Mini 1368 (Game Over)

[triangle123]

It's RVS, any read gained at this stage is temporary, I have no idea if it's going to move into a full scum read or change into a town read. It being a very weak read means that I don't trust it. I'm sorry if me explaining the full level of a read thus far as confused you.

How do you see his preference for circles over triangles to be related to his alignment enough to be translated into any level of a read? Why did you avoid participating in RVS in your first post of the game?

[Cheery Dog]

It's RVS, any read gained at this stage is temporary, I have no idea if it's going to move into a full scum read or change into a town read. It being a very weak read means that I don't trust it. I'm sorry if me explaining the full level of a read thus far as confused you.

How do you see his preference for circles over triangles to be related to his alignment enough to be translated into any level of a read? Why did you avoid participating in RVS in your first post of the game?

My first post didn't need a vote, The only post that struck me as needing anything done was FUT's post, which from reading his posts elsewhere on the site (ongoings) told me was because he wasn't used this site's style of play. I didn't feel this was worthy a vote.

Basketballstar's reasoning of the preference for circles just confused me as there is no real angle in a circle, since there is only the one line. To put the analogy in complicatedness; he must be wanting all of us connected and be attacking each other while getting nowhere. If it were a triangle, there would most likely be three sides attacking each other for the advantage.
I believe that as town, being laid out as a triangle formation will serve us better.

[pappums rat]

LOL.

Unvote
Vote: Cheery Dog

You really think a throwaway random vote reason for voting someone has anything worthy of analysis in it? It looks like you are trying to create something from nothing.

[Cheery Dog]

Well we have nothing so far, so what else am I meant to be working with?

[Melmond]

So we have shape speculation and dogs vs dogs so far...
From cheerys analysis, this must mean triangle123 is town and pieceofpecan3.14 is scum

[Cheery Dog]

So we have shape speculation and dogs vs dogs so far...
From cheerys analysis, this must mean triangle123 is town and pieceofpecan3.14 is scum

Why does my analysis mean that pieceofpcanpie is scum? I haven't said anything about him.

All that pieceofpecanpie has done is claim miller, and as far as I see, doing that would most likely be something only a miller would do, thus rendering him in fact town. If you're working on the shape of a pie, it also means nothing because he's only a piece, which would probably be cone-shaped, which fits into my analogy as being a miller.

[Melmond]

Lol, just making a funny.. Pi has to do with circles

[Cheery Dog]

The information gained from pi tells us the circumference and area of a circle, these are capable of changing between circles and therefore the information gathered still doesn't fit into my analysis of shapes and how the angles of them relate to the game of mafia.

[FUT]

Dem mixed votes.

@ poppums rat, Yes, I play on debate.org.

[FUT]

Unvote

[ChaosOmega]

Vote Count 1.01

Cheery Dog (3) - Hellhound1, triangle123, pappums rat
pappums rat (2) - pieceofpecanpie, Idiotking
Kublai Khan (2) - Nobody Special, Lupo
Nobody Special (1) - Paschendale
basketballstar24 (1) - Cheery Dog
pieceofpecanpie (1) - Melmond
triangle123 (1) - basketballstar24
Hellhound1 (1) - Kublai Khan

Not Voting (1) - FUT

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

Deadline

~13 days and 8 hours

[Lupo]

Basketballstar's reasoning of the preference for circles just confused me as there is no real angle in a circle, since there is only the one line. To put the analogy in complicatedness; he must be wanting all of us connected and be attacking each other while getting nowhere. If it were a triangle, there would most likely be three sides attacking each other for the advantage.
I believe that as town, being laid out as a triangle formation will serve us better.

Why does my analysis mean that pieceofpcanpie is scum? I haven't said anything about him.

All that pieceofpecanpie has done is claim miller, and as far as I see, doing that would most likely be something only a miller would do, thus rendering him in fact town. If you're working on the shape of a pie, it also means nothing because he's only a piece, which would probably be cone-shaped, which fits into my analogy as being a miller.

The information gained from pi tells us the circumference and area of a circle, these are capable of changing between circles and therefore the information gathered still doesn't fit into my analysis of shapes and how the angles of them relate to the game of mafia.

......wtf

[Paschendale]

Cheery's fluffy geometry posting is distracting at best. Active lurking at worst.

[pappums rat]

Well we have nothing so far, so what else am I meant to be working with?

Certainly not some bizarre-ass shit about the psychology of choosing a circle over a triangle as your favorite shape or whatever the fuck you were saying. If your vote on him was just for chuckles I wouldnt be pushing you on this, but when you say you have a scumread on someone based off of horseshit like this and are serious about it, it tingles my scumdar because it looks like you are grasping at straws to lay down a serious vote on someone.

[Kublai Khan]

All that pieceofpecanpie has done is claim miller, and as far as I see, doing that would most likely be something only a miller would do, thus rendering him in fact town.

I've fakeclaimed miller as scum.

Why didn't you answer my questions from Post 25.

[triangle123]

Basketballstar's reasoning of the preference for circles just confused me as there is no real angle in a circle, since there is only the one line. To put the analogy in complicatedness; he must be wanting all of us connected and be attacking each other while getting nowhere. If it were a triangle, there would most likely be three sides attacking each other for the advantage.
I believe that as town, being laid out as a triangle formation will serve us better.

This is stretching very hard. It's one thing to push someone over some minor tell and call it a weak scum read just to get things out of RVS or whatnot, but it just feels like you're trying way too much to make yourself look pro-active.

Lupo, Paschendale, do you have a read on CD?

[Hellhound1]

UNVOTE:
VOTE: Cheery Dog

Why place a vote on someone for convoluted reasoning if you think your scum read on them is going to be temporary?

It's RVS, any read gained at this stage is temporary, I have no idea if it's going to move into a full scum read or change into a town read. It being a

very weak

read means that I don't trust it. I'm sorry if me explaining the full level of a read thus far as confused you.

unvote

Vote: Hellhound1

Others haven't been voted for yet, why Cheery Dog over them?

hell hound
Cheery dog

Hope that clears it up for you

because our names are polar opposites?

Yep, that was pretty much the reason. Just thought it was funny.

The information gained from pi tells us the circumference and area of a circle, these are capable of changing between circles and therefore the information gathered still doesn't fit into my analysis of shapes and how the angles of them relate to the game of mafia.

I really still cant see how that has anything to do with mafia anyway.
A scumread on someone for angles is just wtf.

[FUT]

I have doubts cheery dog is actually scum. He is Jester at best. His posts don't seem indicative of something mafia would do, TBH.

[pappums rat]

I have doubts cheery dog is actually scum. He is Jester at best. His posts don't seem indicative of something mafia would do, TBH.

Spoiler:

This is a normal game, there is no possibility of there being a jester in this game.

[pieceofpecanpie]

Circles, triangles? What the jolly hell is going on?

[Idiotking]

I have doubts cheery dog is actually scum. He is Jester at best. His posts don't seem indicative of something mafia would do, TBH.

Why? As pappums rat has said, Cheery claimed a minor scum read for something that means nothing at all. That led to a stupid argument about the nature of circles and triangles. I personally don't see it as a tell either way, just an annoying distraction, but you seem to indicate that it means that Cheery is somehow not scum. What would lead you to that conclusion?

[pieceofpecanpie]

What would lead you to that conclusion?

I'm interested in the response to this.

[Lupo]

Basketballstar's reasoning of the preference for circles just confused me as there is no real angle in a circle, since there is only the one line. To put the analogy in complicatedness; he must be wanting all of us connected and be attacking each other while getting nowhere. If it were a triangle, there would most likely be three sides attacking each other for the advantage.
I believe that as town, being laid out as a triangle formation will serve us better.

This is stretching very hard. It's one thing to push someone over some minor tell and call it a weak scum read just to get things out of RVS or whatnot, but it just feels like you're trying way too much to make yourself look pro-active.

Lupo, Paschendale, do you have a read on CD?

Well I always try to read past games for behavior differences and what-not. He actually appears to be an intelligent player in other games. As in talking about stuff that actually matters. I don't really have a town-scum read on him just yet. However, he is acting strange in this game.

[Paschendale]

Lupo, Paschendale, do you have a read on CD?

I'm not really sure what he's doing. But other than ensure that we don't know how to approach him, he doesn't seem to be pushing any kind of agenda. But as I said, possibly active lurking.

I'm also not sure about Pecanpie's miller claim. Those will be important details to keep in mind when evaluating them later.

Interesting that Melmond joined in the weird triangle/circle talk.

[Kublai Khan]

Hellhound1 needs more votes.