Toy Story Mafia (Day 9)

[NanookTheWolf]

Mod will be gone until tomorrow ... Eager to hear the result.

[Juls]

The play of Spyrex and diddin have really really really made me think they are both scum today. This post in particular has me really contemplating shooting one of them:

Look, if you REALLY think we ran the scum-mason gambit from the start and you take that shot, fine. I'll give you good natured rage when the game ends.

However, please, please, dont throw away the game as an FU to him.

Here Spyrex pretty much KNOWS I am town but he floats back and forth between me being town throwing the game away and scum. Yet he is 97.54% sure I am scum. Diddin also slows down once I say I am going to shoot him. Which is essentially a town win if they are scum. (I would love to see Spyrex talk his way out of that one)

Also, here:

Mind you, I actually thought Ken/Barbie would be ballsy to be fakeclaims together but.

like seriously you think the Mod would give us BOTH Potato Heads as fakeclaims?

Yeah, that looks like Spyrex patting his own back a little too early.

So I am not shooting. I have presented my evidence. The win or loss is on you (remaining town). Call me chicken shit or whatever. The only thing that is stopping me from pulling the trigger on diddin is that for 6 days I thought Spyrex was town. I never thought diddin was so LOL-protown. Also, one of you look back in the night (I don't have time), but see if the same "crumbing" that has occurred with Spy/diddin occurred with nintendo/diddin. I would wager that it does not. So good luck town, you are going to need it. If Spyrex and diddin are said town, well sorry for doubting you. If you aren't, at least I made a last case on you, which is more than what can be said for what you did to me. diddin, do me a favor and avoid me. I really dislike the way you play. Calling someone a "fucking idiot" repeatedly just makes you

look like

an ass hole.

@mod: I choose not to shoot anyone

[Juls]

The smart play here would have been to lynch one of the masons so that there was no question going into tomorrow. Now tomorrow is going to be a "do we believe the masons or not?".

[jmurph3]

@Juls: why would you not shoot one of the masons to confirm them, then? You have that opportunity and you're not taking it, and at this point, I don't see why you're not doing so. If you are town and believe the masons to be scum (which, if you are town, is quite possibly the case), why not take your shot on one of them to determine if they are or aren't?

[SpyreX]

If your town not taking the shot right now under the guise of "masons may be scum" is no different than taking the shot on us and losing it right here.

Shooting FA, yes, guarantees a win for scum-masons hooo. In all other scenarios it makes tomorrow a cakewalk.

However, I'm still bettin on that scum flip.

[Juls]

You guys can't seriously think i am scum? Taking a shot now and being wrong guarantees we lose. Why would I even post a case if I was scum? I'm going to let the final town decide tomorrow. Take what I said and do the best you can. I basically don't want to be blamed if I am wrong. I want you to be blamed. Have fun.

[SpyreX]

If you're not scum something very irritating is going on.

Its that simple.

[Flavour Analysis]

It doesn't matter if you are wrong or not. You are wasting your ability by not shooting.

Also there may be a chance you were just bluffing about being able to shoot, so I can see why you don't want to shoot.

[Juls]

Well if you are town spy you should have more confidence that you can find scum than me taking a shot. If you are scum I didn't do what to expected and now you have to work hard to explain why you and diddi will be alive tomorrow as I suspect will be the case.

[Scott Brosius]

Flavor here, no time, spotty internet.

Juls, Mr. Pricklepants (Townie) lynched Day 7!

Juls has a vengeful power which may be used 24 hours from this post. The game is still in twilight for all effects except the thread is locked. Night will go into effect 24 hours from this post.




[/color]
[/b]

[/b]

[Scott Brosius]

It is Night 7. Actions are due Oct 2 at 2pm EST.

[Scott Brosius]

Nanook is on the floor! How many of these darn green things are there?

NanookTheWolf, Alien #3 (Neighbor) killed Night 7

It is now Day 8!

Vote Count 8-1

diddin

(0)-

Flavour Analysis

(0)-

jmurph3

(0)-

petroleumjelly

(0)-

SpyreX

(0)-



Not Voting (5)- diddin, Flavour Analysis, jmurph3, petroleumjelly, SpyreX

With 5 alive, it's 3 to a lynch.

Deadline is October 10th at 1pm EST.

[/b]

[/b]

[jmurph3]

Alright. The "Masons"

have

to be the remaining scum. There's no way around that. I neighborized FA again last night. Same flavor-based result. Unless Mod is pulling a hugely bastard move by having Woody be scum, it's gotta be the masons.

[diddin]

No. PJ is the last scum.

Vote: PJ

[Flavour Analysis]

It's possible. I am interested in Spy's thoughts.

...

Wait. Jmurph, have you ever suspected the Masons? If not, why do you suspect them now?

[petroleumjelly]

diddin: UNVOTE. ME. NOW.

I am

NOT

about to be lynched. And I am

not

buying the Masons as scum. They've been on my town list since forever. I'm actually a bit surprised the Masons are alive over Nanook, but I guess that only makes this easier:

The scum here are jmurph3 and FlavourAnalysis. End of story.

Everything -- and I mean

everything

-- points to FlavourAnalysis being scum.

Where did the Night One Mafia kill go?

The answer is that FlavourAnalysis sent in the kill (or at least felt compelled to "cover" for his buddies, whichever). Furthermore, the

only

thing confirming FlavourAnalysis as "Woody" is jmurph3 herself. And additionally, FlavourAnalysis could not give a straight answer on whether or not jmurph3 was "confirmed Town" or merely "confirmed Bullseye": obviously FlavourAnalysis did not want jmurph3 getting lynched, so he tried to toe the line as closely as possible. But he still minced his words whenever it came to giving an opinion on jmurph3.

1.)

jmurph3, why do the Masons "have" to be the remaining scum?

2.)

diddin, why do you think I'm scum? And furthermore, why do you think I'm the "last" scum? Do you seriously think this game only has (had?) four scum in it?

[petroleumjelly]

In case it's not clear: I will lynch jmurph3 and FlavourAnalysis in any order. I do not care.

[jmurph3]

Why do the masons have to be the remaining mafia? It's called PoE. I know that I am town. I can only, by Mod's rules, neighborize those with the flavor of Woody and Jessie. Since FA is Woody, that makes he and I town (again, unless mod is being bastard with flavor. Which thus far hasn't been the case). Given the PRs in the town, my guess is that there are 2 scum left. Spyrex and Diddin confirmed each other. That means that unless one of them is a liar and scum with you, PJ, they have to be the two remaining scum.

[petroleumjelly]

What's the difference between SpyreX and diddin "confirming" each other to you and FlavourAnalysis "confirming" each other?

And furthermore, why have you suddenly shifted to claiming you can only neighborize somebody with the

"flavor"

of Woody as opposed to the

role name

of Woody?

[jmurph3]

Because there's a big difference between a role name - i.e. cop, doc, etc. - and flavor. I don't recall ever stating that Woody was FA's role, just his flavor or character.

And the big difference is in RA's flip. The Jessie flip - and the confirmation of my neighboring with RA - proves what I'm saying. We talked about it and it just doesn't make any sense otherwise.

[petroleumjelly]

I agree there is a

huge

different between role name and flavor, and that's not a distinction I recall you making before.

And actually, hold it. One sec.

[petroleumjelly]

And the big difference is in RA's flip. The Jessie flip - and the confirmation of my neighboring with RA - proves what I'm saying. We talked about it and it just doesn't make any sense otherwise.

Who is "we"? Don't think, just respond.

[jmurph3]

FA and I. But stop trying to change the subject. The distinction was implicit, and I think I might have even said something to that effect when the confusion between Bobs and FA was happening. If I've only ever claimed to confirm FA's flavor or character, and haven't said one thing about his role, then clearly I have no way or knowing or trying to know about his role.

[petroleumjelly]

OOOOH

yes. Yes yes yes.

[petroleumjelly]

(Wow, I am

shaking

as I am writing this post.)

All right: jmurph3 has just

confirmed

being scum with FlavourAnalysis. Earlier in the game when jmurph3 claimed her role, she said:

I am Bullseye. I am a lonely neighbor - i.e. a very limited neighborizer. I can pick one person a night to neighborize, but will only successfully neighborize them if they are Woody or Jessie, and even then, can only be neighbors with them one at a time. I neighborized Ray on N1 with no result. I neighborized FA on N2, and found that he was, in fact, Woody (which is yet another reason why I think Bobs is full of it). On N3 I neighborized Spyrex with no result.

@RandomActs: If I neighborize you tonight,

we will not be able to talk until N5

(assuming we are both still alive). If you have a pertinent role, it might be best to claim it now before the mystery of it leads to your death.

Basically, jmurph3 has been claiming she cannot talk to people on the same night she neighborizes them. But just now, jmurph3 claimed she neighborized FlavourAnalysis

last night

(i.e., could not talk to him) but that she has somehow

talked with FlavourAnalysis concerning Jessie’s (RandomActs’) death.

Hey, guess what? THAT IS NOT POSSIBLE. At least, it is not possible

unless they are scum together.

For the love of all that is good and holy, lynch them.

Jesus criminy diddin, you better fucking log on and unvote me

NOW.