Quig wrote:Nah, lynch Anix, kill sotty, lynch Llyod then we of already won or its a draw.
Well, the problem there is "kill Sotty". If she dies, then
I'm
the next lynch, not Lloyd.
Plan A ("lynch AniX, test Vyo"): If I'm telling the truth about being doc, then Sotty lives tonight and we lynch Lloyd, leaving Quig and myself to win (or draw* if Quig is somehow cult). If Sotty dies, then I get lynched tomorrow, leaving Quig and Lloyd; if both are town, congratulations, but if Lloyd is SK he wins on his own.
Plan B ("lynch AniX, shoot Vyo"): I come up doc, Lloyd ges lynched and it's the same draw*/win scenario only this time with Sotty and Quig; I come up not-doc, then Sotty, Quig, and Lloyd have to figure out where to go from there if the game isn't over. Lloyd could still be SK, in theory, so lynching someone other than him could be dicey.
Plan C ("lynch Lloyd"): there will be no more night kills. If the game isn't over, then the four of us have to figure out how many cultists we have left -- knowing that Quig is most likely clean -- and lynch accordingly, without the spectre of an SK win hanging in the air. Potential snag in that it would be three to lynch, so having two cult left might cause problems.
Both Plans A and B have the same end result: tomorrow's lynch ends the game one way or the other, unless the game is ended at night as a result of Lloyd's kill. Also, "Sotty" and "AniX" are still interchangeable as far as I'm concerned.
Plan C gives the town two chances to clear out the cult without the possibility of SK win if there's only one cultist left; even if we lynch wrong tomorrow, then it's still two townies to one cultist. If there are two, then it's a draw*.
*Note that in all cases I'm assuming that if there are an even number of cultists and townies then the game ends in a draw and not a cult win. The only way the cult can win right now is if this is not the case; it would also be helpful for them if there are two cultists left.
In the beginning there was nothing, which exploded. -- Terry Pratchett, [u]Lords and Ladies[/u]