blindfaeth wrote:I don't know, but I have a hard time believing that Thor is wrong about both Ray AND I. I mean, come on, draw a name out of the hat of 11 players that aren't you and you have almost a 50/50 chance of picking a baddie lol.
I'm so confused here, are you saying he's NOT wrong about you?
Or are you making some sort of weird case that Thor is scum because he's wrong twice?
Well if you are bad, you are already WIFOMing the crap out of us. I was being kinda sarcastic but like I said I wouldn't be surprised.
Don't throw out accusations if you're not willing to stand by them.
Basically I was WIFOMing lol. I know it doesn't mean anything to everyone else. But in my thinking, the only two people Thor have REALLY been suspicious of are Ray and myself. He was wrong about Ray, and he's wrong about me. I just find it hard to believe with his experience and play style that both of his main suspicions are incorrect. (Note that if you are on a scum team your chance of hunting someone from the other team narrows. For example, suspicions aside if he's town just picking someone at random. He's one of the 10 remaining so 5/9 chance of picking scum. If he's a werewolf he won't pursue the lynch of his buddy so he has a 3/8 chance (3 mafia, 10 townies - himself & teammate), and as a mafia 2/7 chance (2 werewolves, 10 townies - himself & 2 teammates).
I'm not sure what you're getting at here, though.
If you mean he's deliberately targeting townies: why? We're in multiscum, he'd have a whole other scum team to hunt.
If you mean he's mistakenly targeting townies: being wrong is not a scumtell. It's even less of a scumtell if you agree with his case against Ray, which you presumably did since you yourself were on the wagon.
Also I think he was trying too hard to set himself up to be suspicious of me/pursue my lynch in Day 2 during Day 1 - regardless of how Ray flipped :p
Finding you suspicious Day 1 and voting you Day 2 isn't a scumtell, it's consistency. :P
Sky wrote:The odds are true. We must lynch someone on the wagon today. And it's not because I wasn't on that wagon.
Eh. While it is more likely that there are scum on the wagon than off, that is only because the wagon is the bigger group. This doesn't in itself increase the odds of any given person on the wagon of being scum; statistically that's a 50% chance for each person either way.
If you think their reasons for being on the wagon are suspect that's one thing, but approaching the problem mathematically is the wrong way to go.
whispersilk wrote:lol, have to laugh at this now considering the town I live in was in a state of mass rioting, arson and looting over the entire weekend.
<3
Ouch, my condolences; hope life stabilizes for you :(
DeityKabuto wrote:Back in Day 1, I had Thor as Null-scum, and now I've moved it to Leaning-Scum because of Ray's flip, which should have been pretty obvious to everyone.
Seriously? If you thought Ray's flip should have been obvious, why did you hammer him?
DeityKabuto wrote:I can see where Thor is going with blindfaeth, another ML.
Why are you so certain the blindfaeth is town?
Thoughts:
I like CMPunk's recent posts; we seem to be in agreement here. DK's stance is pretty scummy (519 is particularily bad). Not liking blind here either though, as noted above. Thor still reads as town to me; I'd be interested in a case that's more fleshed out than 'you were wrong'.
VOTE: blindfaeth
