Mafia in La-La Land (Game over!)

[PeregrineV]

ence to me questioning Mehdi? His vote on Reck set off my false-participation sensors. I'm not sure how you would interpret that as me defending Reck. I don't even have a read on Reck.

You asked the question in 135, and repeated the question in 137 after it was answered in 136.

I'M NOT ONLINE JUST TO HANG OUT WITH PEOPLE AND 5 PAGES?

NO

Vote: Reck

, mostly since first reaction being complaining about page length isn't something I consider a good reaction (personally while more reading the 5 pages are more of a good thing since it helps decide on people more).

So you think expressing dismay about the size of the game is something scum are more likely to do than town? Why? And why would voting him provoke him to talk more/sooner when the game has just started?

Yes I think it's more likely (reason past stated plus I don't consider 5 pages to be a ton of reading along with it sounds like a generic complaint thing).

As for the other question kind of weakened now that I said part of it was a pressure vote, but people tend to react in some way to pressure.

This seems like extremely spurious reasoning. You think that a player is more likely to be scum because they don't feel like reading 5 pages of RVS at 3 AM? Really?

I suspect you realize this and are too scared of backtracking to admit that it was a shitty vote.

[petapan]

yeah i know i see what you are saying but i am not sure that i agree

[Shamrock]

Do you understand what a rhetorical question is?

[4nxi3ty]

I mostly dislike the people he's been looking at more. PM and Jackal aren't exactly the best people to be examining right now imo (one's lurking the other is a VI).

Now is the time to be examining and lynching lurkers, given the slow state of the game.

Dislike the amount of talk dealing with lurkers at this stage of the game from him but beyond that nothing pings me for him.

"its okay scum, have no fear, continue lurking, I will not bother with you"

Has the point been made?

[PeregrineV]

@Reck- Have no fear, I don't think you're town.

Luckily, your buddy defended you while you were gone.

Vote: Shamrock

First statement is null.

Vote on shamrock is too concise and unmotivated. Reads as if he is already moving into a lurking position in this game. I think the best thing to do would be to force him into activity.

If it's too concise, I expanded upon it in the few posts above.
Asking a question and getting an answer is part of the game.
Getting an answer, disagreeing, and saying so, also part of the game.
Asking, getting an answer, asking again as a form of saying the question was never answered, is part of the game, but casts suspicion on the asker, which is also defending the orginal topic of the question (in this case Reck)

@Inox- Why don't you go ahead and try some of those walls you were talking about.

Peregrine, what was the purpose of you posting this?

Read post 88. Read the Iso of Inox.
I'm not getting a good enough read on the basis of his current posting level or style. If he feels more comfortable using walls, then he should do so.

[PeregrineV]

nahh that doesn't look like a partner defense tbh

Why not?

[PeregrineV]

yeah i know i see what you are saying but i am not sure that i agree

That's different. As long as you can see what I'm talking about, then I'm not imagining it.

It's not a strong defense, which is why it stuck out to me.

[MattP]

PV is probtown

[4nxi3ty]

yup his recent flurry of posts seems to indicate that despite reading shamrock's posts incorrectly.

[xRECKONERx]

I'm still on the site. I just want D1 to end because I hate long D1s.

[MattP]

Then vote manho yo

[xRECKONERx]

no

[MattP]

Read on manho go

Also everyones like lukewarm reads on manho but refusal to vote him is pretty damn telling when he flips scum

[xRECKONERx]

N/A

[MattP]

Ok princess

[xRECKONERx]

<3

[Bitmap]

VOTE: manho

[Bitmap]

I'll post later tonight after I get to lvl 30.

[Staeg]

Prodded

GW2

Post and catchup later today

[xRECKONERx]

yeah GW2

[Bitmap]

yeah, GW2 excuse bandwagon

[Mehdi2277]

Lean town for PV based on recent posts is the only read change.

And matt as for the luke warm thing that applies to kondi fine too (and the fact that two counter wagons have appeared to him that people have moved more to when they appeared).

[DeasVail]

I don't agree with lynching manho and I think we should have more posts from him/his slot before that because it's possible that if he's town, he could prove himself to be, and I don't even think he's that scummy. I agree with others that a Kondi lynch is better and there's something else about him (and others too), but I want to wait a bit before saying it.

I still think a Konowa lynch is best though, and I really don't think people should just conclude that he's town for attacking Mehdi (which isn't even that risky from scum's PoV), especially when there are things that are scummy about him.

[Quilford]

Day 1

manho

(5) MattP, petapan, kondi2424, Gammagooey, Bitmap

kondi2424

(4) Mehdi2277, PMysterious, Shiidaji, Konowa

Konowa

(3) Staeg, DeasVail, manho

MattP

(2) Jackal711, Seastormjt

PMysterious

(2) Shamrock, 4nxi3ty

PeregrineV

(1) xRECKONERx

Shamrock

(1) PeregrineV

petapan

(1) Inox

Jackal711

(1) AGar

Not Voting

(1) Blastoide

---

With 21 alive, it takes 11 to lynch or No Lynch.

Deadline hits in 4 days, 15 hours, 9 minutes.

Activity

Searching for a replacement for Jackal711.

Now searching for AGar replacement (he requested it). Suspending deadline until I get both. Might also have to replace Inox. (sigh)

EDIT: Knight of Cydonia replaces Jackal711. Thank you, and welcome!

Seastormjt's semi-prod is being upgraded to a full prod.

Konowa has declared V/LA during weekends.

[Knight of Cydonia]

S'up bitches. Anything in particular I need to hear about before I start reading?