Kast wrote:With Toog lynched, I'm keeping my vote where it is.
@Ooba-
This was ridiculous. There's no need to invent a BS reason to justify voting Toog. The claimed guilty is the reason for lynching him. Also, your flavor chronology is screwed up and indicates you have not actually read the comics but instead are just quoting bits and pieces from a wiki (or whatever source). Ganthet became a Deputy Green Lantern at the same time that Luthor became a Deputy Orange Lantern.
More than that though, the Mod took liberties flavor in BNM and has said he may do the same in BDM. Flavor CAN be helpful, but this was not an example of that.
@Tans-
Does your PM mention of Luthor include anything that identifies or hints at Luthor
as town
, or is that just a conclusion you are drawing?
The flavor of Luthor's as a villain AND his betrayal of his mission support him as prob-scum. The Governor claim asks to be tested (and Ooba's claim to be town but to be unwilling to Governor himself is WTF?!?). But trumping both of those is that his play itself strongly suggests he is playing as scum.
And this is getting to outguessing the mods, but I think his posted choice submission speculation for game setup has a good chance at being correct and I would expect Dana to give Ooba Luthor/SK/Independent given his post guessing about Luthor
.
I could see Tans as town with Ooba as scum (of some sort). I could also see a Larfleeze/Luthor pair as two third party roles (potentially not on the same team as each other).
@Mastin-
Your softclaim as
X
of
X
and
Y
STRONGLY suggests who you and
Y
are
AND
STRONGLY suggests that
Y
is a role that probably does not want to reveal herself. But it looks much more like a town-town pair than the Oranges.
So let's analyze this
- There is no reason for me (as scum) to invent a BS reason to vote Toog when I could have just sheeped the rest into voting for the guilty. Absence of any scum motivation for pointing out that his claim didn't fit the {white,tans-me} claims points to me doing exactly what I said I was - pointing out discrepencies as town.
- Maybe you should actually go back and read the flavor Toog claimed (the reason why I asked him for it) and the comics again:
-- Ganthet was only a deputy GL at the end of Blackest night
-- Ganthet only resigned as a Guardian and became a full-time GL only at the start of Brightest day
http://greenlantern.wikia.com/wiki/Ganthet
- I was unwilling to waste a lynch on myself. What do you think would have happened?
-- I use the governor on me. Town lynches me. I survive. Second lynch also on me. Bam - two lynches wasted and one town player down. Clearly, I was going to be lynched and didn't see why I had to waste another lynch.
Anyway - Mod has confirmed that I cannot use it on myself.
Also - I don't see the point in wasting a lynch just to confirm myself. If the exact power transfers - tans should be able to confirm it's a Governor.
Am I cult?
No. I am not going to come out of the gates cult hunting as cult. Lying low or just general scum hunting (i.e my regular play as Mafia) would have carried me through most of the game without getting lynched.
Am I scum?
No. One, I have tans vouching for me. Two, the brokeness of the Janitor+Governor combo should be apparent.
Am I third-party?
If I was third party like Tans last time, the mods would have given me a fakeclaim. (Tans had "Sodam Yat" last game)
