Um...why is oversoul voting Toast? Nik already pointed out the directed kill strategy.
CJ, Andrius and Vezok seem the most likely mafia (likely others as well). Unless I miss read something (false humility), vezok claimed day 1 that he is JL, and that Nik and company were lying about being JL. Link to post
442 as reference. That, combined with claiming to become a WL by buddying up to hiplop and using "role" info that hiplop announced to gain town cred, make him a likely scum player.
Andrius also rubs me with a scum feel due to the tone of some of his Day 1 posts. Both posts include statements that come from a uniquely scum=mafia perspective. Link to posts
519, complains about mod making the game unbalanced against scum, and
542, concludes that cult team can screw over mafia team, thus concluding that scum are screwed if culted (when in fact only *mafia* would be screwed, while cult would be doing really well). Either case, both posts draw conclusions that come from a largely scum perspective (also, he talks WAY too much).