Open 317 Masons & Monks (Game Over) Finished: September 8

[Scott Brosius]

Chevre obv for completely making up reads.

[DeityKabuto]

Chevre obv for completely making up reads.

Chevre is gone, use the format, please and provide more reasoning.

[Thor665]

Who do i want to lynch - Descent

Why? - for being Chevre (replacement does not change a slot's scumminess) Also, for making up reads *exactly* like Chevre did which is why I wanted to lynch Chevre in the first place. Also, PoE

Also would be happy lynching Scott.
Also feel I have said this all before.
Also hate deadline extension because of everyone being a lurk sack.
Also, love DK realizing we need movement after he's been kvetching about me trying to get movement for two weeks straight.
Also hate Cirno going useless and making me doubt my awesome town read of her out of annoyed frustration with all the uselessocity in this game.
Also, love replacements who immediately sheep me.
Also have a beard.

[Mist7676]

Shion Sonozaki has been replaced by zMuffinMan

[zMuffinMan]

Hi. 42 pages. Be back later.

[Thor665]

Hey, Muffin, when you catch up remember to sheep me for more awesome awesomeness.

[zMuffinMan]

OK, will do. I'm slowly getting through this.

Feel free to give me a summary of who's scum and why.

[Thor665]

Here
s the summary;

You, Guido, and DK have all claimed Monk or Mason, so you're not being lynched and we're testing how dumb the mafia/werewolf players are.
Cirno is prob. town, shes working hard to mess with it, but is still prob town for actually doing more scumhunting than about 2/3rds of the rest of town combined.
I'm obv. town (as always)

That leaves cjdrum (who has been called scum via derptitude...I'm neutral on that tell currently)
Yank - who is kinda opportunistic, but has scumhunted some and did have a defense period where he protected Guido so I'm not totally sold on lynching.
Than there's Scott, who has been useless, and Descent who (along with predecessor Chevre) has actually managed to be more useless than Scott (we're not sure how, but they did do this)

With a solid presumption of 3 scum available within four slots with one possible wildcard amongst the claimed - I am strongly in favor of lynching either Scott of Descent

Descent was "caught" because *both* he and Chevre have made a Werewolf suspect list containing both claimed Monks - this is suspect because...duh, someone's not reading, and to have someone else duplicate it sounds like scum just repeating the slot's previous suspects and hoping no one notices. Super gakky. Best defense is...can scum really be this bad? (yes, they can...but...)

Scott is top suspect because, and I hate to use this tell, he's better than this. He has been derping up a storm, has basically played the old "don't care about this game...but won't replace out" card, and is otherwise being generally unhelpful to town in a way that feels intentionally standoffish and stonewalling.

One of them should die and then we should sort over the remaining bodies in the morning and reassess reads.

[zMuffinMan]

Oh, right. Guido is a hydra. I was reading over the quicktopic trying to figure out why a former-me was talking to a guido A and a guido B. Makes sense now.

Yea, it'll be a long day.

So many terrorists pushing on my case.

I could spend all day reading up on games with DK in them.

Anyway,

I'm like 3/4 of the way through. Your beard looks sheepable.

Is there going to be a deadline extension or am I in a rush to finish this read-through immediately?

[zMuffinMan]

Wait, nm, just checked the previous page. I get a week. Cool. Finishing this after sleep.

[Mist7676]

Nope it's tommrow...

[Thor665]

That's not what the title says...

[Cirno]

Well, i said I'd change my vote to get a lynch so here it is.

VOTE: Descent

[Mist7676]

Well good night all! Only 1 daY ahead of schedule!

Vote Count:
Thor - 1 - (DeityKabuto) (L-4)
zMuffinMan - 1 - (YankCane151) (L-4)
Descent - 5 - (Guido Crescendo, Thor, Scott Brosius, cjdrum, Cirno) (L-0)

Not Voting: zMuffinMan, Descent
Descent has been lynched.

[Mist7676]

Mist walks back in to the tent to see many people she didn't recognize. "Do I know you"
"Yes I'm zMuffinMan I've been with you for 4 years!"
"No Shion was... I'm going to go check the records." Mist checks the records and sees everything in black-and-white. "Well look at that he was here for 4 years.

When Mist gets back to the group to see Cirno harrasing Descent (another unfamiliar face. What's going on here?!?) and forcing him to scream, "FINE I ADMIT I'M MAFIA JUST KILL ME NOW!! Descent runs up the ladder with the speed of a cheeta but is about to jump off when he sees the reality. Cirno climbs up ready to push him off when he goes, "No I lied I'm not mafia! It was the heat of the moment!"
"LIAR!!!" and Cirno pushes him off.

When the blood splatters everyone runs to loot the body. 13¢, his liscense, and cross.

"Guys I was trying to tell you I'm doing backround checks. Descent hasn't done anything wrong!

Descent (Vanilla Townie has been thrown off the highdive Day 2)

[Mist7676]

DEADLINE HAS BEEN EXTENDED 24 HOURS!

[Mist7676]

Andrew94 has replaced YankCane151 and deadline is tommrow at 5PM CST.

[Mist7676]

"Hey sorry I'm lat- WHAT HAPPENED?!?"
"Th-th-they killed Thor!!" andrew94 came out crying.
"OMG!! Umm who are you again?"
There was bite marks all around him.
"So this one was obviously killed by the werewolfs." Mist thought.
"But look at his head!" Spoke up Guido.
A bullet mark.

Double killed?

"We already checked his pockets nothing but a hammer m'am."
"Maybe he's mafia. Why would he have a hammer."
"But there isn't blood on it, just soot. Like it was struck by lightning.

Thor, Vanilla Townie killed Night 2 by Mafia/Werewolf.

[Scott Brosius]

There's no reason for the living monks/masons to alive unless most of them are scum.

[andrew94]

hi guys me reading

[Cirno]

Okay, I'm gonna go v/la tomorrow night but I'll be around until then. Here are my thoughts on the game.

Concerning The Remaining Werewolf
1.Start with the remaining players
2.Subtract those that cannot be werewolves (muffin,guido)
3.Subtract those parking their votes in the middle of nowhere (DK,Yank)
4.Subtract myself

The remaining werewolf is Scott or cjdrum.

Concerning The Mafia
1. I agree with Scott that one of the Monks is mafia, so Muffin OR Guido is mafia.
2.DK cannot be mafia and I think yank (now andrew) is town.
3. Subtract myself

Mafia is Muffin OR Guido + cjdrum OR Scott.

Which means both cjdrum AND Scott are scum, so I'm willing to lynch either of them.

Discuss.

>disconnected 3 times while trying to post this.

[Scott Brosius]

Parking votes in the middle of nowhere should not be a reason for clearing Yank/DK. If anything that's a scumtell for avoiding major wagons in an attempt to skate by. But leaning towards null.

Muffin as scum would have no reason to out himself earlier in the game as monk after Guido claimed. It puts a target on your back for the other scum team to kill you. It has to be Guido. Given that he has been floating in this game especially after the wagon disintegrated D1.

In terms of actual gameplay, cjdrum was next on my list after Chevre.

Not really sure why you are clearing andrew. Can you explain that?

Your analysis is fine, and replacing myself in for you leaves me with you cjdrum and andrew. Given my earlier scumread on cjdrum, that's where my vote is. Guido also needs to die though.

Vote: cjdrum

[DeityKabuto]

YOU GUYS ARE FUCKING ASSES NOBODY EVER LISTENS.

I should be cleared for this, so I am leading the fucking lynch, NOBODY ELSE will lead another ML.

We lynch Scott, mainly for being on everyone ML wagon.

Vote Scott

[Scott Brosius]

That's your entire case?

Guido and cjdrum have also been on both wagons.....

[DeityKabuto]

I don't care what order, all of you are going to die one or another.

Nobody but me is leading today's lynch.