Mafia in La-La Land (Game over!)

[Seastormjt]

@Sham -- 8, and two more that are ongoing. Some of them we've died early in, but yeah, ~8.

[Shamrock]

oh I forgot to VOTE: PMysterious

[DeasVail]

He appears unaware that anyone other than Shii called him town for attacking Mehdi. I was thinking this could be scum trying to look town in this way, but I don't think it's all that likely, and I think it's likely he would be aware of opinions of him as scum. I do tend to call people town for bad reasons though, so I'd like opinions on this, especially since I actually think the last point for him being scum is good.

Can people please tell me what they think of this?

Also, I'm still kind of eh on Kondi. He could easily be scum from most of his posts, but I'm not sure if he'd go for the hydra-attack as scum. I think Konowa's more scummy anyway.

[PMysterious]

DV, I will clarify. You believe that townme would have said “Yep, you guys are right. I was wrong.” instead of actually explaining my read and thought process? Right now, I am null on Mehdi. I was asking since you disagreed with my scumread, why? Or rather, what has he done to make you think he is town? All I see are posts.

Also,

I think that scum may be less likely to attack a popular townread, but I can see scum doing it in the way that Konowa did and I think that how he went about the whole thing and the way that he changed his mind are how scum would act.

This is crap. Why are you talking out of both sides of your mouth?

Also, Konowa, what is your opinion on people finding you town for attacking medhi?

To be honest, I do not know why you are asking

me

this question. Unless I am mistaken, Shiidaji is the only one saying that. Others have said that while they disagree with reasoning, they can see why I would say that.

peta, I tried to create a flash in a pan by withholding my read and being obnoxious about it.

261 is cheering from the sidelines and is scummy.

All of your statements are wrong.

1)Yes it is accusatory. That is the point.
2)Was asking Reck to clarify his statement since what I said was two parts.
3)It is not negligable. I view Reck's entrance post as null, so for someone else to see it as scummy and combining the fact that said person has not said anything worthwhile so far it is relevant.
4)Yes I am asking for scum reads from Mehdi because he hasn't said anything yet. Why would this be an afterthought?

Nope, I'm right

I don't care who's right. As long as we lynch Scum, I'm happy.

Please explain how this is scummy. I'll be glad to defend myself if you do.

[petapan]

Also, I'm still kind of eh on Kondi. He could easily be scum from most of his posts, but I'm not sure if he'd go for the hydra-attack as scum. I think Konowa's more scummy anyway.

i don't know what you mean by this. i think he's bullshitting his reads - as town i'd see more reasoning, more thought process but he's just kind of pulling things out of his ass and comes across as overconfident in what he says.

[petapan]

Fuck me.

You are actually playing very close in tone to your town meta.

i was just about to say that tonally he comes across as scummy lmao

Derp what do you think of Inox? ISO the bitch

i had him as eager newbie who was sort of fish out of waterhad dumb reasons for his suspicions but i didn't think he was just trying to adhere to a formula i dunno man (although my day 1 reads aren't the bset thing in large games because there's so much information to process so i wouldn't lean heavily on what i say(but kondi is still scum))

[petapan]

Blatant school proddodge. Weekend is coming up, I should be able to do something.

quoting for when he doesn't deliver

[Quilford]

Day 1

kondi2424

(7) Mehdi2277, PMysterious, Shiidaji, Bitmap, Gammagooey, petapan, Konowa

Konowa

(5) Staeg, xRECKONERx, kondi2424, DeasVail, 4nxi3ty

MattP

(3) manho, Jackal711, Seastormjt

PMysterious

(1) Shamrock

Inox

(1) MattP

Shamrock

(1) PeregrineV

petapan

(1) Inox

Jackal711

(1) AGar

Not Voting

(1) Blastoide

---

With 21 alive, it takes 11 to lynch or No Lynch.

Deadline hits in (expired on 2012-09-02 00:09:48).

Activity

Sorry for not getting to this sooner; unexpected LA.

Jackal711 has requested replacement. Wheeeee.

manho has declared V/LA until the 22nd.
Bitmap has declared V/LA until the 23rd.
Jackal711 has declared V/LA until the 22nd.

Konowa has declared V/LA during weekends.

[DeasVail]

It's the main thing holding me back from a scumread, because it's based on a hydra, so is unlikely to be able to convince anyone (When I went back and had a look, even I had trouble distinguishing his posts from mine) and is something he as scum may not attempt because it could very well be considered a bad reason to be on the wagon ---> scummy. I also think it's fairly believable that Kondi would think that as town.

This is pretty much what I meant, but I'm not really opposed to the wagon on him.

You all could come join me on Konowa instead though! (And another thing: The last time I asked for opinions on something I found townish about a scumread and no one answered, the scumread was scum! So, you all have to vote for him now.)

[petapan]

nahhh i think that's scum reasoning tbqh - cherry picking a single game and saying "he's acting different" is the ultimate weaksauce

[kondi2424]

Peta, would you say your main reasoning for thinking I'm scummy is that I don't have as much reasoning for my reads as usual?

[petapan]

"as usual" would be a fallacy - as town from when i've seen you, you don't say much but there's a thread of logic - i don't see that here and i think you pulled your big list of reads out of your ass

[Shiidaji]

Huh.

Hi as evidenced by my extremely low post count I'm not from around here.
Is there anything in particular I should know about this community before I do something notoriously stupid? (i.e. Things that are considered UNSPEAKABLE OFFENSES, philosophy on no lynches, etc...)

That said

Vote: DeasVail

Because

that question!

Inoxbb what are you referring to in the last line of the above?

[petapan]

he answered it in his ISO because someone already asked him this

[Shiidaji]

Shshhhash peta sigh

[Gammagooey]

okay yeah

i wouldn't be sad about a kondi lynch but peregrine's posts are aggressive horseshit with nothing behind it and I think he's a better shot at scum right now.

as a side note i don't see scum motivation in mattp's posts and don't see why there are people voting him in general.

Vote: PeregrineV

[xRECKONERx]

I'm gonna just sheep Gamma because I'm drunk and I trust him

vote peregrinev

[Gammagooey]

wooooooooooooo

[MattP]

I love that reck is town

[4nxi3ty]

The only thing kondi has done that is scummy to me is disappear since my wagon took off. I believe that PM's cheering from the sideline is scummier though. I have no read on Bitmap, other than he is low- content.

bitmap has been absent while posting elsewhere And his posts have been sideliny as well.

PV lynch over kondi lynch? Definitely.

instead of bitmap or PM?

scratches chin

unvote,vote: pmysterious

[manho]

finally catch up.

i like konowa's first post, but his backtracking of the vote is scummy.

unvote, vote: konowa

and i also want reads from mehdi.

inox is scummy for being paranoid.
agar is scummy for not taking part in the conversation around konowa. for detail, see page 8 and his ISO.

mattp is probably town and i'll sheep his kondi case if he is 100% sure about the meta thing.
reck is also probably town.

[MattP]

Manho why the fuck are you binding me to the meta case

[petapan]

that was a p. scummy post by manho i don't really like it

[manho]

Manho why the fuck are you binding me to the meta case

because i don't wanna spend anytime doing meta case. and i've seen magical meta case that caught scum out of no where.

[MattP]

Nah

You're scum