TV Mafia Game Over - Scum Win

[izakthegoomba]

Can't we just decide one way or the other? Either of them gives us info. Both of them tell us what to do next.

[Banshee]

@Rainbow:

It is currently impossible to get any reads on anyone with Castle Bravo interjecting his particular variety of chaos into the thread. He's derailed conversations over and over and has claimed scum repeatedly; I'm generally against policy lynches, but that HAS to be one if ever any are to be made.

He's already been proven wrong about Rodion (as have I) and he's still behaving as if he is infallible and throwing suspicion in all directions in ORDER to derail any coherent discussion.

He's claimed scum, he's not going to stop muddying the waters, so it's time for him to go.

[Banshee]

@Izak: Yes, let's lynch Castle Bravo. Shotty is tomorrow's lynch.

[David Xanatos]

Just to interject.. what're we going to do with Peregrine? Standard policy of if Shotty flips Role Cop as he claims, drop on Pere like the proverbial ton of bricks, or does anyone have a more subtle idea?

[izakthegoomba]

I don't care... I'll go along with a lynch on either of them. As I said already.

@DX subtlety is not always a virtue

[David Xanatos]

Depends entirely on what you're dealing with. I favour the direct approach here myself but I'm open to a whimsical plan of action from Rainbow on the matter.

[Mysterio]

Castle Derp today, drmyshottyisherp tomorrow; if town, peregrine; if scum, lol.

VOTE: Castle Bravo

[David Xanatos]

Looks like we're in agreement then.

VOTE: Castle Bravo

[David Xanatos]

Unofficial Day 5 Vote Count

Castle 7 - Vezok, FourseenCircumstance, MagnaofIllusion, Banshee, Jakalope, Mysterio, David Xanatos
Shotty 3 - Rainbow, Peregrine, Izak
Peregrine 3 - Shotty, Castle Bravo, ZeL1nK

Spoiler: Vote History:

Izak - Castle Bravo, Peregrine, Shotty
Vezok - Castle Bravo
Jakalope - Castle Bravo, Shotty, Castle Bravo
Rainbow - Shotty
Banshee - Shotty, Castle Bravo
Peregrine - Shotty
Shotty - Peregrine
Castle Bravo - Peregrine
FourseenCircumstance - Castle Bravo
MagnaofIllusion - Castle Bravo
ZeL1nK - Peregrine
Mysterio - Castle Bravo
David Xanatos - Castle Bravo

[Castle Bravo]

I wonder if MoI will have the balls to hammer today~

[TheJakalope]

Why don't you self Hammer?

[David Xanatos]

Because I get the feeling he's a counterattack role, and he can't counterattack himself..

[David Xanatos]

Well, that and the logistical problem of hammering yourself when you're not at L-1..

[Rainbowdash]

You instantly wavered away from CastleBravo after throwing down a half-hearted vote and tried to lynch Meran. Read yesterday again and tell me you didn't try to shift towards Meran as opposed to CB.

You reread yesterday and try and tell me that I was not saying "keep obviously town ponies off CB incase he is vengeful". Meran vote was to prove a point while not being on CB.

CastleBravo dies today. Because he's asking to and there are no Jesters. It's a big wall of WIFOM that you are biting like a Newb. Castle is more dangerous alive than Shotty is even if Shotty has ANY PR and Castle is a Goon.

When it turns out DMSIS is a bigger threat than CB, from the grave or not mocking will ensue. If my call that cult got two nights of recruiting and then is able to kill, AND that DMSIS is leader, AND that CB is a recruit. Oh you will be bombarded with so many mocking pony pictures you will not know whats going on.

I do NOT see CB being the type of pony that in a situation where a town PR is the only other lynch possibility at the time to suddenly claim that they are a goon and want to be lynched unless they benifit in some way. Either by saving a partner for a limited time, or by their lynch somehow damaging town.

Nuts to this. Im not moving.

Yes CB is going to flip some sort of non-town, but im not going to be a part of this crap when the right wagon is sitting over on DMSIS.

[David Xanatos]

Look at it this way.

If you move, we can make a non-useful, scummy player hammer. Then when CB flips Cultist, you can mock MoI, and we're lynching Shotty tomorrow.

Moving only makes your point get proven faster, no?

[ZeL1nK]

Someone put him at L-1 so I can be like POW MUDAFAKA.

[David Xanatos]

That's your cue I guess Rainbow.

[TheJakalope]

Unvote

ZeL1nK, Vote.

Then Rainbow.

I'll hammer.

[Rainbowdash]

Look at it this way.

If you move, we can make a non-useful, scummy player hammer. Then when CB flips Cultist, you can mock MoI, and we're lynching Shotty tomorrow.

Moving only makes your point get proven faster, no?

I think im right, so im not going to make the subpar move by lynching CB. The wagon on him is a complete cop-out. He is going to flip something weak. DMSIS is going to flip something good from the same faction. Then I will laugh and post mocking pony pictures.

No I am not voting him. Get somepony else to, im holding my ground.

[TheJakalope]

You're admitting to not voting someone you believe to be scum? I don't like Shotty either, but a Shotty lynch isn't going to help us. Can you help us lynch scum?

[TheJakalope]

EBWOP: *But a Shotty lynch isn't going to happen today

[ZeL1nK]

VOTE: Shotty

Apparently it's not cool to vote for bravo.

Still want bravo to tell me what oversoul posted in the QT bout his gambit.

[David Xanatos]

Suit yourself I suppose.

On the vague offchance Shotty is what he says he is, who're we having him target, if he's still around tonight?

Jaka, you should revote Bravo. You're not really one of the higher scumreads, there's no gain in having you hit a bomb, even if you are VT as you claim.

ZeL1nK, why do you want to be the hammer?

[Rainbowdash]

You're admitting to not voting someone you believe to be scum? I don't like Shotty either, but a Shotty lynch isn't going to help us. Can you help us lynch scum?

Yes I am not voting somepony who is going to flip non-town because I am voting somepony ELSE who is going to flip non-town.

I mean come ON everypony.

Even if you actually believe that DMSIS is a Role Cop. For WHATEVER reason your little pony minds think such, he still had a N0 action. Not only a N0 action but he is a rolecop that gets the ENTIRE role of anypony he checks, and also can catch SKs! Makes no sense for him to be town. None. Period.

He botched his claim #1 so he makes claim #2, AGAIN false. Why, he still has that N0 action he locked himself into. And the god tier overpoweredness. There. Is. No. Way.

NO WAY!

That DMSIS is town here. Given that, who is the threat? The pony who is doing everything possible to stay alive, or the pony who is trying to die? Im not voting CB. Line in the sand drawn. If im wrong, im wrong, but it should be quite obvious to even the Derpiest pony, that I am pretty sure that im right here.

[TheJakalope]

Scum won't hammer Bravo though. Especially if he actually is a bomb or other revenge role.

P-Edit. Rainbow. If you help lynch Bravo, I'll support you 100% in lynching DMSIS tomorrow.