Brightest Day Mafia, Part 1 - GAME OVER

[zMuffinMan]

Dunno, was an assumption based on a few things (they weren't masons, they were lovers <- more limited, and double day mechanic, etc)

[Mr Subliminal]

Posting my thoughts constantly makes me anti-town vs. not-posting-at-all like some people? O_o

Didn't you say earlier that the CR wouldn't be a lurker, but an active poster? lol

So I'm gonna put this in large shiny text because you're all ignoring it.

BB SCUMSLIPPED

[vezokpiraka]

What?

I delayed Kast last night. There is no way I stole your powers.

[Oversoul]

Are we MCing our targets? Because I targeted Kast and tans last night.

Why are people eliminating others as CL based on the fact that they were RB'd? Does somebody know the number of recruits?

I'd like to MC, starting with WLC.

WHAT THE FUCK NIKANOR. Putting you and your claims into a box, in a closet, in a warehouse, far away from me.

Either way, this confirms that there is only 1 scum unless Nikanor is the scum.

I've made up my mind, for this first part of the day I am only lynching Blackberry or WLC unless someone has a damn good reason not to.

Mod, do masons have daytalk and do cult members have day talk?

I am posting this on all of my games. I am going to be V/LA until Tuesday (I said this earlier) so see you guys then.

[Mr Subliminal]

We've discussed, kind of.

One head thinks that Blackberry is an insufferable twit who can't seem to maintain the same thought process from one page to another and is an active detriment to the town...but is still town.

The other head thinks Blackberry is an insufferable twit who can't seem to maintain the same thought process from one page to another and is an active detriment to the town...and is actually scum.

Hydra dissonance is scummy.

It's gotten quite violent between the two heads. Things have been said that cannot be unsaid

lousy in bed

.

We like Kast's #1757, with one question:
Kast, you say you were tracked N1 (or that you tracked someone -- Blackberry? -- N1). I don't recall this; can you point it out to me where it was claimed?

Assuming Kast can come back with some claim, we don't like a vote for WLC because of nopointinactingup's push on him. Does not read like bussing. This head thinks Blackberry is town, so let the hydra infighting commence!

UNVOTE: Blackberry
VOTE: Candlejack

[hiplop]

VOTE: Zmuffinman

He was the one who "confirmed" Nopointinactingup. Also, he didn't claim when the mass white lantern PM went around. Nor has he done anything to confirm him as a a WL, I think hes the CR.

[Nikanor]

a) Friend was the one who confirmed npiau.
b) muffinz DID claim when the WL PM went around.

Anyway why aren't we MCing? idc who goes first.

[Mr Subliminal]

hiplop, we do not need you joining Blackberry in the list of people who don't bother to actually read the thread.

Nikan(d)or, I see little reason to mass claim at this point, given the small pool of potential cult recruiters. We do want Candlejack to claim, though.

[hiplop]

Nah, I do read the thread. Muffin was defending npiau pretty hard, he must have been. I wrote it down o_O. Perhaps I'm just going insane

[Nikanor]

CJ's probably mafia.
The only thing we learned from yesterday is that WLC is probnotcult. afaik the list of people who are not confirmed to not be the CR looks like this:
- Kast
- Candle Jack - probnotcult
- WeyounsLastClone - probnotcult
- Blackberry
- Mr. Subliminal
- ToastyToast - probnotcult
- vezokpiraka - probnotcult
- inHimshalibe - probnotcult
- Oversoul

Like honestly why are people eliminating Oversoul as possible CR again?

[Oversoul]

CJ's probably mafia.
The only thing we learned from yesterday is that WLC is probnotcult. afaik the list of people who are not confirmed to not be the CR looks like this:
- Kast
- Candle Jack - probnotcult
- WeyounsLastClone - probnotcult
- Blackberry
- Mr. Subliminal
- ToastyToast - probnotcult
- vezokpiraka - probnotcult
- inHimshalibe - probnotcult
- Oversoul

Like honestly why are people eliminating Oversoul as possible CR again?

Because I got delayed and then jailkept and a recruit already flipped? I am the only one who cannot be cult. And you and hiplop are lucky you guys are confirmed white lanterns because this lack of reading skill is annoying me.

gah. back to writing my papers

[Oversoul]

and I wouldn't mind to have a massclaim

[Mr Subliminal]

So, NOPOINT was cult-recruited.

*reads up on Nopoint to see if there's anyone he defended yesterday*

Weren't you under the impression that Cult couldn't recruit until N2?

wkrneofjwjqmodfkdm
In case anyone feels like actually reading my post.

[hiplop]

maruchan, its hard to remember EVERY little detail.

[Mr Subliminal]

Maruchan is not in this game.
hiplop, why are you still voting muffin? Were you Culted last night?

[hiplop]

Whoops, Multiple tabs are the devil

UNVOTE:

Not sure where to put my vote

No

[hiplop]

Oh actually: I meant OVERSOUL, not maruchan so

oversoul, its hard to remember EVERY little detail.

[Blackberry]

So, NOPOINT was cult-recruited.

*reads up on Nopoint to see if there's anyone he defended yesterday*

Weren't you under the impression that Cult couldn't recruit until N2?

wkrneofjwjqmodfkdm
In case anyone feels like actually reading my post.

A) You're a dumba$$
B) My original ASSUMPTION is they could recruit N1 and someone responded "How do you know" because in my mind Cult being able to recruit every night (and only one person) would be standard
C) Someone ELSE said last game they didn't do it until N2 last game and that I must be cult for assuming they could N1 (i.e., the cult said this)
D) THE FACT THAT A CULT RECRUIT IS DEAD WOULD IMPLY HE WAS RECRUITED N1 (this is why you're a dumba$$)

...

Posting my thoughts constantly makes me anti-town vs. not-posting-at-all like some people

Also, why the hell is that a scum-slip? I am saying it's ridiculous to think I'm anti-town because I post at all, when there are plenty of people not-posting who are more likely to be scum because they want to stay under the radar.

[The Book of Oa]

I've had a great deal of computer trouble lately. Should be over now.

Please note: No questions about the roles of dead players will be answered unless they are completely hypothetical.

[Blackberry]

I've had a great deal of computer trouble lately. Should be over now.

Please note: No questions about the roles of dead players will be answered unless they are completely hypothetical.

Yeah, I find the way Oversoul asked the question... dumb. I typically ask lots of questions but I know if I want to get a direct answer I ask hypothetical questions. The way Oversoul asked that question felt like "I'm mafia but I'll pretend I'm asking a question that I don't really care about." ... but that's just me, maybe Oversoul isn't used to asking the mod a question.

...

I want to lynch WLC after reading Friend. He seems very serious with his accusations. And seeing he flipped Watcher, I doubt he saw anything in particular but maybe he did and that is why he wanted to lynch WLC.

...

Also, after Muffin said something, it struck an idea, and I have come to a semi-odd conclusion. I am pretty sure there is a particular role that was used on me last night and if someone claims it I can pretty much confirm they are telling the truth due to, ummm, I'm not sure what the proper word is, but I have a strong feeling about something. However, I'm not really sure if it's a mafia role or a town role. Regardless, if it's claimed and claimed to be used on me, I can pretty much confirm it was used on me (though my method of confirmation is probably not fair/I should not know this).

=D

Also, I asked a question in private, I now know that this role was not specifically used on me, but was definetely used on someone else.

I might as well say it now, I'm pretty sure there is a Bus Driver (Redirector? But the redirector is already dead), and I know one of the two persons it was used on last night.

Also, I'm used to Bus Driver being mafia but after looking it up it says it's a common town role. And I think I remember reading this before too that it was a town role, but I'm always wary of this. Regardless, if someone does come forward as a Bus Driver and claims to have selected a specific person I can pretty much confirm they are telling the truth (at least in my mind, others might be wary of why I can confirm it but it makes perfect sense to me - I will explain further if it comes down to it).

...

Also, I kind of want to just go ahead and claim by the end of the day so everyone knows. Based on all the hints I've dropped, and the fact I earlier said that I've dropped hints, I feel as if mafia or cult could just ISO me and have a pretty good idea what I probably am.

But let's have the others claim first (preferably CJ and WLC I think).

[Mr Subliminal]

Like honestly why are people eliminating Oversoul as possible CR again?

He was delayed by vezokpiraka N1, we have an N1 recruit, etc.

Why are you saying CJ is probnotcult?

I (but not we) have a townread on ToastyToast and Blackberry. That leaves the pool down to Kast (who may have some track result that clears him?), Candlejack, or IHSIB, for my preferences. Of those, I favor Candlejack by far. We really don't see IHSIB-cult, though I could see IHSIB-mafia, so am very interested in your reasons against.

A) You're a dumba$$

You can say dumbass.

[Kast]

Mr. S, I tracked Tans night 1 and saw he targeted Andy. I soft claimed this fairly early Day 2. I also hid a hard breadcrumb to this effect in my first post of the game (this is Kast 2, my first post was my first post of D2). I also stupidly put my character name in the same post so I didn't want to point that out unless we were doing a name claim as well. I'll point it out if necessary.

[Kast]

BB, you're right; you are unlikely to be both CR

AND

also perma-block/stealer. This was NOT a requirement for being suspicious of you. there are tells indicating you are scum, some are mafia tells, and some are CR tells, but there are NO townie tells. Not sure why you bring that up as an objection when it is immaterial.

BTW, if you always play like XYZ style as town, and you are aware of this, then I don't see what is to stop you from playing in XYZ style as scum and trying to use that as meta proof that you are town. It could be valid if it was behavior you were UN-aware of, but if you're smart enough to recognize your play style, then I imagine you're smart enough to adapt. Though you are free to prove me wrong there...

Toast, yes I'm trying to be objective so I included myself. I assumed it was clear Day 2 why I trusted tans so strongly combining my soft bread crumbs and suspicion of Andy. As above post, I can further back up my claim with a hard breadcrumb as needed.

[Kast]

The only thing we learned from yesterday is that WLC is probnotcult.

Where did this come from?

[Magua]

I am blind. Please show me where you softclaimed your tracker result on tanstalus.

Also, remembering that I'm blind, please give your tracker result for N2.

Where did this come from?

nopointinactingup's pushing on WLC when it is known that NPIAU was already recruited at that point.