my rhetorical question was inviting.

2. You don't care? Could get you lynched. And you don't care?

3. If you don't say anything and, in fact, ignore me,

how am I supposed to assume it was Occam's Razor applied to my PGO claim?

If that's what it was, you could have said it. That you didn't is exactly why my vote is staying there.

[BloodCovenent]

I've been voting Pidgeon for a while and he doesn't acknowledge me at all. Obviously doesn't want to start a fight with my slot. But my vote is on him; how can he not? How can he be so sure that my vote is legit and I'm not scum trying to railroad him?

Benmage was saying things that were objectively bad strategy. Until someone comes along and says that Benmage is really, really bad at mafia, something I haven't noticed in my experience with him, I'm holding him to the standard of knowing the basics of the game. Bad advice is scum advice in cases that aren't borderline.

ThAd's posts (at least some of them) don't engage with the thread at all. It's like he's posting here accidentally and means to be responding to a different game. "Wait, that never happened" is my response to most of them replying to or talking about me. It's like he wishes I said things so that he could criticize them, but I didn't, but, hell, he's committed to the passive-aggression anyway, so RAMMING SPEED.

Yates is off. I'll figure out why he is off eventually.

you were just asked for scum reads, and you give this which is borderline fence sitting.

Why its fence sitting in my eyes

-You were asked scum reads
---You listed 4 players and called none of them scum .
---Of the listed players you mention shit they did, but don't mention how or if it's scummy.

I'd definitely be kosher with your lynch after a post like this.


Preview edit:
I just noticed Aco, you've been voting AP for 10 pages now (pretty much when he replaced in) for when he essentially poked fun at you. And your for your reasoning in your top line... well.... that's pretty shitty. If you've been paying attention to the thread, i think you would have better reads than the cop-out response you gave in post 666.

So aco, who are your real scum reads?

[Acosmist]

????????????????

Those are the real ones. Wanna lynch me today?

[Acosmist]

Because otherwise I'm not going away. YOU know that. So do your buddies. And damn if that ill-advised post isn't going to get you killed in this game.

[Acosmist]

You got daychat? Because damn if there aren't calls for you to replace out after that, huh?

[Acosmist]

Where's your vote, coward?

[BloodCovenent]

????????????????

Those are the real ones. Wanna lynch me today?

the only reason you gave for calling someone scum was benmage, and it was hardly any sound reasoning. If that's the best detective work you can do, we probably should lynch you pretty soon. >.>