Brightest Day Mafia, Part 1 - GAME OVER

[The Book of Oa]

Posting in colors is still against the rules, Magister Ludi.

[Magister Ludi]

Opps. Sorry.

[hiplop]

WHAT? When is town ever ok to be killed? This is the last day town will probably have the majority. No way in hell am I happy about being lynched, and we learn nothing about the game that we didn't already know.

That makes no sense. Are you happy if we lynched you?

Subliminal vote?

fair enough

[Mr Subliminal]

yes. I think there is a good chance he is anti-town. Looking at the WL pm, unless I'm fucking blind; theres nothing in those posts that proves ANYTHING. It honestly makes a lot of sense.

Do you think zMuffinMan is lying about seeing the obvious breadcrumb, then?

Here. We'll be more obvious.

Read the WL PM.

Read #675.

Tell us whether or not you see the breadcrumb.

[Magister Ludi]

Heh, reading from a fakeclaim proves nothing.

Hiplop, now's your time to activate

[Mr Subliminal]

(This is of course neverminding the fact that zMuffinMan already confirmed its there, and that if we were CR, we can't have any recruits due to NPIAU being N1 recruit and us being blocked N2.)

Heh, reading from a fakeclaim proves nothing.

Hiplop, now's your time to activate

That's very interesting

sarcasm

coming from someone who's entire defense is based around his claim.

[hiplop]

GODDAMIT. I feel fucking stupid now.

My bad I see it

[Kdub]

UNVOTE:

We still have time and we should try to figure out a plan. Once we do, I'll put my vote back on unless an argument for a better lynch candidate surfaces.

[hiplop]

was busy working with high LIGHTS

[Magister Ludi]

Heh, your defense for not being Cult Recruiter is that you have no recruits? So sorry about that MR. recruiter, maybe better luck next game.

[Mr Subliminal]

Heh, your defense for not being Cult Recruiter is that you have no recruits? So sorry about that MR. recruiter, maybe better luck next game.

No, the defense against being cult recruiter is obvtown play plus WL claim. Your attack that "Oh, your WL claim is a fakeclaim" is just lulzy given that your entire defense is "Guiz, I'm a blue ring doctor!!1111eleventyone".

@Kdub:

The plan is:

Toasty jailkeeps Kast
vezokpiraka delays Kast
Andrius roleblocks Mr Subliminal
Oversoul tracks whomever the fuck he wants
Blackberry investigates whomever the fuck he wants
Nikanor, MuffinMan, hiplop do whatever the fuck they want
Someone gives us a ring

[Magister Ludi]

That's one of the funniest crap defense's I've ever heard. "I have no recruits. Spare me!"

Half of my defense is certainly, being the only original blue lantern, original doctor, and my role balancing the game, already a doctor fakelcaim out there, yeah, It's pretty certain I'm not fakeclaiming.

[Kdub]

Mr. S, can you explain the reasoning behind each of those actions for the plan?

I have follow-up comments, but I'll wait to hear your explanation.

[Mr Subliminal]

The fake claim was a JOAT. By your logic, BB and Kdub are clear too. Because of a JOAT fakeclaim? No.

[hiplop]

wait.. under ludis thing about possible fake claims

Why would dana give Toogelloo a Fake claim of a role SOMEONE ELSE HAS????

[Mr Subliminal]

Toog's claim was JOAT, NOT Doc!

[Mr Subliminal]

Half of my defense is certainly, being the only original blue lantern, original doctor, and my role balancing the game, already a doctor fakelcaim out there, yeah, It's pretty certain I'm not fakeclaiming.

That's actually all of your defense, because Lord knows you haven't played a town game at all.

Mr. S, can you explain the reasoning behind each of those actions for the plan?

Er. Thought it was pretty cut and dried, but ok:

Toasty jailkeeps Kast - Toasty, Ludi, and Kast are the three potential CRs. If Ludi is dead, Toasty jailkeeps Kast.
vezokpiraka delays Kast - No other good target for vezok to delay.
Andrius roleblocks Mr Subliminal - We would vastly prefer that Andrius roleblock Toasty at this point, as that would have all of the CR candidates blocked. But, for whatever derp reason, Andrius thinks we're the recruiter, and it's easier to say "roleblock us" than it is to convince him otherwise.
Oversoul tracks whomever the fuck he wants - We think it's pretty obvious from play that Oversoul is not lying about his claim, so is not the recruiter.
Blackberry investigates whomever the fuck he wants - Same as Oversoul.
Nikanor, MuffinMan, hiplop do whatever the fuck they want - White Lanterns are not recruiter, not mafia
Someone gives us a ring - We'd really like one.

[Magister Ludi]

BB and Kdub are clear too.

Pretty sure they are both town at this point. You don't?

[Kdub]

...

OK, question for the White Lanterns. Given two CR suspects of equal scumminess (with no other players being possibilities), with one being a WL and the other being a non-WL, what is the % chance you ascribe to the WL being the CR? How "clear" the WLs are is really the key here. Because Mr. S last post just gave me some major reservations about what I've been thinking.

Gonna be offline for a little bit, be back in maybe an hour.

[Andrius]

Andrius roleblocks Mr Subliminal - We would vastly prefer that Andrius roleblock Toasty at this point, as that would have all of the CR candidates blocked. But, for whatever derp reason, Andrius thinks we're the recruiter, and it's easier to say "roleblock us" than it is to convince him otherwise.

SOMEONE's gotta do the right thing here.
Toasty's not CR unless shenanigans with Oversoul.
So yeah.
Because Nik/Toast would have worked perfectly D1... but the argument that recruition comes AFTER death...

HEY MODS: If someone was culted and killed the same night, would they die before they were culted, or after?

Someone gives us a ring - We'd really like one.

[hiplop]

^ why is kdub clear

Ninja'd: Eh probably like 60-40? It all depends if the recruiter/mafia got fake claims, I guess. I highly doubt ANY of my WL buds are CR <3

[Mr Subliminal]

You're clearing people off a fuckig JOAT fake claim. THIS DOESNT WORK!

PEDIT: We strongly believe all the WLs started as town.
PEDIT 2: OMG ANDRIUS THAT SAME FUCKING QUESTION HAS BEEN ASKED TWICE ALREADY

[Mr Subliminal]

Of the other possibilities for lynch, we believe Kast's claim far, far, far, far more than Ludi's because of Kast's breadcrumb, and we believe Toasty's claim more than Ludi's because Toasty appears to give at least 3/8s of a damn about town, which is about 11/8s more than Ludi seems to.

BB and Kdub are clear too.

Pretty sure they are both town at this point. You don't?

The difference is that we think Blackberry isn't recruiter based on his play, not on his claim.

HEY MODS: If someone was culted and killed the same night, would they die before they were culted, or after?

Reading is tech: #1720

^ why is kdub clear

Uncc'ed claim of the Peregrine kill => not recruiter

[hiplop]

highly doubting Subliminal is CR now :\

Really want Ludi dead still....

[Magister Ludi]

hiplop, don't get cold feet.