TV Mafia Game Over - Scum Win

[Mysterio]

Rodion just derailed a claimed scum wagon... because he thinks it's premature? Looking back at what happened before I replaced in, I see a lynch on a JK Day 1 (no big deal at all), a lynch on scum Day 2 and a lynch on more scum Day 3. We now have a sizeable wagon on a claimed scum with Shotty as a candidate for hammer if it turns out that Castle Bravo is a bomb of some kind, but Rodion wants to put it off so I can post something? Seems silly and somewhat scummy.

The fact that I placed an immediate vote on Oversoul in my second post since replacing in should show one of two things:

1. I'm town.

2. I don't give a crap about bussing fellow scum.

Either way, town benefits. Castle Bravo is an obvious lynch. You can worry about me when you don't have a clear scum target.

[izakthegoomba]

Mysterio is entirely right. There is nothing wrong with the speed, size, or intentions of the wagon, and Rodion just pinged m Scumdar™.

[David Xanatos]

Rodion's CT. Your Scumdar is broken.

[Banshee]

No. Rodion is confirmed not to have a weapon.
He could be Mafia doctor, SK, or some other third party.

It's just not LIKELY, but don't call him conftown just yet.

[TheJakalope]

Damn, guys, CB needs to get lynched.

VOTE: CastleBravo

[jasonT1981]

Day 4 Vote count 2

Castle 8 - Mysterio, MOI, Fourseen, Vezo,THAdmiral, ,Nero,Jester,TheJakalope (L-3)
Shotty 1 - Mera
Mera 1 - Rainbow
Fourseen 1 - Banshee
Rodion 1 - Castle

Not voting

PeregrineV,drmyshottyizsik,ZeL1nK,Junpei,silverbullet999,Izak,Rodion,DavidX

With 20 alive it takes 11 to lynch

[David Xanatos]

SK is unlikely to have been blocked /at least/ two night in a row. Mafia Doctor is unlikely in my eyes.. mainly through the fact we seem to be light on killing roles, which I'm taking from the fact there's only one kill that doesn't fit into either Lynch or Mafia kill.. therefore there's not likely to be a Mafia Doc. Therefore, he's as close to CT as we have right now, and I call a spade a spade.

[Nero Cain]

Lets get two more votes on Bravo. Wait for Jun's track and Sotty to hammer. If anyone hammers before he does they're scum anyways.

[MagnaofIllusion]

No. Rodion is confirmed not to have a weapon.
He could be Mafia doctor, SK, or some other third party.

Mafia Doctors have guns ...

[Nero Cain]

all mafia have weapons I think.

[drmyshottyizsik]

all mafia have weapons I think.

Not true, in a lot of games only one scum will have the power to kill.

[Banshee]

The Gunsmith is an information role that can target a player at Night to learn if they have a gun in flavor. Members of the Mafia

(that are not Doctors)

, Cops, FBI Agents, Vigilantes, other Gunsmiths, Paranoid Gun Owners, etc. all have guns in traditional flavor. Notably, Serial Killers and Doctors do not have guns.

This should not be construed to mean that I think Rodion is a Mafia doctor. I think he's probably town and that I was wrong. But he's not CONFIRMED town, nor are any of the others until Shotty flips town or scum imo.

[David Xanatos]

Even Shotty hasn't confirmed anyone. He's stated roles, not alignments. Vanilla could be Goon for example, since they're functionally the same, just on different sides..

[David Xanatos]

Magna > Did Chk confirm anyone else? If so, don't tell us who, but if it's a guilty, we do rather need to know. If there's an innocent, it's your call whether to tell us.

[drmyshottyizsik]

Even Shotty hasn't confirmed anyone. He's stated roles, not alignments. Vanilla could be Goon for example, since they're functionally the same, just on different sides..

..... The role I got back was Vanilla Townie

[killerjester]

Since this is a theme game, it's reasonable to believe DMSIS got back the full role name of his investigations.

We still need some people to get in here before we hammer CB. For instance, Junpei and his tracker result.

[Castle Bravo]

Told ya they don't believe in godfathers rod.

Moi practically fellated lc for the innocent back in super.

[Banshee]

@Mod: Can we have a prod on Junpei please?

I know it hasn't been all that long, but we need his results.

Thanks!

[Rodion]

Questions to

everyone

:

1 - Do you believe Shotty's claim?
2 - Do you think Castle Bravo should already have been lynched by now and the derailing of his wagon that just took place is negative?

A simple yes or no will suffice, but feel free to elaborate if you want to. Please answer both questions;

[David Xanatos]

1: No. I don't completely disbelieve it.. I think it's a failed gambit he's clawing desperately at.
2: To an extent, yes, but I see the merit in getting the Tracker information and potentially a Guilty from Chkballin's role.

[Rodion]

Let me ammend question #1: if you partially believe in Shotty's claim, please specify what you believe and what you don't.

[David Xanatos]

I'm still thinking about that.. I have a few thoughts but I want to ISO him again before I put it down. I'd rather take the time than look like an idiot..

[Nero Cain]

Questions to

everyone

:

1 - Do you believe Shotty's claim?
2 - Do you think Castle Bravo should already have been lynched by now and the derailing of his wagon that just took place is negative?

A simple yes or no will suffice, but feel free to elaborate if you want to. Please answer both questions;

1.no
2.yes , I think he should have been lynched already.

1: No. I don't completely disbelieve it.. I think it's a failed gambit he's clawing desperately at.
2: To an extent, yes,

but I see the merit in getting the Tracker information and potentially a Guilty from Chkballin's role

.

If Chk had found a gun on any of his targets MOI would have said something.

[Rainbowdash]

@mod

- Are andrew and oversoul from the same faction? One is called scum and one mafia but they are same color flip.

1 - Do you believe Shotty's claim?
2 - Do you think Castle Bravo should already have been lynched by now and the derailing of his wagon that just took place is negative?

1 - Not at this point.
2 - No. Junpei (who is quickly starting to go up the needs to be lynched list) needs to give track results. Also we need to have a specific pony hammer CB.

For other things.

Meransial is scum with Oversoul. This comes through interactions being limited entirely to

Meransiel - nothing from him for quite a while. Null. Prod dodges. Gives no reason for inactivity. Yay... Doesn't seem to actually want to participate in this game and instead says, tell me when I am tunnelled so I am forced to defend myself. Mersan seems lazy and the conversation between him and Junpei looks like TvT

Currently Oversoul and Silver are on Pine. Dunno about oversoul, don't really care right now. But I think silver is scummy so my theory works. I don't like the wagon on Leon, because as I said I ISO'd him and found nothing wrong. Wait, Oversoul for prod? Oh, he must've just parked his vote. Maybe they're both scum.

Very nice little stance of oversoul being off, but somepony else being more scummy then him for doing the same thing. Same pony that all flipped scum have been trying to lynch since the start of this game.

Ok so Oversoul back with the big guns after a well deserved prod. Let's see what he says. Hmm...his reads are mostly null or town. Though I like the fact that he's voting silver. Null slightly leaning town.

Remember that post that was really scummy from Oversoul? Yeah Meran is using it as a town tell here. Next you hear of him he is voting after the claim.

Junepi should be looked at sometime soon too. He is probably a tracker but easily could be a scum one at this point. If Meran is town, that rockets Jun up the lynch list.

Vezokpiraka has recently joined the ranks of solid town with her last few posts. Rodin is obviously in as well.

@Nieghbors - Who suggested a Rodin investigation?

[Rainbowdash]

Geez, if I didn't know you were town that'd be scummy.

I c what u did thar.

Ok this will sound VERY HYPOCRITICAL coming from me but can we stop with the fucking gambits?

This needs to be explained too. Like how it is hypocrital to Meran who I can't understand how they are running a gambit here.