Open 329: Mayo Clinic D3: Town WINS!

[Thomith]

i said i wanted it before grey replaced in, so don't say everyone wanted in as it was only vitamin and glow, and even then i am not buying that glow actually cares about the plan.

[whispersilk]

After reading 9 pages of this shit, the plan better work. I'm on board.

[glowball]

You are right Thomith, I don't care about the plan I am just tired of talking about it so do whatever you guys need to do and I hope it works for you.

[Thomith]

So you aren't even going to answer the questions? glad you care that much about the game.

[glowball]

Ever heard of fight for what you believe in? if you don't like something why are you giving in that easily? Why do you see no good in the plan, what would you propose instead?

oh these questions, I thought they were rhetorical...

I did fight for what I believed in. I am not necessarily giving in I just don't want to talk about it anymore.

There is good in the plan, but it can also go wrong and I've already said what I propose: I PROPOSE YOU GUYS STOP LOOKING FOR AN EASY WAY OUT UNDER THE GUYS OF A PLAN THAT IS NOT FOOL PROOF AND IS ONLY SYSTEMATIC. IT DOES NOT INCREASE OUR ODDS. JUST SCUM HUNT AND STOP BEING LAZY.

[glowball]

DAMN IT!

I meant under the GUISE*** of a plan....blah blah blah

[glowball]

OMG ISO'd Thomith... in other news: YOU ARE SCUMZ.

I was so distracted and not even paying attention to you, hell I even enjoyed you for a moment there...

UNVOTE:
VOTE: Thomith

[Thomith]

Care to explain why i am scum?

[PiggyGal15]

Prod dodge. I still agree with the plan.

[BBmolla]

Alright so I think most people (except for Quar and Mega who only have one post, and Neil and Glowball) are on board.

How do we want to execute this? We just want to have vigs claim right now or does someone want to say something first?

[BBmolla]

I think the best way to go by doing this is to have EVERYONE either say:

I am a Vig

or

I am a Doctor

This way we can account for everyone.

At least one Vig should claim first imo. I don't want a Doctor to claim and then have people pussy out on the plan.

Thoughts?

[Thomith]

I like the claim doc or vig idea, although it is pretty obvious what the scum doc will claim but meh :/.

[GreyICE]

Popcorn style very solid.

I am a doctor

Popcorn to Neil1113

[BBmolla]

Popcorn style very solid.

I am a doctor

Popcorn to Neil1113

Oh, this works good too.

[Maruchan]

NEILS TURNNNN

[VitaminR]

I did fight for what I believed in. I am not necessarily giving in I just don't want to talk about it anymore.

There is good in the plan, but it can also go wrong and I've already said what I propose: I PROPOSE YOU GUYS STOP LOOKING FOR AN EASY WAY OUT UNDER THE GUYS OF A PLAN THAT IS NOT FOOL PROOF AND IS ONLY SYSTEMATIC. IT DOES NOT INCREASE OUR ODDS. JUST SCUM HUNT AND STOP BEING LAZY.

Glowball, for what it's worth, my initial reaction to the plan was very negative. I like to play games the way they were meant to be played, even if that can be difficult. One thing that swayed me is the fact that this set-up is pretty much going to turn into a killfest without some sort of plan like this and not like a game of careful scumhunting or anything. This plan maybe takes away a bit of good old-fashioned scumhunting, but it also keeps the game sane.

[Thomith]

adding to the above we still need to use a fair amount of scumhunting to find out people faking doctor or faking vig, now would you rather a likely 2-4 deaths a night and scumhunting completely or a more likely 0-4 deaths a night and use a little less scumhunting?

[izakthegoomba]

Why does neil have to go next? I thought he was against a massclaim.

[BBmolla]

Maybe we should start a second popcorn train to speed this up?

[neil1113]

I'm not claiming. And no, you will not force my hand. I'm sorry, but the way this plan has been sheeped, by either lazy town saying "Oh hey, this game is started! Yeah, I'm in!" Or by scum saying "Man this plan better work..." either way, I'm not going to cooperate with this plan and give scum and easy victory. I apologize if this does not fit your plans, but how about we just rely on what we know (scum hunting) and not what we don't know? Scum know who's town and who's scum, all they don't know is who has what powerrole. If we give them that information, we give them more power to do as they please. Knowledge = Power, especially in this game. The only reason I've refused to really lay out the details as to how this will backfire, is because you all seem to set on the plan, that it would do the town more damage to give the scum and the sk ideas, then it would to try and convince everyone that this plan is faulty. So no, you will not have a claim from me.

[BBmolla]

Okay, assume Neil is doc, I'll go next.

I am a Vig

[izakthegoomba]

Who after you?

[Maruchan]

I guess I am,

Doc here

izak u next bro

[izakthegoomba]

I'm a doc

I want glow to go next. Whether she actually will or not is another story.

[GreyICE]

vote: Neil1113

Pure fear mongering. What's scum going to do? Roleblock?

Town weapons are numbers and organization. Not secrecy and lies.