Mini 1186: Repo! The Genetic Mafia - Game Over!

[camn]

Yosarian OR Incognito.
Pine OR haylen.

Why?
If only I knew.

[Medicated Lain]

You really don't think it's possible for both Yos and Incog to be town?

[Incognito]

@incog: I voted for you because it was an option.

...that doesn't answer my question at all. Everyone in this game was also an option but you didn't vote any of them. You're now claiming that you saw something in-thread that made you think Yos2 had inside knowledge that led him to believe I was town but yet you still voted me. You had nothing like that with anyone else apparently. So why?



Camn, that's not a case - it's more common sense.

[Medicated Lain]

It is an answer. Voting anyone else wouldn't have had enough weight to shift anything. I tried voting around/throwing ideas around a bit, and nothing conjures up anything. We have an extremely bad case of lazy town going on! So Incog, who are your eyes set on as scum?
I do think there is something to be said that I guess Yos could be scum, and Incog not... but it just seems so highly unlikely that Yos would make such a heavy case in favor of a player whom has a fairly large portion of the town suspecting them. What do others think about this?

[camn]

I think it is totally possible they are both on the same team... I just am not getting overwhelming townvibes from incog.
I am willing to peruse some Pine-replacement and /or Haylen hate, though.

Overall I am very unhappy in this game. It is so disjointed, and I have crap for reads on anyone.. So wtf.

[Medicated Lain]

unvote, vote: haylen

The logic there doesn't make sense anyway. Bvoigt seems town to me. So let's see what happens.

[Thor665]

Though if you want to speed lynch camn I'm game.

Pro town how?

Explain the last pro town thing you did which will make this desire look silly.
I'll wait.

Thor, I don't understand your sayings. You are voting for trip, yet you think it is scummy if I pull the trigger on him, because you don't think he is scummy, yet you are voting for him?

You don't understand what I said.
Please quote where I said it would be scummy for you to pull the trigger on him. When you fail to find that you'll realize you didn't read what I said very well.

@TMW - also PoE and ennui.

What's ennui?

Google is your friend;

a feeling of utter weariness and discontent resulting from satiety or lack of interest; boredom: The endless lecture produced an unbearable ennui.

Now - do anything pro-town, or replace out (unless you're scum - because in that case you're playing perfectly)

Consider me 50% on that camn wagon too.
Haylen wagon suxx0rs though - it should die.

[camn]

There is a Haylen wagon?

[Thor665]

There's a vote on Haylen, ergo there is a wagon there.
It should die.
You should try to look pro town in any way whatsoever.

[camn]

Why, exactly?

[Thor665]

Good point.

Unvote: TripMyWire
Vote: Camn

Though if your reply was as regards the Haylen wagon - because Haylen is town and I'm voting you for not clarifying your responses.
If it's as regards why you should do stuff to be pro-town, my vote is my answer.

[camn]

You said I should try and LOOK pro town.
To avoid your vote? I think not.

I play as transparently as possible, and as pro town as I know how/ have the energy for. How I LOOK is, and always has been a secondary concern.

Do you have a case of any kind?

[bvoigt]

@incog: I voted for you because it was an option.

The fact is, I do think that one of either incog or camn is probably scum. I would be down with lynching either or right now. Trip is going up and up on this list, because

I'm just not seeing any real motives behind ideas

... but this is more as ineffective town, rather than scummy actions... given that we are day three, we need to be taking lynches seriously. I do also agree that pine is incredibly scummy. I would prefer over anyone, to lynch in that direction, I think there's a high chance of hitting scum, but no one else seems to agree.

So... @town. Top 3 candidates, and why?

What do you mean by the bolded? My top 2 are still Trip and Pine, but I'm not really sure about the 3rd. Yosarian, maybe.

[Thor665]

@Camn - so you admit you look scummy? What more of a case do I need?

[camn]

I dont look at me. From my POV I am as town as the day is long.

Despite my own personal inability to put cases together.. I hear they are generally pro-town. Looking back at my mislynch, it benefits the town to see your reasoning. Is it authentic? Is it crap? Just voting me FFS, that doesn't help anyone at all.

But keep it up, nothing else is happening. I meant to reread today, but I fell asleep instead, on page 2.

[Thor665]

Yeah, let's lynch camn.
Speed wagon is go!

[camn]

How about Haylen instead?
I don't get why you are against the 'wagon'.

Plus, a Haylen-wagon would guarantee that Haylens activity level quintupled.

[Yosarian2]

Ok, back from V/LA.

Perhaps so, Yos, but if I had voted Trip yesterday and hadn't been killed during the night, I would have been attacked for participating in a lynch that I don't believe in. Which could have potentially lost the town 3 townies if Trip isn't scum.

That's terrible reasoning, Haylen. If you're town, and you have a choice, then take the the pro-town option and be prepared to explain the next day why it was the pro-town thing to do in that situation if you get attacked for it.

Between "lynching someone you're not sure is scum" and "allowing a no-lynch to happen", lynching is the pro-town choice, no-lynching is the pro-scum choice. You made the pro-scum choice. Why? Because you didn't want to look bad? That's a scummy reason for making a scummy choice.

[Yosarian2]

I don't mind if someone refuses to claim; there are times that's the pro-town thing to do. However, that does mean that that we have to judge Camn's alignment based strictly on her posts. And this:

Yosarian OR Incognito.
Pine OR haylen.

is a scummy post.

[Thor665]

Hey yos, when you call her scummy and someone as dashing and handsome as me is voting her you're supposed to help by voting her too.

@Camn - Haylen looked really town on my read through bad play =/= scummy play, sadly enough.

[camn]

your face is scummy

I agree that some of Haylen's posts were great.. but she is just so absent, it makes me suspicious. Usually she has a pretty high profile as town. I understand she might be busy though? I STILL figure she would be a better lynch than me. But not as good as INCOG.

Lets do this, Thor: SHow me a pro-town thing INCOG has done, can you? The question you ask of me, I ask you it re: 'COG
Lets get our egos out of the mix.

[Thor665]

Yos is stridently against the Incog lynch.
I think Yos is town.
I'm giving him benefit of the doubt on the read.

[camn]

Last game I was in Yos had a couple very critical misreads (sorry, Yos!).
So I am not similarly inclined.

Anything that Incog has done himself?

[Thor665]

Nope, if you recall the long ago times of last day phase I specifically came in and wanted to lynch Incog, and Yos argued with me, and I settled for a Trip lynch.

[InflatablePie]

D3 VC #4 - The On My Own Votecount (... wait...)

[3] Incognito - Pine, TripMyWire, camn
[2] TripMyWire - bvoigt, Yosarian2
[2] camn - Incognito, Thor665
[1] bvoigt - Haylen
[1] Haylen - Medicated Lain

With 9 alive, it takes 5 to lynch or No Lynch.
Deadline is Friday, August 12th, at 1PM EST.
Please point out any votecount mistakes.